Giants or Eagles

[Rayman]

This conversation can go on and on - but the bottom line is in the last couple of years the Giants have won 3 Superbowls - Playing in 4, How many have the Eagles won?.

[Rayman]

ya won 1 last couple of years and appeared in 1 last couple of years

That's like me saying the Cowboys have won 3 Super Bowls and numerous playoff games in the last couple of years.

[G-men]

Wanna flame him now for stating the truth?

no because he stated facts. you just talked shit and showed you have no idea what you are talking about.

[G-men]

who ? who ? and who? , stop being a homer man....i think its a close one because every year either Eagles or Giants win the division + it dont really matter who wins da division because last year we won the wildcard and beat the Giants in the 2nd round. big whoop.


McNabb>Eli
Eagles RB's < Giants RB's
Eagles WR's> Giants WR's
Eagles D-line < Giants D-Line
Eagles O-line > Giants O-line
Eagles LB's < Giants LB's
Eagles CB's > Giants CB's
Eagles S's > Giants S's
idk bout ST's cause idk who giants PR and KR's are.

on paper eagles are better but i still say its a tie.

i agree with all of this except i would say the o-lines are equal.

[BWEISS]

That's like me saying the Cowboys have won 3 Super Bowls and numerous playoff games in the last couple of years.

It'd acutally be like saying the Cowboys havent won a playoff game since 1996

What he said was actually pretty accurate, Eagles went to XXXIX and the Giants won XLII... thats pretty recent man...

[Juggernaut]

i agree with all of this except i would say the o-lines are equal.

I'd still give it to the Giants, maybe at the end of the season when we can look back, yet i'll have to give it to the Giants since all of them know the system

[G-men]

you guys are all so bitchy he probably meant to say decades.

[Rayman]

It'd acutally be like saying the Cowboys havent won a playoff game since 1996

What he said was actually pretty accurate, Eagles went to XXXIX and the Giants won XLII... thats pretty recent man...

Reading comprehension FTL

This conversation can go on and on - but the bottom line is in the last couple of years the Giants have won 3 Superbowls - Playing in 4, How many have the Eagles won?.

[Archer]

Wanna flame him now for stating the truth?

This coming from the kid who said the Eagles are better than the Steelers cause they won a regular season game and said Jim Johnson held back the Eagles from winning a superbowl with his cancer.

Also said the Eagles have basicly won 2 superbowls because they were cheated 2times (Pats and Raiders) and then said Mcnabb and Peyton are equal because they are both "chokers" but McNabb is a sure fire hall of famer .

Also check my sig if you need any more to add to this conversation

[seaplus]

eagles

i would go with the giants if andre brown was starting since he is their best RB now :D ;)

[celtsxpatsxsox]

Cowboys ftw! lol jk. Giants only won one SB btw.

no they have 3
2008
1987
1991

[G-men]

Yeah, I know but he said in the last couple of years. I'm guessing its just a mistake.

you must just be really slow at picking things up.

[Wrath]

I think Philly has the better team and will win the division.

But I think New York has the better franchise, at least until the Eagles find a suitable quarterback to take over once #5 hangs it up. Kevin Kolb is a fucking joke. He's in John Beck's league. Neither quarterback should've ever been in the draft.

I agree with your post except about Kevin Kolb because it's way too early to write him off yet. I mean what player would do well in their first game action at Baltimore. But yeah, Eagles will be better this year, but the Giants are the better franchise because they have won rings period.

[Flight24]

better team next year? eagles. the eagles were the better team last year (not record wise, but they knocked new york out of the playoffs) and they've become a better team while the giants in my opinion have become worse. mcnabb and westbrook staying healthy is really going to ddetermine how the eagles finish though because kolb is garbage and you cant really rely on lesean mccoy to hold up the running back spot.