Enough is enough. Peyton Manning is the greatest QB of all time.

[Maynard]

who wins a Super Bowl and how many times you get there as an individual is irrelevant in a team sport in the entirety of a individual career and yet he's been to 3 with 2 different teams which is hard as heck to do. He owns all the stats and is incredibly successful at his position. He like Favre is one of the greatest of all time along with Brady because those guys own all the stats.


as a side note...Kurt Warner is like the Gayle Sayers of QBs because he did a lot in a very short time.

...its a shame NY wasn't gelling when he was there. That would have been fantastic !

he plays in a pass happy era so his stats are marginally better. he has the worst post season record and only won 1 SB.

you act like only his regular season numbers matter. Well if thats the case then how is Manning better than Marino considering Marino put up manning record like # back in 1984 when the league wasnt all about the pass.

his regular season record and number are outstanding, but his post season numbers MUST be taken into account when referring to him as the goat. You must have the total package when it comes to being the goat. Joe Montana is the only QB with the stats, the regular season, the post season and the SB numbers. Manning only has 2 of those qualifiers.

[Glenbino]

he plays in a pass happy era so his stats are marginally better. he has the worst post season record and only won 1 SB.

you act like only his regular season numbers matter. Well if thats the case then how is Manning better than Marino considering Marino put up manning record like # back in 1984 when the league wasnt all about the pass.

his regular season record and number are outstanding, but his post season numbers MUST be taken into account when referring to him as the goat. You must have the total package when it comes to being the goat. Joe Montana is the only QB with the stats, the regular season, the post season and the SB numbers. Manning only has 2 of those qualifiers.

Manning has the worst playoff record because he's in the playoffs EVERY SINGLE YEAR.

That wasn't the case with Marino, Favre or even Brees.

Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

[Aso]

Peyton Manning doesn't have the worst playoff record he has the most losses. Big difference which considering how many times he's been there isn't really that surprising.

[Houston]

Well if thats the case then how is Manning better than Marino considering Marino put up manning record like # back in 1984 when the league wasnt all about the pass.

Marino doesn't have a ring.

[ram29jackson]

Marino doesn't have a ring.

yes he does. You do get rings for winning conference championships and losing SBs too

http://www.hoffco-inc.com/sb/rings-conf.html

[Warner2BruceTD]

Peyton Manning is 11-11 now in the postseason and is headed to his third Super Bowl with a second team. It's time to drop the goofy "He has a bad playoff record!!!" narrative. It's false.

His postseason QR Rating is now over 90, and he hasn't played a bad playoff game since 2006 - and that's the year he won the SB.

"Peyton isn't good in the playoffs!!" is just shit people say now. It simply isn't true.

The anti Peyton crowd is running out of talking points, and it's great. When he wins this Super Bowl, they have none left. It's over. I will no longer accept arguments for any other QB. The book will be closed.

[Maynard]

Manning has the worst playoff record because he's in the playoffs EVERY SINGLE YEAR.

so was joe montana.

[Glenbino]

so was joe montana.

Well if you wanna play the "era" game I could point out that Montana played in an age where Eddie DeBartolo could spend anything he wanted to keep those teams together.

It's still a team sport.

Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

[ram29jackson]

Well if you wanna play the "era" game I could point out that Montana played in an age where Eddie DeBartolo could spend anything he wanted to keep those teams together.

It's still a team sport.

Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

and no one took away his trophies after he got busted either

[Maynard]

Well if you wanna play the "era" game I could point out that Montana played in an age where Eddie DeBartolo could spend anything he wanted to keep those teams together.

It's still a team sport.

Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

era game? you said Manning has the worst record because he goes to the playoffs every year....i said so does montana. how is that an era thing?

can anyone make a valid argument that manning is the better QB over Montana? no, you cant. thats why manning isnt the goat...Montana is.

[ram29jackson]

era game? you said Manning has the worst record because he goes to the playoffs every year....i said so does montana. how is that an era thing?

can anyone make a valid argument that manning is the better QB over Montana? no, you cant. thats why manning isnt the goat...Montana is.

3 people already did, you lose..again

[Glenbino]

era game? you said Manning has the worst record because he goes to the playoffs every year....i said so does montana. how is that an era thing?

can anyone make a valid argument that manning is the better QB over Montana? no, you cant. thats why manning isnt the goat...Montana is.

You've tried to marginalize the fact that Manning's numbers will dwarf those of Montana when all is said and done because he plays in a pass happy era.

I say fine.

Then I should be able to disqualify Montana's greater team accomplishments and playoff record because he played in an era more conducive to building and maintaining a super team.

Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

[Maynard]

You've tried to marginalize the fact that Manning's numbers will dwarf those of Montana when all is said and done because he plays in a pass happy era.

I say fine.

Then I should be able to disqualify Montana's greater team accomplishments and playoff record because he played in an era more conducive to building and maintaining a super team.

Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk

really? this is you r argument for why manning is better than montana...fail

[Maynard]

3 people already did, you lose..again

you think trent dilfer in an elite QB.

[Glenbino]

really? this is you r argument for why manning is better than montana...fail

What happened? Out of troll bait?

Sent from my HTC6500LVW using Tapatalk