NFL Would You Rather

[G-men]

Post two players and ask who you would rather have on your team. Can be current players, past players, or even college players for the hell of it.

Adrian Peterson or Chris Johnson

 

[ThunderHorse]

Adrian Peterson

All the explosiveness of Johnson + the ability to get Tough Yards. Fumbling doesn't seem to be so much an issue anymore either.

Steve Smith or Reggie Wayne? (in their respective primes)

EDIT -

Since this apparently pisses some people off (lol).

Let's rub some fucking salt into the wound

I also want Adrian Peterson because he's not a fucking goon. The kid plays like one, has all the edge that a real Nigga needs, but off the field I know I wouldn't have to worry about stupid, petty shit.

CJ2K on the other hand (just see the stupid ass nick name for further evidence) is a fucking character. if he isn't bitching about his nick name, he's bitching about being the MVP/ROTY (or, more specifically, NOT being the MVP or ROTY), bitching about teams like Baltimore supposedly purposefully injuring him in the playoffs (Yea.... Right.... Bitch.. Run faster next time), the guy even said he wants that fucking joke Vince Young back in Tennessee.

In the end it comes down to this.

I want a guy who's coming in to work

AP comes to work baby and work is what the man does

CJ comes to put on a show, run real fast, then bitch when shit doesn't fall his way like a 5 year old. I'll be surprised to see Johnson finish his Career in Tennessee truthfully.

Maybe he'll hit 2K5 next year? It's funny, because I hear AP talking about trying to get to the superbowl, and I hear CJ talking about EA Sports Madden NFL Rushing Statistics.

 

[j.hen]

CJ2K > AD

 

[Nucking Futs]

Reggie Wayne - Both guys are great players but I've been a bigger Wayne fan than Smith. Also, Wayne with a small height advantage.

Wes Welker or Percy Harvin

 

[ThunderHorse]

Reggie Wayne - Both guys are great players but I've been a bigger Wayne fan than Smith. Also, Wayne with a small height advantage.

Wes Welker or Percy Harvin

This is a good one I like this one.

I go Percy because Percy in New England would be fucking ugly.

It's already ugly with a 5' nothing white guy who's quick as shit, finna be stupid ugly with a strong ass Black Man who's just as quick but can outrun a fucking lion.

Josh Freeman or Sam Bradford?

 

[EmpireWF]

Wes Welker. He can stay on the field more and he's a hard nosed player who can produce over 8 catches a game. Consistent as fuck.

Harvin may be explosive but it seems he's more of an all or nothing cat plus his migraine issues aren't going away.

Steve Smith (NYG) or Steve Smith (CAR)?

 

[ThunderHorse]

Wes Welker. He can stay on the field more and he's a hard nosed player who can produce over 8 catches a game. Consistent as fuck.

Harvin may be explosive but it seems he's more of an all or nothing cat plus his migraine issues aren't going away.

Steve Smith (NYG) or Steve Smith (CAR)?

Forgot about those fucking Migraines.

I'm sure we'll be hearing about those much more often these next few years.

 

[Nucking Futs]

Stevie Smith (CAR)- easily. Guy is a workhorse and he's the type of player you want around other players.



Nnamdi Asomugha or Darrelle Revis?

 

[PEYMAN18]

Asomugha

Nobody even tries to throw it to him.


Julius Peppers or Dwight Freeney?

 

[G-men]

Freeney just because he never seems to have a down year

Andrew Luck or Tony Romo (to start an NFL game today)

 

[Nukleopatra]

Andrew Luck.

Kurt Warner or Sam Bradford.

 

[St. Francisco]

I'd take Warner if I get him in the early years of his career...if not, Bradford.

Terrell Owens (in his prime) or Randy Moss (in his prime)?

 

[G-men]

Andrew Luck.

Kurt Warner or Sam Bradford.

im assuming you me when Warner was younger, so ill go with Warner.

Brandon Jacobs or Ahmad Bradshaw

 

[Nucking Futs]

Ahmad Bradshaw - I can't stand players that like to bitch and complain and even tho Jacobs is a huge guy, I like Bradshaw's abilities better.




Emmitt Smith or Barry Sanders?

 

[Berowsk]

I'd take Warner if I get him in the early years of his career...if not, Bradford.

Terrell Owens (in his prime) or Randy Moss (in his prime)?

Randy Moss, hands down.

im assuming you me when Warner was younger, so ill go with Warner.

Brandon Jacobs or Ahmad Bradshaw

Brandon Jacobs. He's just massive.

Mike Vick of the season before last or Redskin's McNabb of last season?

 

[Bear Pand]

Mike Vick of the season before last or Redskin's McNabb of last season?

Vick. With Vick coming out of prison he was sort of unknown so at least there was a chance he'd surprise and play well. You already know with McNabb you're just getting mediocrity.

Would you rather have Kyle Orton QB your team or Peyton Hillis at starting RB?

 

[Obst]

Vick. With Vick coming out of prison he was sort of unknown so at least there was a chance he'd surprise and play well. You already know with McNabb you're just getting mediocrity.

Would you rather have Kyle Orton QB your team or Peyton Hillis at starting RB?

Peyton Hillis.

Ray Lewis or Patrick Willis

 

[Nukleopatra]

Peyton Hillis.

Ray Lewis or Patrick Willis

Patrick Willis.

Obst, Ryan Kerrigan or Corey LiuFaggot.

 

[Obst]

Patrick Willis.

Obst, Ryan Kerrigan or Corey LiuFaggot.

Kerrigan. LiuFaggot will be forgotten in a couple of years, if Kerrigan can get on a good team like the Patriots, maybe he will be decent and make a play once in a while.

John Riggins or Mike Alstott

 

[trojan49er]

Emmit or Barry?
Barry Sanders, every time

Riggins or Alstott?
Riggins

Ryan Leaf or JaMarcus Russell?