Who said anything about McNabb??? Where did this come from? and make sure you quote ESPN becuz they've said this word for word the other day.
I'm glad some one realizes this and for everyone saying Romo is weak without Witten... Take Boss away from Eli and he's a pile of bullshit. Matter of fact it's games Witten barely got the ball and we blew people out. Boss is Eli's bitch blanket
Eli is already a pile of bullshit.
All I know is that there are 22 people on the field. A starting Quarterback can't do everything. Eli didn't win the Super Bowl alone. Either did Big Ben. Quite frankly Eli only put up 17 against the greatest offense of all time, and won the Super Bowl. So I'm pretty sure he didn't do his job. If New York scored 35+ Yeah, Eli did his job. However only scoring 17???? If that defense doesn't play SB Worthy Eli Manning, and the New York Giants are never SB Champs, and you wouldn't even have Eli Manning in your top 10.
Another thing... Who are the active SB Champion QBs in the league right now? Let's see where they stand in QB Rating. Because stats are Facts people. And QB Rating is the best way to measure a QB based of stats.
Peyton - Career 94.6 Season 93.8
Brady - Career 92.9
Eli - Career 76.1 Season 86.9
Roethlisberger - Career 89.7 Season - 80.8
Favre - Career 85.6 Season - 84.0
Warner - Career 93.6 Season - 95.5
and Romo.... - Career 95.9 Season 94.8
I also want to let you guys know he is undrafted. He is only in his 3rd year as a starter, and 4th year in uniform.
Are you guys that talk all that SB Winners better than non SB Winners mumbo jumbo really trying to say that Peyton Manning wasn't the 1st or 2nd best QB in his first 8 years as a starter just because he didn't have a SB? Are you really trying to say Trent Dilfer/Doug Williams > Peyton Manning pre Super Bowl Win? Are you really trying to say Trent Dilfer/Doug Williams > Dan Marino?
Get a fucking grip... It's not always the QB.
Seriously... get a fucking grip and stop being a hater..