Who is the most overrated and underrated player?

[Gonzo]

I know, he's a hard-ass hitter man. Very underrated.

[Maestro]

Out of all the starting QB's in the NFL i would not pick Favre or Romo to lead my team on a game winning drive,they play a little outta control and tend to lock on to one receiver.

[Primetime]

Favre isint there though , however i agree , its up to you as qb to lead the team down on what could be a game winning drive . How can him throwing them 3 ints be on the defence ? hell if the colts D (using them cause i support them) put peyton in position to drive down and win the game id be happy with them .

Rodgers is young tho , he has time to get that winning "favre factor" if you may into him

I agree that Rodgers will one day grow into the role as the starting QB for the Packers. Favre was traded according to Ted Thompson because Rodgers was ready to step in and be the leader, which he is not. Favre gives you a chance to win (and lose) every single game at any point in the game. Rodgers does not. Once the Packers are down, Rodgers' abilities seem to fade away.

[Archer]

I agree that Rodgers will one day grow into the role as the starting QB for the Packers. Favre was traded according to Ted Thompson because Rodgers was ready to step in and be the leader, which he is not. Favre gives you a chance to win (and lose) every single game at any point in the game. Rodgers does not. Once the Packers are down, Rodgers' abilities seem to fade away.

yeah iv saw that when iv watched them , but only watching him say 4times this season isint enough for me to give a full opinion on him

[Maestro]

I agree that Rodgers will one day grow into the role as the starting QB for the Packers. Favre was traded according to Ted Thompson because Rodgers was ready to step in and be the leader, which he is not. Favre gives you a chance to win (and lose) every single game at any point in the game. Rodgers does not. Once the Packers are down, Rodgers' abilities seem to fade away.

That i agree with,he isnt ready to be a leader,but he was ready to be a starting QB in the NFL.

[Magnetic Spectrum]

when did rookies start being overrated,what has royal done to become overrated?just wonderin

[celtsxpatsxsox]

overrated- Brett Favre, Chad Johnson(this year), Terrel Owens, Ben Watson

underrated- Sammy Morris, Kevin Faulk, Donavan Mcnabb