I would rather have Pat, I wont comment on Frank because I'm to close to it, plus I have heard Frank talk enough over the years, lol, Randy also is better than Joe
Just think of it like this, Adam Sandler loves Basketball, he plays a lot, maybe played in high School, I don't know, do I want Hubie Brown or Adam Sandler in the booth?
If Dennis Miller 'practiced' football for years, would I want him in there instead of Ron Jaworski?
They are both more entertaining but its the color spot, not evening at the improv
Like W2B said, Rogan is there for the demo, but I don't care about that, I want a guy that knows more than me (hard to find I know), but I want guys who were in there and can get inside the head and breakdown what is going for the fans and have experience to pull from