I think it's b/c there was so much hinting at it only being a timed exclusive, then at the last minute new news comes out about EA/Microsoft's deal. It just seems that with all that talk that Microsoft dropped off another truck of money to EA. By no means do I think it's bad, that game will sell quite a few consoles for them, so good for them.
As for the Sony comment, does Sony have any third party exclusives? That's why I think this gets more talk, b/c we don't see it that often anymore.
Wasn't TLOU developed by Naughty Dog?