Is Miles Austin the best wide receiver in the NFL?

[Irish]

 

My boy with the best TD catch that wasn't called a TD.

[MvP]

He is repping Monmouth very nicely...but he isn't even top 10 yet alone number one.

I'm hoping when he comes back to visit campus next year he brings along Kim. :crowd:

[dave]

Brent Grimes | 2010 Pro Bowl | 15 INT's

Linebackers can do that in Madden.
Sadly, defensive backs can't.

[ram29jackson]

Oh no! The insane laughter has returned!! Make it stop!

el oh el :uglyhammer:

[steeljake]

No.

But he's in the top 10 conversation and can still make improvements to his game.

really... here are 10 wr's that are better than he is right fucking now:

andre johnson
reggie wayne
steve smith
santonio holmes
randy moss
wes welker
brandon marshall
anthony gonzales
anquain boldin
calvin johnson

i would also include hines ward, marques colston, larry fitzgerald, ochocinco, greg jennings and donald driver ahead of miles as well. let the man put up more than just one season with decent numbers before he starts making list you fucking homer.

[Aso]

really... here are 10 wr's that are better than he is right fucking now:

andre johnson
reggie wayne
steve smith
santonio holmes
randy moss
wes welker
brandon marshall
anthony gonzales
anquain boldin
calvin johnson

i would also include hines ward, marques colston, larry fitzgerald, ochocinco, greg jennings and donald driver ahead of miles as well. let the man put up more than just one season with decent numbers before he starts making list you fucking homer.

So you're gonna talk about players needing more than one season before they make top ten lists yet your list of players includes Santonio Holmes, Anthony Gonzales (lol), and Calvin Johnson...?

[steeljake]

So you're gonna talk about players needing more than one season before they make top ten lists yet your list of players includes Santonio Holmes, Anthony Gonzales (lol), and Calvin Johnson...?

wow... i always knew you were an idiot...

holmes - 5th season (his accolades include a super bowl mvp)

calvin johnson - 3rd season - despite being ona team that went 0-16 he still had 1k yards and 12 td in 08 and he missed 1k yards by less than 20 and had 5 td's despite being out for two games.

I will admit that gonzo is a reach seeing as how he has been hurt and miles played a full season as a starter (technically he started just 9 of 16 games) in just his third year on the active roster.


come on aso, stop trying to piggy back on other people's opinion and form your own for once... honestly it won't hurt you.

[Miami Flash15]

Nope, Ted Ginn is!

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYSxJgjjJFc"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYSxJgjjJFc[/ame]

[Chadman]

miles austin's route tree isnt exactly diverse. mfer is the king of slants. jus throwing that out there.

[steeljake]

miles austin's route tree isnt exactly diverse. mfer is the king of slants. jus throwing that out there.

does he catch the ball away from his body?

[Aso]

wow... i always knew you were an idiot...

holmes - 5th season (his accolades include a super bowl mvp)

calvin johnson - 3rd season - despite being ona team that went 0-16 he still had 1k yards and 12 td in 08 and he missed 1k yards by less than 20 and had 5 td's despite being out for two games.

I will admit that gonzo is a reach seeing as how he has been hurt and miles played a full season as a starter (technically he started just 9 of 16 games) in just his third year on the active roster.


come on aso, stop trying to piggy back on other people's opinion and form your own for once... honestly it won't hurt you.

Whoa, really? SuperBowl MVP.. wow, you're right. He is top 10. He had only one really good season despite having Big Ben at QB and being on a pass first team. He is good but still only had 1 good season.

And if you almost have 1K yards all of a sudden you're elite? And 5 td's, is that suppose to be good?

Piggybacking on other people's opinion? Who else has my opinion in this thread? The only person that posted before me after you're post is glenwillet and he didn't post anything like I did.

It's ridiculous to say you can't even consider Miles Austin to be in a top 10 list while it's not to say Santonio Holmes or Calvin Johnson can.

[jags224]

is that a rhetorical question?

[Chadman]

does he catch the ball away from his body?

Does my job pay more than yours and i am only 18?

[corbin]

lol @ this thread, anyone who thinks Miles Austin is the best receiver needs their head checked immediately.

The dude can slide into the top 10 depending on your opinion of certain players but he's not even close to being in the elite category of WRs.

[packersfan4eva]

If he has another amazing season or two, then he can be considered for the top spot.