If Fedor hasn't fought cans post-Pride, then neither has Overeem.
Outrageous nonsense.
Fedor fights since PRIDE:
d. Matt Lindland - not a can, but Lindland is not a heavyweight
d. Hong Man Choi - post tumor removal, CAN
d. Tim Sylvia - good opponent, total destruction
d. Andrei Arlovski - good opponent
d. Brett Rogers - good opponent
l. Fabricio Werdum - good opponent, lost
So Fedor faced one total can, and had one fight vs. a name fighter who was undersized an really didn't have a chance. He then had four consecutive fights vs. "real" opponents.
For Overeem, we will use all fights since he won the SF title, since that's the period where people are critical of his fight quality:
d. Tae Hyun Lee - BUM, not even a can. 1-2, this was his last MMA fight
d. Mark Hunt - BUM, Hunt is 5-7, and has lost 6 in a row. Hasnt been relevent since 2005
NC Mirko Cro Cop - good opponent, was winning the fight,
d. Gary Goodrich - washed up BUM, loser of 7 straight and 8 of 10
d. Tony Sylvester - BUM
d. James Thompson - BUM, loser of 12 of last 15 including losses to KIMBO and BUTTERBEAN
d. Kazuyuki Fujita - washed up, was 40 years old, loser of 5 of 7
d. Brett Rogers - good opponent
d. Todd Duffee - decent opponent
So what do we have? Two fights vs. "real" conteders, one of which he didn't win, the other of which Fedor beat, too. Dufee is his next best fight, a guy who has never sniffed the top 10. Then you have 6 total, complete, BUMS.
SUMMARY:
Fedor - 1 total BUM, 2 if you throw in Lindland. 4 legit opponents, 3 of which were either former world champs or ranked top 10 at the time of the fight. the fourth, Rogers, was a bordeline top 10 guy.
Overeem - 6 total BUMS. His toughest opponent, Rogers, was also defeated by Fedor, so that's a wash. Dufee isnt a bum, but never top 10 or even close. Cro Cop isnt a bum, but clearly declining, and Overeem technically didnt even beat him.
Fedor's top 5:
1. Werdum (L)
2. Rogers (W)
3. Arlovski (W)
4. Sylvia (W)
5. Lindland (W)
Overeem's top 5:
1. Rogers (W, Fedor beat him too)
2. Duffee (W)
3. Cro Cop (NC)
4. Fujita (W, BUM)
5. Sylvester or Hunt (W, BUMS)
It's not even close, Fedor has faced a much better lineup of fighters, it's impossible to argue. The sad part, is it's not like Fedore has faced some sort of killer lineup, and it still blows away the parade of BUMS Overeem has faced. Since 2007, Overeem has faced the weakest lineup of fighters of any "elite" level fighter in history. We finally get to see if he is for real.