Tried the demo today on 360. No chance in hell I drop $20 on this. Fielding, especially as an outfielder, is a nightmare. The game has zero depth ... and without the ability to play online is pretty much useless. This is a game, like RBI 4, that needs to be played against a human opponent. I remember playing RBI 4 on a table top arcade vs. guys I knew at a bar in 1987. Those games were a blast.
I get what these guys are attempting with RBI 14, but it simply doesn't work without online play ... and we've become too accustomed to having features and this game has none.
If you live in a college dorm and can always find a human opponent, spend the $20. Otherwise, just try the demo.