The Best of the Best in the NFL

[Raidersabc123]

Russells throw power should be 100, Dmac's elusiveness, accel, and agility should be 100, Tommy Kelly's overpaid rating should be 115, and Al Davis' owner rating should be -145,786,994,883,722

WTF im not saying any of the Raiders players like Kelly deserve a high rating Jano has by far the strongest leg in the NFL how doesn't he get the highest kick power his accuracy shouldn't be high but he should definitely have the highest kick power

 

[RosettaStoned]

I've never thought that much of Roethlisberger as a passer. I think he holds onto the ball far too long, I think he makes his O-line look worse than they are because of that. And either his WRs are terrible at getting separation, or he's just slow as fuck making his reads. (I lean more toward the latter)

It's neither. He's just always trying to make big plays. Either way, to say Rodgers is better on the run is stupid. He's not even in the discussion.

 

[RosettaStoned]

I wasn't really trying to compare them. I was just saying that Rodgers is pretty good at throwing on the run and off-balance.

I didn't say you were. That's what the conversation was about though, so I guess I have no idea what you're trying to say, or if you're actually saying anything at all.

 

[RosettaStoned]

I guess I'm saying he's "in the discussion," based on what I've seen, but I just don't care enough to go through the task of finding everyone's numbers in those situations and then also watch a lot of highlight reels to actually compare the two.

So I mean it's fair if you want to say he's not "in the discussion," but I just don't care enough to argue one way or another beyond a simple disagreement.

Then why are you posting? I mean, that's 3 posts with a lot of typing to say nothing.

 

[stevsta]

brian westbrook is so overrated its insane. portis is by far better than bwest as far as running,pass pro,vision,power, and durabillity its a landslide. hes given these ridiculous ratings every year no matter wat. wat does portis do, runs for 1487 yds and like 10 tds yet only gets his 93 rating like every year. hes better than L.T. wtf does it fucking take!?

im sorry but bwest is a beast he may not have as much power as madden always gives him but hes still a beast and is def not overrated

 

[Fox1994]

I think I agree. He's really good, but he's never played in sixteen games and only had two thousand-yard seasons in seven years, plus one 900 yard season last year. Portis has rushed for over 1200 yards in all but one season (2006). He isn't anywhere near as good a receiver, though. Maybe that's where the ratings come from.

 

[Blade]

Nice to see Westy is mentioned in a bunch of categeries. I bet hes got the worst injury rating