NFL Would You Rather

[BigBucs]

Ryan Leaf or JaMarcus Russell?

Talk about a mind fuck. Leaf. He had at least 1 decent game, didnt he?

edit: Looking at the game logs It'd definitely be Leaf.

Josh Freeman or Mark Sanchez

 

[G-men]

Talk about a mind fuck. Leaf. He had at least 1 decent game, didnt he?

edit: Looking at the game logs It'd definitely be Leaf.

Josh Freeman or Mark Sanchez

i saw your name as the last post and new this would be the question.

Freeman, no discussion

Justin Tuck or Trent Cole

 

[Juggernaut]

Trent Cole, no discussion

Larry Fitzgerald or Greg Jennings

 

[G-men]

Fitzgerald as long as he actually has a QB

Dan Marino or John Elway

 

[TheImmortalGoud]

Fitz, not even close.

Deji Karim or Rashad Jennings?

EDIT: Elway

 

[Obst]

Rashad Jennings.

Jeremy Maclin or DeSean Jackson

 

[strahanfan92]

^Jeremy Maclin.

Mostly due to the baggage Desean brings and the fact that he is the size of a toothpick. Jeremy Maclin is a very underrated WR (esp. in the speed department, dude is almost as fast as Desean) and I predict a breakout breakout season this year.


Hakeem Nicks or Dez Bryant

 

[Goober]

Nicks.

TEBOW or newton?

 

[Rivers17ncsu]

Tim Tebow

Barry Sanders or Gale Sayers

 

[Leftwich]

Tim Tebow

Barry Sanders or Gale Sayers

Barry Sanders

The better discussion would have been Sanders or Jim Brown. Sanders was the best runningback I've ever seen play. I've seen tape of Sayers but still Sanders was the complete package.

Jake Long or D'Brickshaw Ferguson

 

[G-men]

Long, id say hes the third best tackle in the league behind Clady and Thomas.

Cameron Jordan or Aldon Smith

 

[Rivers17ncsu]

Aldon Smith because he has produced for more than one season, both are really talented though

The better discussion would have been Sanders or Jim Brown. Sanders was the best runningback I've ever seen play. I've seen tape of Sayers but still Sanders was the complete package.

I agree about Sanders being the best that I've ever seen play. Threw in Sayers because judging from the film he was a bit taller, but was very elusive like Sanders was. But yea Sanders/Brown would've been a great one as well


Haloti Ngata or Vince Wilfork

 

[strahanfan92]

Ngata cause I fucking can't stand that fat fuck Wilfork.


Walter vs. Jim Brown

I obviously didn't see them play but I asked my father this question about a week ago and he believes Payton is not only the greatest RB but the greatest player of all time. Said he was the amazing at everything, blocking, catching, and obviously running.

 

[Leftwich]

Ngata cause I fucking can't stand that fat fuck Wilfork.


Walter vs. Jim Brown

I obviously didn't see them play but I asked my father this question about a week ago and he believes Payton is not only the greatest RB but the greatest player of all time. Said he was the amazing at everything, blocking, catching, and obviously running.

Jim Brown

Walter Payton was an incredible back my #3 as far as running backs go. He had durability which was evident in his 170 consecutive starts. But Jim Brown was just had it all. If he were playing today he would still dominate the game like he did back in the day.

Sean Taylor or Ed Reed

 

[strahanfan92]

Trent Cole, no discussion

Larry Fitzgerald or Greg Jennings

Trent Cole better than Tuck? AND no discussion?

Fucking retard.





To answer Leftwich, rather have Ed Reed on my team any day of the week than Sean Taylor.


Jamaal Charles or Darren McFadden?

 

[G-men]

Trent Cole better than Tuck? AND no discussion?

Fucking retard.





To answer Leftwich, rather have Ed Reed on my team any day of the week than Sean Taylor.


Jamaal Charles or Darren McFadden?

he did that because he has a "beef" with me. note the similarity between my post and his.

ill take Charles and his 6 YPC which is just mindboggling.

John Lynch or a healthy Bob Sanders

 

[ThunderHorse]

he did that because he has a "beef" with me. note the similarity between my post and his.

ill take Charles and his 6 YPC which is just mindboggling.

John Lynch or a healthy Bob Sanders

I'd take the 5'8 hitman any day.

when he was healthy the man could do anything.

Tony G or Antonio Gates?

 

[G-men]

I'd take the 5'8 hitman any day.

when he was healthy the man could do anything.

Tony G or Antonio Gates?

call me crazy but ill take Gates, that guy is just a complete freak athlete.

Joe Webb or Jake Locker for the future of the Vikings

 

[Scikotic]

Adrian Peterson

All the explosiveness of Johnson + the ability to get Tough Yards. Fumbling doesn't seem to be so much an issue anymore either.

Steve Smith or Reggie Wayne? (in their respective primes)

EDIT -

Since this apparently pisses some people off (lol).

Let's rub some fucking salt into the wound

I also want Adrian Peterson because he's not a fucking goon. The kid plays like one, has all the edge that a real Nigga needs, but off the field I know I wouldn't have to worry about stupid, petty shit.

CJ2K on the other hand (just see the stupid ass nick name for further evidence) is a fucking character. if he isn't bitching about his nick name, he's bitching about being the MVP/ROTY (or, more specifically, NOT being the MVP or ROTY), bitching about teams like Baltimore supposedly purposefully injuring him in the playoffs (Yea.... Right.... Bitch.. Run faster next time), the guy even said he wants that fucking joke Vince Young back in Tennessee.

In the end it comes down to this.

I want a guy who's coming in to work

AP comes to work baby and work is what the man does

CJ comes to put on a show, run real fast, then bitch when shit doesn't fall his way like a 5 year old. I'll be surprised to see Johnson finish his Career in Tennessee truthfully.

Maybe he'll hit 2K5 next year? It's funny, because I hear AP talking about trying to get to the superbowl, and I hear CJ talking about EA Sports Madden NFL Rushing Statistics.

Almost agree with this completely, because on the other hand you have AP who compared NFL players to slaves. Dumbfuck move IMO.

 

[Scikotic]

call me crazy but ill take Gates, that guy is just a complete freak athlete.

Joe Webb or Jake Locker for the future of the Vikings

Ugh. What a joke. I really want to say neither but for the sake of the game I'd say Joe Webb. I just don't see Locker having a successful career of any sorts. The guy is extremely overrated.

PP3 or Joe Haden?