The problem with Tony Romo

[Esjay]

Any room left on the Vince Young Bandwagon?

I'm guessing you could probably find room. :nana:

 

[Rayman]

I'm guessing you could probably find room. :nana:

Only after I'm done with Peyton.

:heart:

 

[Woy]

Any room left on the Vince Young Bandwagon?

Hop right on. He does have the third best record as a starting quarterback this year.

 

[nflman2033]

:jonesy:

No, no he isn't. Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Brett Favre Phillip Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Aaron Rodgers, Donovan McNabb, and Joe Flacco are all better quarterbacks and theres a few more guys who you could also argue for.

i was with you right up until you put McNabb on there..

 

[mgoblue2290]

i was with you right up until you put McNabb on there..

I'd still put him in the same group as Romo. He'd be at the back end of that group though now.

 

[bringbackjimmy]

:jonesy:

No, no he isn't. Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Brett Favre Phillip Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Aaron Rodgers, Donovan McNabb, and Joe Flacco are all better quarterbacks and theres a few more guys who you could also argue for.

Ok i can understand Manning, brady,brees,rivers, roethlisberger. In all hoensty how can you put Rodgers, mcnabb, and Flacco over Romo?

Is it's Flacco leading the Ravens to a mediocre season? or is it his last yrs performance of 14TD/12 INT care taker season?

Mcnabb is Mr. Choke so how he can be better than romo is beyond comprehension. The eagles probably would have won a SB during his time if they let him be what he does best and be a care taker while letting westbrook be the focus. Somebody said Romo would puke and crap his pant's if he was on the steelers final drive, well Mcnabb did puke .

I would say Rodgers is about even with Romo, but he does take alot of sacks where he holds on to the ball way to long(makes his line look worse than it is, they still suck but he makes them look worse)....

My top 10 would be right now putting in current/past/future:
Tier1
1.Manning
2.Brady
3.Brees
Tier2
4.Rivers
5.Romo
6.Roethlisberger
7.Rodgers
Tier3
8.Favre
9.Palmer
10.Warner

Favre is in the best situation he could ever dream with AP and a young talented Recieving corp and longterm is always uncertain. Warner has 2 top 10 wr and a pretty good number 3 so i will not put him over guys like the 4 R's.

 

[Woy]

Umm Donovan McNabb led the Eagles to the NFC Championship five times, four of them with mediocre receivers. That argument doesn't help your case.

And LOL @ you still having Romo over Roethlisberger...and fucking Warner? What a joke.

 

[bucky]

You've mentioned me in nearly 10 posts between the last time I was here and now.

Holy shit, get off my nuts.

Where ya been? Glad your OK.
A little sensitive aren't ya? Dude, I was just having a little fun with ya. Chill out.

 

[kbpsu]

My top 10 would be right now putting in current/past/future:
Tier1
1.Manning
2.Brady
3.Brees
Tier2
4.Rivers
5.Romo
6.Roethlisberger
7.Rodgers
Tier3
8.Favre
9.Palmer
10.Warner

Favre is in the best situation he could ever dream with AP and a young talented Recieving corp and longterm is always uncertain. Warner has 2 top 10 wr and a pretty good number 3 so i will not put him over guys like the 4 R's.

W.O.W.
........this is easily the worst top 10 QB list I have ever seen. Do you actually watch football on Sundays?

 

[bringbackjimmy]

Umm Donovan McNabb led the Eagles to the NFC Championship five times, four of them with mediocre receivers. That argument doesn't help your case.

And LOL @ you still having Romo over Roethlisberger...and fucking Warner? What a joke.

Warner???? honestly you can put any decent QB in there and look great...4-7 are interchangable so i really don't see the problem with the list...

I am done i am wrong i guess take Romo out of the top 10 hell take him out of the top 25 I don't care...sorry for having a opinion on such a opinion subject as a top 10 list or who is somethinks is better......

 

[bringbackjimmy]

W.O.W.
........this is easily the worst top 10 QB list I have ever seen. Do you actually watch football on Sundays?

sorry Mcnabb didn't make the list...

 

[Woy]

Warner???? honestly you can put any decent QB in there and look great...4-7 are interchangable so i really don't see the problem with the list...

I am done i am wrong i guess take Romo out of the top 10 hell take him out of the top 25 I don't care...sorry for having a opinion on such a opinion subject as a top 10 list or who is somethinks is better......

Look at my previous posts, dumbass. I said Romo is a top 10 quarterback. Not a top 5 one that you're trying to make him out to be.

And that Cardinals system isn't that easy to perfect, I mean...what's Matt Leinart doing right now? Kurt Warner has won a Super Bowl and was seconds away from winning two more, including last year with the Arizona fucking Cardinals. Again, what has Romo done besides give you a slight erection when he takes a snap?

 

[Liquidrob]

Top 5 QB's Manning, Brees, Brady, Rivers, Romo....

 

[bringbackjimmy]

Look at my previous posts, dumbass. I said Romo is a top 10 quarterback. Not a top 5 one that you're trying to make him out to be.

And that Cardinals system isn't that easy to perfect, I mean...what's Matt Leinart doing right now? Kurt Warner has won a Super Bowl and was seconds away from winning two more, including last year with the Arizona fucking Cardinals. Again, what has Romo done besides give you a slight erection when he takes a snap?

what has Rodgers Flacco done? Sorry if you can't read my post correctly, but i have always said that 4-7 could be changed to prefrence. I like Romo more than i like Ben, or Aaron...

It's really not hard to do well if your a decent/good QB to run the Cards Offense. or really the TGSOT. Matt Leinart isn't a decent QB and was highly overrated coming out of college which was because he played at USC with Reggie. There is not a team in the NFL that can cover both Fitz and Bold then throw in Breaston come on man really? is it that hard? Anybody in my top 7 would put up even better numbers than Warner. Do you really think warner on a cowboys team with 1 WR and 1 TE would do better than Romo? I don't Think so...

 

[Rayman]

Where ya been? Glad your OK.
A little sensitive aren't ya? Dude, I was just having a little fun with ya. Chill out.

One or two posts is "having fun".

You're just being an asshole.

 

[bucky]

One or two posts is "having fun".

You're just being an asshole.

Take the panties off rayman...All I did was call your team a quality team and say it was a good win for GB.

 

[steeljake]

look, the real problem with Romo is that he plays for Dallas. before you flame me, hear me out...

The facts are he is an undrafted free agent who had a great college career at a I-AA school was spotted by parcells as having 'potential' which in the land of the Star means GOAT. He comes in and replaces an old washed up Drew Bledsoe and since he can actually out run the growing grass and thrwo the ball more than 40 yards everyone in Dallas is estatic. he then has some bad luck with a slick ball (yes the Walrus did in fact make sure a brand new slick ass ball went in for the XP, he is cuntbag that way) and he gets a rep for 'choking'. He then lives up to that rep by playing like a dog in December and also losing to teh Giants in the playoffs. All this while being touted by JJ as the 2nd coming of Staubach and he signs a monster deal to boot. He also has to change coaches in his 2nd full year and that run first mentality that made him look good was gone. If this guy was anywhere else he would be a qb that is growing into his role and be given that chance. But since he plays in dallas and the fans, as well as the idiot owner, expect this team to win the super bowl every year and they still havent won a playoff game this century, he is a choking dog.

he has the chops to play, he just needs to be taught and who on that team is in a position to teach him anything besides how to be a marshmellow and a yes man? Garret wants Wade's job and Wade wants his daddy's approval. Add to that his so called number one drops more passes than Braylon Edwards and (i mentioned this before) and offense bulkit to run being run by a coordinator who runs the ball almost as much as Andy Reid and it doesnt matter how good he really is. Now, he is not better than McNabb, or Rivers or Eli and especially not Roethlisberger so stfu with that noise. But he is a top 10 qb and a viable franchise qb. If he played for say Atlanta, where they have a young qb currently strug-a-ling, then maybe he gets less of this choking dog stuff from fromer team greats and the like. The fans dont help either when you have morons like Bringbakcjimmy and Durrville claiming that Romo is better than people who have won playoffs games (this includes flacco you dopey bitches) and that he is somehow 'elite' when he clearly is not.

If you put romo on another team does he suceed? maybe, then again maybe his flaws show up more clearly when there are no other factors to consider. Then again, maybe Romo is just a glorified bench warmer.

flame on.

P.S. I really fucking hate dallas and I couldn't be happier that they continue to suck in the post season.

 

[Woy]

what has Rodgers Flacco done? Sorry if you can't read my post correctly, but i have always said that 4-7 could be changed to prefrence. I like Romo more than i like Ben, or Aaron...

It's really not hard to do well if your a decent/good QB to run the Cards Offense. or really the TGSOT. Matt Leinart isn't a decent QB and was highly overrated coming out of college which was because he played at USC with Reggie. There is not a team in the NFL that can cover both Fitz and Bold then throw in Breaston come on man really? is it that hard? Anybody in my top 7 would put up even better numbers than Warner. Do you really think warner on a cowboys team with 1 WR and 1 TE would do better than Romo? I don't Think so...

Flacco has two playoff wins. And now he's putting up stats with (arguably) the worst receiving core in the league. Never said he wouldn't be above Rodgers. Read a little more, homer.

It shouldn't be that hard to cover receivers when the offense has the worst running attack in the league. You're basically saying that any decent quarterback (which I have no clue who you would qualify as decent) could run that Arizona offense as good or better than Warner. Would they be able to put up the big games in the playoffs like Warner though? Would they be able to take a franchise with the history of not doing shit to the Super Bowl? You don't give Warner enough credit. Just another blind Cowboys homer I see.

Try to be more like your other Cowboy fans that actually know two shits about the game.

 

[Esjay]

look, the real problem with Romo is that he plays for Dallas. before you flame me, hear me out...

The facts are he is an undrafted free agent who had a great college career at a I-AA school was spotted by parcells as having 'potential' which in the land of the Star means GOAT. He comes in and replaces an old washed up Drew Bledsoe and since he can actually out run the growing grass and thrwo the ball more than 40 yards everyone in Dallas is estatic. he then has some bad luck with a slick ball (yes the Walrus did in fact make sure a brand new slick ass ball went in for the XP, he is cuntbag that way) and he gets a rep for 'choking'. He then lives up to that rep by playing like a dog in December and also losing to teh Giants in the playoffs. All this while being touted by JJ as the 2nd coming of Staubach and he signs a monster deal to boot. He also has to change coaches in his 2nd full year and that run first mentality that made him look good was gone. If this guy was anywhere else he would be a qb that is growing into his role and be given that chance. But since he plays in dallas and the fans, as well as the idiot owner, expect this team to win the super bowl every year and they still havent won a playoff game this century, he is a choking dog.

he has the chops to play, he just needs to be taught and who on that team is in a position to teach him anything besides how to be a marshmellow and a yes man? Garret wants Wade's job and Wade wants his daddy's approval. Add to that his so called number one drops more passes than Braylon Edwards and (i mentioned this before) and offense bulkit to run being run by a coordinator who runs the ball almost as much as Andy Reid and it doesnt matter how good he really is. Now, he is not better than McNabb, or Rivers or Eli and especially not Roethlisberger so stfu with that noise. But he is a top 10 qb and a viable franchise qb. If he played for say Atlanta, where they have a young qb currently strug-a-ling, then maybe he gets less of this choking dog stuff from fromer team greats and the like. The fans dont help either when you have morons like Bringbakcjimmy and Durrville claiming that Romo is better than people who have won playoffs games (this includes flacco you dopey bitches) and that he is somehow 'elite' when he clearly is not.

If you put romo on another team does he suceed? maybe, then again maybe his flaws show up more clearly when there are no other factors to consider. Then again, maybe Romo is just a glorified bench warmer.

flame on.

P.S. I really fucking hate dallas and I couldn't be happier that they continue to suck in the post season.

Excellent post.

 

[Archer]

what has Rodgers Flacco done? Sorry if you can't read my post correctly, but i have always said that 4-7 could be changed to prefrence. I like Romo more than i like Ben, or Aaron...

It's really not hard to do well if your a decent/good QB to run the Cards Offense. or really the TGSOT. Matt Leinart isn't a decent QB and was highly overrated coming out of college which was because he played at USC with Reggie. There is not a team in the NFL that can cover both Fitz and Bold then throw in Breaston come on man really? is it that hard? Anybody in my top 7 would put up even better numbers than Warner. Do you really think warner on a cowboys team with 1 WR and 1 TE would do better than Romo? I don't Think so...

Two MVPs , One Superbowl MVP .

Holds the NFL Completion % record for a single game

5th most 300yard passing games in NFL History

300-YARD GAMES BY PERCENTAGE
44.6 – Kurt Warner (45 times in 101 games)
28.2 – Dan Fouts (51 times in 181 games)
26.2 – Peyton Manning (44 times in 168 games)
26.0 – Dan Marino (63 times in 242 games)
23.6 – Warren Moon (49 times in 208 games)
20.8 – Brett Favre (55 times in 265 games)

And probably a Hall of Famer

Yeah ... most if not all the other top 10 guys would put up equal numbers