Rate NCAA 10

[DoubleDeuce]

Well, so far I'd give it a 8.5-9.0

 

[Maynard]

i gave it a 8.....but i agree that its more like 8.5

btw, where are all the people without the game to give it a 5 or less.....

 

[killgod]

i gave it a 8.....but i agree that its more like 8.5

btw, where are all the people without the game to give it a 5 or less.....

They didn't buy the game.

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

If you purchased the game, odds are, at this stage of play (ie: as soon as you got it...maybe a weekend with it at max)...you are going to give it a high score because of the warm fuzzies you get with a new game.

I prefer to read these when we are one month or two months deep...after all of the actual game play flaws are found and people get sick of the game...thats when real grades come out...not after 10 minutes with the game.

 

[Herm]

i take my seven back im now giving it a 2 after playing a lobby game since i mostly play online


there is no commit on D to pass or run and guys just run PA pass all the way down the field and your d bites every time

 

[Maynard]

They didn't buy the game.

exactly....but that doesnt stop them from posting their opinion on every detail of the game, even though they havnt played it

 

[Point Blank]

I'll give it a 8.

Who the hell put perfect?

 

[thirtydaZe]

I gave it an 8, but would border between 8 and 9.

when the demo came out, i struggled liking it, then it really grew on me.

last nite when i got the game, it again seemed different to me than the demo. after playing the game, then doing a quick comparison to '09, i was sold.

really liking the things they've done color wise to the stadiums, and overall game play is night and day different to me.

 

[ralaw]

It’s funny to see the range of likeability this game has created. Prerelease everyone was basically saying it sucked......a few people get the game and its seen as being a good game.....and now it appears the game is approaching the sucks range again. I am not buying this game, but should be getting it soon from GF. Should be interesting.

 

[Tengo Juego]

Someone gave it a 10 :confused2:

I'll vote with my score once I've gotten enough time with the game.

 

[Joey P]

8

 

[chazmaniandevil]

dont the sliders not work?

 

[adembroski]

I gave it a 6... as in, "I enjoy it slightly more than the average game"... so it's mostly a positive, it just doesn't blow me away by any means.

 

[Tengo Juego]

Still feel Madden will be the football game of the year?

Theres only two football games...unless you're counting BCFX

 

[dave]

If you purchased the game, odds are, at this stage of play (ie: as soon as you got it...maybe a weekend with it at max)...you are going to give it a high score because of the warm fuzzies you get with a new game.

I prefer to read these when we are one month or two months deep...after all of the actual game play flaws are found and people get sick of the game...thats when real grades come out...not after 10 minutes with the game.

Agreed.
This poll is two weeks too early.

 

[dave]

i gave it a 8.....but i agree that its more like 8.5

btw, where are all the people without the game to give it a 5 or less.....

I tend to trust Maynard on things like this, because he's a grumpy old fart like me and is very picky about these kinds of things.

I am likely to pick this one up before I go to work this afternoon.

Still can't decide between the ps3 and 360 versions (leaning towards the ps3 version).

 

[adembroski]

Still feel Madden will be the football game of the year?

Considering the competition, it's not saying much, but yes.

 

[dave]

I tend to trust Maynard on things like this, because he's a grumpy old fart like me and is very picky about these kinds of things.

I am likely to pick this one up before I go to work this afternoon.

Still can't decide between the ps3 and 360 versions (leaning towards the ps3 version).

UPDATE: I picked up the ps3 version before work. Won't get to play it until midnight.

 

[Hasselbeck]

Still way too many lapses on defense.. but it's fun to play.

I give it a 7/10

 

[FlawLeSs]

7.5/10