Who has your vote for Heisman?

[1ke]

I dont get why people feel the need to argue for argues sake.

RG3. Its fucking Baylor!!!! Nuff said.

[Bear Pand]

Heisman trophy fell off. Just doesn't seem like it holds a ton of meaning anymore. Like last year when Ingram won it was just like "oh neat," then 2 mins later I was past it.



Am I the only one who feels this way?

[Tengo Juego]

Heisman trophy fell off. Just doesn't seem like it holds a ton of meaning anymore. Like last year when Ingram won it was just like "oh neat," then 2 mins later I was past it.



Am I the only one who feels this way?

Cam Newton won it last season.

[Rudi]

The more I ponder this, the more I can see how anyone could make a case for atleast 5 players [RGIII, Honey Badger, Montee Ball, Luck, Barkley]. Such a wide open race.

[Bear Pand]

Cam Newton won it last season.

Ya thats how bad it's gotten for me, I have a hard time even remembering who won it and when.

[Woy]

The more I ponder this, the more I can see how anyone could make a case for atleast 5 players [RGIII, Honey Badger, Montee Ball, Luck, Barkley]. Such a wide open race.

You can't make a case for Luck. Ball and Barkley, meh.

RG3 and Mathieu are the only two who deserve it in my mind.

[nesper]

when ball got hurt in the first wisky/msu game he missed one offensive series.

[Champ]

Russell Wilson

[NAHSTE]

Russell Wilson

[West]

[NAHSTE]

Oh hai there it's me Passing Efficiency and I like RGIII more now.

http://web1.ncaa.org/mfb/natlRank.jsp?year=2011&rpt=IA_playerpasseff&site=org&div=IA&dest=O

[Obst]

Richardson wins Heisman, Bama gets in the National Championship, ESPN is happy.

[Sportsbuck]

Since it's that time of year, here's a good place to keep track of the Heisman votes that writers/winners make public:

http://www.stiffarmtrophy.com/

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

This year literally has no real deserving winners of the Heisman, but in that, you might actually get a real winner...not this "QB or RB from a Top 5 team that isn't really good" selection. Ala, the Jason White, Mark Ingram, Troy Smith, Eric Crouch type winner.

Griffin had a great season, but completely shitting the bed against Okie State leaves me "meh".
Luck had a great season and is the best player in CFB, but he didn't have a good game versus Oregon.
Richardson had a great season, but isn't the reason his team 11-1, and Montee Ball has a better resume as a running back despite being a cherry picker.
Case Keenum had an awful game versus Southern Miss.
Kellen Moore was the best QB in college football all season, but lets be honest, no one is voting for Kellen Moore nationally, unfortunately.
Brandon Weeden isn't the best player on his team (Blackmon is)
Barkley had a big season, but he wasn't lights out early on and plays for a team that doesn't matter.
Tyrann Matthieu makes a lot of plays and is a buzzsaw, but you need to be Charles Woodson to win the Heisman as a CB, and Matthieu can't cover like Woodson.
Russell Wilson will split votes with a guy on his own team (Ball).


I saw Luke Kuechly was getting some ESPN votes. lulz. He's good though.

All of these guys have warts...big warts.

[ralaw]

This year literally has no real deserving winners of the Heisman, but in that, you might actually get a real winner...not this "QB or RB from a Top 5 team that isn't really good" selection. Ala, the Jason White, Mark Ingram, Troy Smith, Eric Crouch type winner.

Griffin had a great season, but completely shitting the bed against Okie State leaves me "meh".
Luck had a great season and is the best player in CFB, but he didn't have a good game versus Oregon.
Richardson had a great season, but isn't the reason his team 11-1, and Montee Ball has a better resume as a running back despite being a cherry picker.
Case Keenum had an awful game versus Southern Miss.
Kellen Moore was the best QB in college football all season, but lets be honest, no one is voting for Kellen Moore nationally, unfortunately.
Brandon Weeden isn't the best player on his team (Blackmon is)
Barkley had a big season, but he wasn't lights out early on and plays for a team that doesn't matter.
Tyrann Matthieu makes a lot of plays and is a buzzsaw, but you need to be Charles Woodson to win the Heisman as a CB, and Matthieu can't cover like Woodson.
Russell Wilson will split votes with a guy on his own team (Ball).


I saw Luke Kuechly was getting some ESPN votes. lulz. He's good though.

All of these guys have warts...big warts.

What are your thoughts on Tyrann Mathieu ? He's seemed to have the big moments people like to see from a Heisman candidate.