Start, Sit, or Cut

[NAHSTE]

Start - Vlad
Sit - Sheff
Cut - Walker

Deion Sanders, Bo Jackson, Brian Jordan

Start: Bo
Sit: Deion
Cut: Jordan



Scott Podsednik, Mark Grudzelianek, David Eckstein

[Warner2BruceTD]

Start: Bo
Sit: Deion
Cut: Jordan



Scott Podsednik, Mark Grudzelianek, David Eckstein

start - Grudzelianek (along with A. Huff one of the most undeappreciated players of his generation)

sit - Podsednik
cut - Eckstein

Juan Pierre, Dave Roberts, Brett Gardner

[FirstTimer]

It was easy to cut Bonds. I am really a fan of Pete Rose and he played in more modern of times. If I was a coach I don't know how Cobb would do, baseball has changed a lot in like 90 years imo.

I'd cut Rose. He's one of the most overrated baseball players of all time.

The interesting question is whether you are talking pre-roids Barry or Baroid.

Pre-roids Barry was most likely the best player I have ever seen...along side Junior and Albert.
Between Pre-Roid Barry and Cobb would be an interesting discussion.

I'd also like to point out that this position battle between those three is a battle between perhaps the three biggest assholes ever to play.

Start: Gehrig
Sit: Pujols
Cut: Foxx

Disagree

[NAHSTE]

Disagree

I just couldn't get Gehrig out of the lineup. It's like the guy never takes a day off.

[Warner2BruceTD]

ANSWER MINE

[shag773]

Start - Vlad
Sit - Sheff
Cut - Walker

Deion Sanders, Bo Jackson, Brian Jordan

Start Bo
Sit Jordan
Cut Neon

Al Oliver, Lloyd Moseby, Chris Chambliss

[EmpireWF]

Start Moseby
Sit Chambliss
Cut Oliver

Marcus Giles, Wally Backman, Felipe Alou

[Warner2BruceTD]

Lloyd Moseby and Chris Chambliss over Al Oliver?

Moseby is a .250 hitter who I dont think was even an all star. Oliver was a .320 hitter in his prime who won a batting title, was a yearly all star, and probably almost had 3000 hits and 200 HR's.

[NAHSTE]

Gonna restart this:

Start, sit our cut?


Rex Hudler
Mark Lemke
Tim Naehring