The problem with Tony Romo

[ZAN]

If the Cowboys were to get gritty and pound the ball more, they'd be hard to beat. Their OL is arguably bigger than any OL in the league...

[Rayman]

Catch-22 style? Nasty part of the movie.

EDIT: RayMan's last post was on Sunday 11/15. Anybody else worried about him?

You've mentioned me in nearly 10 posts between the last time I was here and now.

Holy shit, get off my nuts.

[Derrville]

There is a difference. I believe there are levels of guys. Peyton, Brady, and Brees are obviously the top 3. Then there is Rivers, Roethlisberger, Favre, and Warner. Those guys I think most can agree are the leagues top 7 quarterbacks. After that comes the Romo, McNabb, Rodgers, Flacco and others group. Those guys can be placed all over the place.

Exactly how i feel.

[Woy]

Well, we know RayMan isn't dead.

[Rayman]

Well, we know RayMan isn't dead.

Any room left on the Vince Young Bandwagon?

[Esjay]

Any room left on the Vince Young Bandwagon?

I'm guessing you could probably find room. :nana:

[Rayman]

I'm guessing you could probably find room. :nana:

Only after I'm done with Peyton.

:heart:

[Woy]

Any room left on the Vince Young Bandwagon?

Hop right on. He does have the third best record as a starting quarterback this year. ;)

[nflman2033]

No, no he isn't. Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Brett Favre Phillip Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Aaron Rodgers, Donovan McNabb, and Joe Flacco are all better quarterbacks and theres a few more guys who you could also argue for.

i was with you right up until you put McNabb on there..

[mgoblue2290]

i was with you right up until you put McNabb on there..

I'd still put him in the same group as Romo. He'd be at the back end of that group though now.

[bringbackjimmy]

No, no he isn't. Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Brett Favre Phillip Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Aaron Rodgers, Donovan McNabb, and Joe Flacco are all better quarterbacks and theres a few more guys who you could also argue for.

Ok i can understand Manning, brady,brees,rivers, roethlisberger. In all hoensty how can you put Rodgers, mcnabb, and Flacco over Romo?

Is it's Flacco leading the Ravens to a mediocre season? or is it his last yrs performance of 14TD/12 INT care taker season?

Mcnabb is Mr. Choke so how he can be better than romo is beyond comprehension. The eagles probably would have won a SB during his time if they let him be what he does best and be a care taker while letting westbrook be the focus. Somebody said Romo would puke and crap his pant's if he was on the steelers final drive, well Mcnabb did puke .

I would say Rodgers is about even with Romo, but he does take alot of sacks where he holds on to the ball way to long(makes his line look worse than it is, they still suck but he makes them look worse)....

My top 10 would be right now putting in current/past/future:
Tier1
1.Manning
2.Brady
3.Brees
Tier2
4.Rivers
5.Romo
6.Roethlisberger
7.Rodgers
Tier3
8.Favre
9.Palmer
10.Warner

Favre is in the best situation he could ever dream with AP and a young talented Recieving corp and longterm is always uncertain. Warner has 2 top 10 wr and a pretty good number 3 so i will not put him over guys like the 4 R's.

[Woy]

Umm Donovan McNabb led the Eagles to the NFC Championship five times, four of them with mediocre receivers. That argument doesn't help your case.

And LOL @ you still having Romo over Roethlisberger...and fucking Warner? What a joke.

[bucky]

You've mentioned me in nearly 10 posts between the last time I was here and now.

Holy shit, get off my nuts.

Where ya been? Glad your OK.
A little sensitive aren't ya? Dude, I was just having a little fun with ya. Chill out.

[kbpsu]

My top 10 would be right now putting in current/past/future:
Tier1
1.Manning
2.Brady
3.Brees
Tier2
4.Rivers
5.Romo
6.Roethlisberger
7.Rodgers
Tier3
8.Favre
9.Palmer
10.Warner

Favre is in the best situation he could ever dream with AP and a young talented Recieving corp and longterm is always uncertain. Warner has 2 top 10 wr and a pretty good number 3 so i will not put him over guys like the 4 R's.

W.O.W.
........this is easily the worst top 10 QB list I have ever seen. Do you actually watch football on Sundays?

[bringbackjimmy]

Umm Donovan McNabb led the Eagles to the NFC Championship five times, four of them with mediocre receivers. That argument doesn't help your case.

And LOL @ you still having Romo over Roethlisberger...and fucking Warner? What a joke.

Warner???? honestly you can put any decent QB in there and look great...4-7 are interchangable so i really don't see the problem with the list...

I am done i am wrong i guess take Romo out of the top 10 hell take him out of the top 25 I don't care...sorry for having a opinion on such a opinion subject as a top 10 list or who is somethinks is better......