Palooza's Top 125 Films of 2012
Collapse
X
-
73 . The GreyDirector(s) - Joe Carnahan
Liam Neeson, Frank Grillo, Dermot Mulroney, Dallas Roberts, Joe Anderson, Nonso Anozie, James Badge Dale, Ben Bray, Anne Openshaw
Writer(s) - Joe Carnahan, Ian MacKenzie Jeffries
Source Material/Connections - based on the short story "Ghost Walker" by Ian MacKenzie Jeffries
MPAA Rating - R
Release Date - January 27
Runtime - 1 hour, 18 minutes
RT Score - 79%
Metacritic - 64/100
Views - 1
Viewed - torrent
Quote - "This is fuck city, population five and dwindling."
Review - Sometimes, simple is good. Far too often in Hollywood we see a movie try to be more than it is and it winds up really hurting in the long run. This movie has been a victim of that. Outside of the generally badassery of a bunch of guys crash landing in wolf territory and having to survive, this movie falls pretty flat. It goes beyond the man vs. nature themes and delves into the themes of God, heaven and the like. This is where the movie tries to be more than what it is. You have a perfect scenario where these guys are fighting for their lives; it can be 90 minutes of pure entertainment, but no, we need a message and blatant motifs and themes that are constantly addressed. Outside of a few fight scenes, Liam Neeson and a cool plane crash, this movie is beat. There's a reason this movie is given a C rating - every one good thing that happens it's counteracted with a bad thing. You can't win here, but you also won't lose.
The Good -
I can't tell if me liking the fact that nobody survives is a good thing or a bad thing for this movie, but I'll chalk it up as a good thing for their sake. I didn't care about most characters, so my interest in their dying was expected. However, in such a scenario, you know the chance for survival is limited, so I'm glad they didn't cop out and have Neeson find safety right at the end of the movie. Would have taken the poorly established religious themes and took a shit on them and this movie would have failed.
The death and fight scenes were a little hit or miss. I'll get into one or two in particular in the bad section, but here I was relatively pleased with how violent some of the wolf attacks were. I can't say I was overly impressed with the deaths in general, but the events leading up to most the deaths were fun. Also, the plane crash was pretty fucking sweet. Really well done.
The Bad -
Ahhhh, a flimsy script leads to predictability within the events of the movie. You know where every turn is headed, it's only a matter of time before you get there. The only way they'll stray from the path is if they completely butcher it, so there's something wrong with rooting for predictability. There was no circumstance where you could have been surprised. Survival movies are all the same, it's all about your execution in the deaths.
Speaking of deaths, there is one that irked me and probably did the actor, too. The Richest Man in Qarth is the only black dude who is a part of their crew and after seeing some of his buddies go out by getting eaten by wolves while they piss or they fell off a cliff and got all ate up by the wolves, this guy gets hypoxia and dies. What a pathetic death, even though it may add to realism, I don't care. I don't want realism, I want these guys to bareknuckle box wolves.
And what a transition we have here. So bareknuckle boxing wolves, eh? That's what this movie advertised would be going down. They say "Liam Neeson will fight and kill wolves with his hands." Do it happen? Yes. It does. OFF SCREEN! The last 5 minutes of the movie Neeson encounters the alpha wolf and they battle it out, some quick cuts and a pause later and they both lie in the snow, dying. Credits. Why the fuck would you hype me up for Liam Neeson killin mofuckin' wolves with his hands and then cut away before they get going? So beat, Joe Carnahan, so beat.
But not as beat as the forced religious talks throughout the movie. God weighs this movie down, forcing dialogue between the guys about whether they believe in God, praying and thanking God for keeping them safe. It's just thrown at you too much. It's obvious the filmmakers are trying to add substance to a movie about killing wolves in the middle of a blizzard and it's done oh so horribly.
Rating - CComment
-
Wow that's low for the grey... one of the few decent January releases ever.Comment
-
edit - I'm also not caught up in the omg Liam Neeson biggest badazz evar hype, either.Comment
-
72 . God Bless AmericaDirector(s) - Bobcat Goldthwait
Joel Murray, Tara Lynn Barr, Melinda Paige Hamilton, Rich McDonald, Mackenzie Brooke Smith, Maddie Hasson
Writer(s) - Bobcat Goldthwait
Source Material/Connections - n/a
MPAA Rating - R
Release Date - May 11 (limited)
Runtime - 1 hour, 34 minutes
RT Score - 67%
Metacritic - 56/100
Views - 1
Viewed - netflix
Quote - "Why have a civilization if we are no longer interested in being civilized."
Review - I kind of had a hard time rating this movie. I liken this movie to last year's Hobo with a Shotgun - it's a violent, over the top "revenge" B-movie. Joel Murray stars as Frank a guy who after being diagnosed with some sort of terminal illness, finally snaps and begins a cross country road trip killing everyone who represents something that is wrong in this world, concluding at an American Idol spoof with guns a-blazing. What's good about this movie sometimes turns bad. It blends the aforementioned elements of violence and redemption with satire and black comedy, so what's wrong with it? Well, it's over-the-top, too ambitious and angry. The targets are obvious and Goldthwait winds up being his own worst enemy here, getting self involved. It's essentially Goldthwait's way to blow off steam about all the shit he hates in the world. It's preachy and a bit hypocritical at times. The entire thing has a low budget feel, but not ironically like Hobo with a Shotgun. The acting, outside of Joel Murray, is borderline embarrassing and it gets ridiculous at certain points.
Rating - CComment
-
71 . FrankenweenieDirector(s) - Tim Burton
Writer(s) - Tim Burton, John August
Source Material/Connections - based on Tim Burton's own 1984 short film of the same name.
MPAA Rating - PG
Release Date - October 5
Runtime - 1 hour, 30 minutes
RT Score - 88%
Metacritic - 74/100
Views - 1
Viewed - theaters
Quote - "They like what science gives them but not the questions..no, not the questions the science asks."
Review -
This review can be summed up pretty easily, so I won't waste too much time. Even though Tim Burton's latest foray in animation is clever, looks perfect for the setting and is a pretty fun ride, it's completely forgettable. It's an old and overdone storyline with Tim Burton's animation and trademarks caked on. It's nothing revolutionary, but it's fun for what it is. I don't suppose I'll ever see it again and I'm okay with that. It's always satisfying to watch a Tim Burton movie without Johnny Depp's face or voice, so that's a plus. In addition to that, Winona Ryder's somber, depressed voice always turned me on, so yeah.
Rating - CComment
-
I actually liked The Hunger Games. For a film with young adult source material, it was incredibly well acted (most films from this genre are incredibly corny) and while the film could have expounded on certain things...I think it hit all of the points.Comment
-
C for Frankenweenie?
Bollocks, I say. Second best animated film of the year.
The Grey gets a C. C'mon, son.Comment
-
Comment
-
The Grey couldn't decide between being an action film or a dialogue driven movie about some regular dudes in a very bad situation. It tried doing both and failed. It could've been a decent action survival movie if it wanted too, or could've been, I think at least, a better, bleak story driven movie.
They should've done more to parallel the humans and wolves in the movie too. There the one scene where Liam Neeson is like nah brah I'm the alpha here, but maybe them sacrificing one of the guys to survive a la the omega wolf would've been a nice touch. It had potential but definitely did not reach it.Comment
-
Comment
Comment