Steve McNair dead

[T.Dot]

Did Culpepper win an MVP? I'm not completely sure. And unlike Daunte, McNair played in a Super Bowl, and never fell off the face off the earth like Culpepper when he played for the Raiders and the Lions.

no MVP, no Super Bowl but I guarantee that if Culpepper had a defense like McNair had on the Titans he would have won a couple and Daunte fell off the face of the earth because of injuries, arguably worse than any McNair suffered

[ZoneBlitz]

W2B would attend McNair's funeral just to argue about this with everyone there.

[Warner2BruceTD]

W2B would attend McNair's funeral just to argue about this with everyone there.

I mean, c'mon....Montana, Graham, Unitas, Marino....McNair?

Really?

[Liquidrob]

He isnt a HOF player, you guys are silly

Very good QB, but it stops there

[DDRGuido]

If McNair gets in the HOF and McNabb doesn't, then something is wrong in Canton.

[Nukleopatra]

Lol @ one of the best quarterbacks to ever play the game.

Jesus Christ.

When I die, I wonder if I'll become one of the best at what I do.. Because like McNair's NFL career, I'm above average at what I do.

R.I.P - That's as far as I go.

[ZoneBlitz]

Lol @ one of the best quarterbacks to ever play the game.

Jesus Christ.

When I die, I wonder if I'll become one of the best at what I do.. Because like McNair's NFL career, I'm above average at what I do.

R.I.P - That's as far as I go.

Except you would be caught cheating with another man, not woman (allegedly).

[EmpireWF]

McNair had some great seasons and was among the better QBs of his generation, but he was not a HOF QB.

[BigBiss]

Not Sure if this has been metioned but i really hope this does not send Vince Young off the deepend.

[Nukleopatra]

Except you would be caught cheating with another man, not woman (allegedly).

It would all be worth it, if my legacy would be forever known as the guy who came up 1 yard short. Personally, I'll remember him as the guy who threw the ball 15 yards too short, because he was outclassed by a better quarterback on the other side. Reverse roles, and Warner would have had that ball in the endzone.

If you people want to praise the guy for being one of the ''best,'' that's your right. The guy was a decent NFL player, with questionable decison making in key moments. He wasn't the best, or one of the best. He's wasn't even better than McNabb.

And believe it or not, most NFL players play in pain. McNair just made sure we all knew about it.

[Helicopter]

Sad story. I feel for those closest to him, but he's not a HOFer.

[Deviant]

Wow. What a bunch of douchebags. I mean, really, the man just died yesterday and some of you have to get up on your high horses and talk about how he wasn't that great of a quarterback and that he doesn't belong in the Hall of Fame. Who cares? His teammates and players around the NFL loved this guy and respected him. He played with great heart on the field and was a great field general. He was the face of the Titans just like Moon was the face when they were the Oilers. Threw for 30,000+ and scored 200+ TDs passing and on the ground. The guy was a great quarterback and was certainly a great of his time and there are many quarterbacks who wished they could have the career he had or played the game like he did.

Requiescat in pace.

[The Messenger]

Wow. What a bunch of douchebags. I mean, really, the man just died yesterday and some of you have to get up on your high horses and talk about how he wasn't that great of a quarterback and that he doesn't belong in the Hall of Fame. Who cares? His teammates and players around the NFL loved this guy and respected him. He played with great heart on the field and was a great field general. He was the face of the Titans just like Moon was the face when they were the Oilers. Threw for 30,000+ and scored 200+ TDs passing and on the ground. The guy was a great quarterback and was certainly a great of his time and there are many quarterbacks who wished they could have the career he had or played the game like he did.

Requiescat in pace.

Except, there's people on here claiming McNair's a HoF QB when he wasn't.

And no one's taking a piss on his dead body, just remarking that his career is not what a lot of these other people are making it out to be.

[jags224]

crazy stuff i was on my way to the fireworks when my boy texted me and told me

rip air mcnair..

[Rayman]

Not Sure if this has been metioned but i really hope this does not send Vince Young off the deepend.

Actually one of the first things I thought about.

Didn't want to say it, though.