Best NFL WR?

[Saluki]

Rank the TOP NFL wideouts from this season so far.

[Magnetic Spectrum]

andre johnson still not number 3 overall

[Buzzman]

#1 Calvin Johnson

who cares about the rest.

[Saluki]

#1 Calvin Johnson

who cares about the rest.

What the hell are you smokin?

He's 9th in reciving yards, 41st in receptions, he's tied with 10 guys with 5TDs and his team is losing. What makes him the best wr in the lg?

[DSpydr84]

I guess stats mean everything...

Why not just check out NFL.com to see who the best is if we're playing the numbers?

[Buzzman]

no im not saying hes the top WR

there is no ture #1 WR in the league. There are a bunch of great WRS.

Calvin if he was in a more aggressive offense would get more catches and yards.

I hate when I see the CB 10-12 yards off him and they dont throw a quick pass to him. I see Steve Smith and Jake D have a little thing where if the CB is that far off they automatically know to throw a quick pass.

[steeljake]

steve smith is a top guy, he is just so fast. Hines ward would have to be up there as well. I am really fucked up from the pills right now, so my list will be up later.

[j.hen]

Roddy White.

[/homer]

[Saluki]

I guess stats mean everything...

Why not just check out NFL.com to see who the best is if we're playing the numbers?

Even if you don't look at his stats, Calvin Johnson isn't enough of a force to be considered a top WR this season. Especially not when he had such high expectations coming out of college.

In my mind a Top WR is a guy who you know can make the big catch or get the big Y.A.C. when u really need it, or guys that are consistent producers for their teams. Calvin Johnson is neither.

[BWEISS]

Im going to say Boldin is the top right now

[Saluki]

Boldin is def up there. So is Fitz.

[Chadman]

Are we talking talent wise or production wise?

Talent wise as a wide receiver meaning hands, route running etc

1. Chad Johnson
2. Steve Smith
3. Larry Fitzgerald
4. Brandon Marshall
5. Calvin Johnson
6. Randy Moss
7. Andre Johnson
8. Boldin
9. T.O
10. Plax


I dont how boldin gets the respect he receives when he hasnt done much the past 2 years but be injured.....the stats may not show it but he hasnt actually been consistent. hes like chad in a since....puts up monster numbers in few games.

[BonesMahoney95]

Antonio Bryant.

[Chadman]

Antonio Bryant.

[BWEISS]

Are we talking talent wise or production wise?

Talent wise as a wide receiver meaning hands, route running etc

1. Chad Johnson
2. Steve Smith
3. Larry Fitzgerald
4. Brandon Marshall
5. Calvin Johnson
6. Randy Moss
7. Andre Johnson
8. Boldin
9. T.O
10. Plax


I dont how boldin gets the respect he receives when he hasnt done much the past 2 years but be injured.....the stats may not show it but he hasnt actually been consistent. hes like chad in a since....puts up monster numbers in few games.

You sure about Chad Johnson?