What's the deal with the Cardinals and grumpy old broadcasters?
First we heard from Houston's Milo Hamilton, yelling something about Lance Berkman's physical conditioning. And then the Cincinnati curmudgeon, Marty Brennaman, insulted pitcher Chris Carpenter and pitching coach Dave Duncan with an acrid blast of hot air during a broadcast diatribe Monday night.
What's next? Is ornery Chicago White Sox broadcaster Hawk Harrelson going to show up and holler at the Cardinals to get off his lawn?
The entertaining Brennaman pretty much rips on every team, including the Reds. But Brennaman also claimed the Cardinals are the most disliked team in baseball, which is interesting.
Is that true?
"I would have to say that is 180 degrees opposite the opinion of other clubs in both leagues starting at the ownership level, going to the front office, going to the players, coaches," Cardinals manager Tony La Russa said before Wednesday's 5-1 win over Houston.
"Over the years I've been here I've heard more compliments from general managers, coaches, managers, players. They tell us, 'You guys try hard to beat us, but if you get beat, you tip your cap to the other side.' That's why it's such a clueless comment."
I doubt that the Cardinals are the most disliked team in baseball, not with the Yankees and Red Sox around.
I think the Cardinals are probably high up on the list. But that shouldn't come as a surprise.
And the Cardinals are definitely the most disliked team in Cincinnati. Absolutely. The favorite sport in the Queen City is pro football. The second-favorite sport there apparently is hating on the Cardinals. The first-place Reds were averaging only 23,368 per home game before drawing another pathetic crowd (16,543) for Wednesday's 5-0 loss to visiting Pittsburgh. The Reds are an outstanding team. They deserve better fan support.
If the Cardinals rank high on the list of most disliked teams, it's for a simple reason: jealousy.
Rather than be offended, the Cardinals should take it as a compliment.
La Russa's most egregious offense is being successful.
Moreover, La Russa doesn't back down from opponents, and he's been standing up to foes for 33 years. That tends to produce some baseball enemies. But only to a point. Most of this is just professional.
When La Russa took a leave to receive treatment for his shingles, one of the people who left him an encouraging voice mail was Reds manager Dusty Baker. It was a classy gesture by Baker.
But on the field, tension is inevitable.
When La Russa managed Oakland for nearly 10 full seasons, the A's won the most games in the American League. Since hiring La Russa in 1996, the Cardinals rank second to Atlanta in the NL in regular-season victories and No. 1 in postseason wins. And the Cardinals are No. 1 in the NL in both categories since 2000.
Wouldn't you get sick and tired of losing to the Cardinals and La Russa? I saw the same thing growing up as a fan in Baltimore; competitors took special delight in beating feisty Orioles manager Earl Weaver. He was the best. His team won more games than anybody over a decade. And the Orioles were the source of envy.
This is pretty simple; long-term success brings out the haters.
TLR disagrees.
"I don't know how you can figure that would be sensible in any way," La Russa said. "I wouldn't want to get beat all the time. But there's more to it. For example, I complimented the way the Yankees played during their heyday with Joe Torre there. They did not beat you and put their noses in the air or do dances and try to humiliate you and make you feel lesser than what you already felt after losing to them.
"And I don't think we do that to teams when we win. There's a right way to win and a right way to lose. And everywhere I've been that's been preached to me by my bosses. And that's the message you send down to the players."
Earlier this season, Berkman, the former Astro, explained what it was like to face La Russa as an opposing player. Berkman's most expansive comments came during an interview with radio station KFNS.
"I love the guy (now)," Berkman said. "And when I played against him I wanted to fistfight him, but it's totally different than you would think. I've always respected him and the way that the Cardinals have approached the game. They always play with an intensity that I think you can attribute directly to his influence and to the tone that he sets.
"And I think too that the Cardinals were so good that you always, for me — I just couldn't stand the whole organization. I was like, 'Man, these guys are our No. 1 rival, always winning the division and if you wanted to do anything you had to beat them.' Almost like a big bully. They play with an attitude of superiority, which is helpful when you're on their side, but playing against them it rankles you. So that's the kind of thing that you sense as an opposing player, but it sure is great to be on the same side."
Cincinnati won the NL Central last season — congratulations — but between 1996 and 2009 the Reds ranked 13th in the NL in winning percentage. The Cardinals were No. 2. The Cardinals won 39 postseason games during that time; the Reds won none. The resentment makes sense.
And there's another element to this: La Russa is combative. His teams don't initiate bean-ball battles. But La Russa readily acknowledges that if an opponent wants to throw down, the Cardinals will offer the appropriate response. And their pushback is often intense.
This old-school baseball doesn't always play well. The Cardinals can be smug and arrogant. And trying to view this from a Cincinnati perspective, it does seem that the Cardinals have been more whiny in reaction to the Reds than any other team. Why? Because the Reds -- after being down for so long -- are a threat to the Cardinals. The Cardinals are feeling pressure after going through a relative dry spell of only one postseason appearance over the past four seasons. The Reds' rise and the Cardinals' downturn invites trouble, especially given the potent mix of volatile personalities on both sides.
The Cardinals can definitely get under the skin, as was the case Sunday in Cincinnati when catcher Gerald Laird upset Reds closer Coco Cordero by shouting warm thoughts to the mound after Cordero nailed Albert Pujols in the wrist with a runaway pitch.
The Reds' broadcast media had a fit when La Russa used a weather report to outmaneuver Baker before the teams met at Busch Stadium on April 22. La Russa didn't break any rules, and Baker should have been paying closer attention to the weather forecast. If he had been, perhaps the Reds would have saved their scheduled starting pitcher (as La Russa did) for after the inevitable rain delay.
The Cardinals annoyed the Reds late in 2009 by making a post-game fuss over slippery baseballs at The Great American Ball Park. (John Smoltz, in particular, protested a bit too much.) Then again, if you thought the home team was messing with the baseballs to get an unfair advantage, what are you supposed to do? Zip it? Again, I think Smoltz went too far. But the Cardinals weren't out of bounds to raise the issue.
Anyway, diplomacy ensued. The matter was settled quietly early last season after a closed-door sit-down between La Russa and his friend, Reds GM Walt Jocketty.
And La Russa famously refused to make a scene in Game 2 of the 2006 World Series. Detroit Tigers pitcher Kenny Rogers, obviously working with a foreign substance under the bill of his cap, pitched eight shutout innings in the Tigers' 3-1 win. La Russa had a low-key discussion with the umpires but never asked them to check Rogers' cap. (At one point the umps did ask Rogers to clean the gunk off his pitching hand, which he did.) Back in St. Louis, fans and media ripped La Russa for not pushing the issue to try to get Rogers ejected.
La Russa calls it "the toughest decision of my career."
"We could have undressed Rogers on the mound in Game 2, and we didn't," he said. "I knew if we lost that Series, that game would be a part of the reason. But you have to revert back to what you believe, and what I was taught. You should play the game between the white lines, and whoever wins, it's because they played better than you did. You don't pull chicken-manure moves."
But if you want to play rough, Don Tony's teams are game. And after all,
Reds second baseman Brandon Phillips initiated all of this last August by calling the Cardinals a name usually associated with a female canine. Game on. And now that the Reds understand the rules of engagement it makes for a heated, terrific rivalry.
Back in the AL days, Toronto pitcher David Cone drilled Oakland's Mark McGwire in the head. Later in the game, the A's retaliated by hitting Toronto's Joe Carter in the hip. The action was true to La Russa's baseball code.
"It's always a revenge thing with Tony," Carter said after the incident. "He's been that way all his career."
Don Tony hardly disputes that.
"Always protect the family," he said. "The family comes first."
And this baseball family has finished first in the NL Central more times than each of its division rivals since La Russa became manager. If the Cardinals are disliked, that's the No. 1 reason.