The Most Overrated Pitcher And Hitter

[chazmaniandevil]

Overrated hitter = Derek Jeter
Overrated pitcher = Cole Hamels

[chazmaniandevil]

were talking about overrrated. and jeter is treated like a god. not saying hes bad, just overrated

[Anthony]

Overrated. Agreed.

Jeter, hit 73 HRs already brah. Rod Carew and Tony Gwynn were also overrated hitters.

[Lanteri]

Hitter: Brandon Inge

Guy finally has a good, about two months for once in his career, and suddenly makes an ASG. Yeah that was a pretty impressive .230/.314/.406 "career year". I'm not sure if he's overrated or not, but the vocal majority of Tigers fans seem to love the guy.

Honorable Mention: B.J. Upton

1 good season/playoff run, a career does not make. He's still young and may regain the promise he showed, but as of now he's not the superstar he's been expected to be, and it seems some people still think he is. We'll see how much of it was the shoulder injury.

Pitcher: Carlos Zambrano

Never been a big fan of this guy. I mean, he's a quality pitcher and all, but far from an ace as he's made out to be Cubs fans, especially in the last 3 seasons.

[Lanteri]

Also, I have to disagree with Jeter being overrated. I do feel he's vastly overrated defensively, but he's one of the better hitters around.

You don't rack up 2700+ hits and hit .317 by being "overrated".

[StealthShot]

Overrated hitter = Derek Jeter

[StealthShot]

Loving the DJ hate. How is a guy with 5! World series rings over rated?

4 Gold Glove awards and guess what his last one was 2009

4 Silver Slugger awards and guess what he's won 4 in a row since 2006.

Calling him overrated is one of the most ridiculous things i've ever heard. He is a team orientated player and a winner. If he was anything he's the most respected player in the league not overrated.

[StealthShot]

Hitter: Manny Ramirez
Terrible teammate terrible energy and all around bitch ass.

Pitcher: Carlos Zambrano
Wild pitcher goes nuts and plays for the Cub that's why he's in the media nothing to do with his pitching.

[Leftwich]

I think everyone is saying Jeter cause he is a Yankee and everyone hates him (including me). But there are other hitters that deserve it more than Jetah.

[beamerball811]

Hitter: A-Rod
Pitcher: Cole Hamels

[beamerball811]

His .418 and .430 OBPs in the last 2 seasons disagree with you, as does his beastish OPS. I'm a Giants fan, and I disagree with this. Clubhouse chemistry means absolutely nothing (see again: 2002 Giants and the A's from back in the day).

also to add onto this...Manny is a excellent clubhouse guy if you keep him happy. The Sox weren't paying him what he wanted for a new contract. That's why he went all Manny being Manny. But it's not a huge deal. Keep him happy. He is still one of the best hitters in the game still.

[celtsxpatsxsox]

Hitter: Jason Bay
Pitcher: Carlos Zambrano/Scott Kazmir

[celtsxpatsxsox]

But again, the "good clubhouse guy" is highly overrated. Jeff Kent and Barry Bonds were at each others throats during the 2002 season and they still made the World Series. If I'm up to bat with a chance to win, I'm not thinking "Man, that Manny guy is a jerk." and letting that effect my performance. IMO it's the most overrated thing in all of sports

ehhh I agree and disagree. I do think the clubhouse thing is overused but I still think it does sometime have an effect on the team. When Manny was going on with his shenanigans in 08 it definitely did affect the way the Red Sox were playing.

[beamerball811]

But again, the "good clubhouse guy" is highly overrated. Jeff Kent and Barry Bonds were at each others throats during the 2002 season and they still made the World Series. If I'm up to bat with a chance to win, I'm not thinking "Man, that Manny guy is a jerk." and letting that effect my performance. IMO it's the most overrated thing in all of sports

I don't, but I definently agree saying it's not going to change his at-bats. It will change fielding if anything.

[DJ Fog]

Derek Jeter is overhated