Start, Sit, or Cut

[shag773]

I've been thinking about starting this thread for two weeks, but I didn't have the balls. Well. I'm drunk, full of turkey, and everybody bailed on me. So here it is. I will give you three players. They play the same position. It is up to you to start him, sit him, or cut him. Kind of like Fuck, marry, kill. The first one is..

Ty Cobb
Mickey Mantle
Barry Bonds

My apologies if someone did this before.

After you answer, come up with another one.

[Leftwich]

I've been thinking about starting this thread for two weeks, but I didn't have the balls. Well. I'm drunk, full of turkey, and everybody bailed on me. So here it is. I will give you three players. They play the same position. It is up to you to start him, sit him, or cut him. Kind of like Fuck, marry, kill. The first one is..

Ty Cobb
Mickey Mantle
Barry Bonds

My apologies if someone did this before.

After you answer, come up with another one.

Start Cobb
Sit Mantle
Cut Bonds

All of that is based on who I liked more. Bond had the power and Mantle is a legend but Cobb didn't cheat or play for the yankees.

Start, Sit or Cut

Cal Ripken Jr
Derek Jeter
Ozzie Smith

[Warner2BruceTD]

Start Cobb
Sit Mantle
Cut Bonds

All of that is based on who I liked more. Bond had the power and Mantle is a legend but Cobb didn't cheat or play for the yankees.

Start, Sit or Cut

Cal Ripken Jr
Derek Jeter
Ozzie Smith

Start - Jeter
Sit - Ripkin
Cut - Smith

Roberto Alomar, Chase Utley, Joe Morgan

[NAHSTE]

Start: Morgan
Sit: Alomar
Cut: Utley


Ryan Klesko, Pete Incaviglia, Glenallen Hill

[Golden Taters]

Start: Morgan
Sit: Alomar
Cut: Utley


Ryan Klesko, Pete Incaviglia, Glenallen Hill

What the hell? lol

Start: Hill
Sit: Klesko
Cut: Incaviglia
....

Tim Lincecum, Roy Halladay, Felix Hernandez

[shag773]

Start Halladay
Sit Felix
Cut Tim

Pete Rose, Ty Cobb, Barry Bonds

[Golden Taters]

Start Halladay
Sit Felix
Cut Tim

Pete Rose, Ty Cobb, Barry Bonds

Start: Rose
Sit: Cobb
Cut: Bonds

....

Ken Griffey Jr, Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays

[shag773]

Start: Rose
Sit: Cobb
Cut: Bonds

....

Ken Griffey Jr, Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays

Damn bro, that is insanely tough

Start Mickey Mantle
Sit Junior
Cut Mays

Mark Fidyrich, Dwight Gooden, Fernando Valenzuela

[FirstTimer]

Damn bro, that is insanely tough

Start Mickey Mantle
Sit Junior
Cut Mays

Mark Fidyrich, Dwight Gooden, Fernando Valenzuela

Easy.

Start Gooden
Sit Fernando
Cut Fidyrich


Lee Smith, Trevor Hoffman, Dennis Eckersley

[SuperKevin]

start: Eckersley
sit: Hoffman
cut: Smith


The 1B/DH division
Frank Thomas, Rafael Palmerio, Jim Thome

[FirstTimer]

start: Eckersley
sit: Hoffman
cut: Smith


The 1B/DH division
Frank Thomas, Rafael Palmerio, Jim Thome

Easy again.

Start Thomas
Sit Thome
Cut Raffy

Albert Pujols, Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx

[NAHSTE]

Easy again.

Start Thomas
Sit Thome
Cut Raffy

Albert Pujols, Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx

Start: Gehrig
Sit: Pujols
Cut: Foxx


Gary Sheffield, Vlad Guerrero, Larry Walker

[Warner2BruceTD]

Start - Vlad
Sit - Sheff
Cut - Walker

Deion Sanders, Bo Jackson, Brian Jordan

[Warner2BruceTD]

sidenote -

Start: Rose
Sit: Cobb
Cut: Bonds

wut

[Golden Taters]

sidenote -

Start: Rose
Sit: Cobb
Cut: Bonds

wut

It was easy to cut Bonds. I am really a fan of Pete Rose and he played in more modern of times. If I was a coach I don't know how Cobb would do, baseball has changed a lot in like 90 years imo.