Don Frye with some Texas Straight Talk

[Warner2BruceTD]

You put Brock in your top 10 POUND FOR POUND, lol

Scammed by hype, BOOM! ITS THE ULTIMATE! YOU GUNNA GET KNOCKED OUT!

You know damn well I was confused by the thread, I will stab you.

 

[Liquidrob]

You know damn well I was confused by the thread, I will stab you.

Yes, I can see how a thread titled 'your top 10 P4P fighters' could be confusing

 

[EmpireWF]

All you guys fell for the Brock hype, you were scammed Bob Sapp style, putting Brock at number 1 and all that jazz, the jig is up, but I'm sure he will fight Mur again and the hype will continue, lol @ 7 UFC fights and 3 of them being Mur

So Brock @ 1 was a fraud with a 5-1 record despite Fedor losing.

But Cain @ 1 with a 9-0 record over apparent "frauds" (in your mind) Brock and Big Nog....is okay?

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

Yes, I can see how a thread titled 'your top 10 P4P fighters' could be confusing

The thread had spiraled off into RANKINGS and arguing the difference, you geek, now stop trolling sucka.

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

That's the same thread where I had the intestinal fortitude and amazing foresight to put GIL MELENDEZ in my p4p top 10, despite laughter and snickers from the gallery. w00t

 

[Liquidrob]

You were confused? Oh really...

You guys are selling someone short here...

Brock Lesnar has been as dominant as anyone, and he avenged his one fluky loss, just like GSP avenged his fluky loss vs. Serra.

He belongs among the top 10 in the world, especially over a guy like Nog who has looked like dogshit recently until Saturday.

1. Anderson Silva
2. Fedor
3. GSP
4. Machida
5. Mike Brown
6. Lesnar
7. Mousasi
8. Penn
9. Henderson
10. Melendez

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

The thread had spiraled off into RANKINGS and arguing the difference, you geek, now stop trolling sucka.

 

[Liquidrob]

So are these your HW rankings or P4P rankings? I can't really tell with Anderson 1 and Gil number 10, strange HW rankings than

Just admit you bought the hype and move on, you are just making a fool of yourself now

sidenote: the thread was not about rankings at that point or derailed, just stop

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

From the same thread:

Sometimes you guys get wrapped up in this mythical idea of skillsets and things like technical striking, which admittedly is where the debates come in, but wins and losses should always be #1

W2B, its P4P which means 'Pound for Pound', the term was created for the fighters with skill sets who would never be able to beat the bigger fighters, and yes, it is mythical

I made a list of the top ten guys based on W's & L's, had nothing to do with skillsets & technical striking & all the other stuff you guys were jabbering on about.

 

[Liquidrob]

That's the same thread where I had the intestinal fortitude and amazing foresight to put GIL MELENDEZ in my p4p top 10, despite laughter and snickers from the gallery. w00t

You guys are selling someone short here...

Brock Lesnar has been as dominant as anyone, and he avenged his one fluky loss, just like GSP avenged his fluky loss vs. Serra.

He belongs among the top 10 in the world, especially over a guy like Nog who has looked like dogshit recently until Saturday.

1. Anderson Silva
2. Fedor
3. GSP
4. Machida
5. Mike Brown
6. Lesnar
7. Mousasi
8. Penn
9. Henderson
10. Melendez

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

This is also why I couldnt understand how you guys had Torres over Bowles, when Bowles had just beat him convincingly. I was ranking guys on results, and results alone.

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

What are you missing here? You are rehashing the same argument we had in that thread, and you still arent getting it.

I was looking at it as a results oriented list of all fighters across all weights, which wasnt what you guys were doing.

 

[Liquidrob]

JUST STOP

It was a P4P thread, you posted your P4P list, stop spinning goofball

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

JUST STOP

It was a P4P thread, you posted your P4P list, stop spinning goofball

What the hell am I spinning?? I'm defending myself if the SAME EXACT MANNER I defended my self in the original thread! I even posted the quotes!

I listed 10 guys based on recent W-L record, you guys were doing something else.

 

[Liquidrob]

that was your P4P list, it was the only list you posted in the thread and you just said IN THIS THREAD you were the only one to have the vision to put Gil in the top 10 P4P, so which is it?

That's the same thread where I had the intestinal fortitude and amazing foresight to put GIL MELENDEZ in my p4p top 10, despite laughter and snickers from the gallery. w00t

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

that was your P4P list, it was the only list you posted in the thread and you just said IN THIS THREAD you were the only one to have the vision to put Gil in the top 10 P4P, so which is it?

EXACTLY ROB, we have come full circle. This is why I admitted I was confused in the first thread, and quoted the explaination you gave from the same thread.

My "p4p" list was a RANKING of ten fighters, regardless of weight, based on wins & losses. Which is why it also made absolutely no sense to me that EVERYONE had Torres over Bowles, when Bowles had just beat him head to head.

I wasnt doing a traditional p4p, I thought you guys were just ranking fighters, notice how low I had Penn compared to everyone else.

This is dejavu.

 

[Liquidrob]

Yes, the thread title is very misleading

I guess we need a P4P list, a divisional rankings list and a special W2B NON-TRADITIONAL P4P RANKING BASED OFF WINS AND LOSSES list, but it only counts for his traditional P4P when talking about Gilbert Melendez

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

Yes, the thread title is very misleading

I guess we need a P4P list, a divisional rankings list and a special W2B NON-TRADITIONAL P4P RANKING BASED OFF WINS AND LOSSES list, but it only counts for his traditional P4P when talking about Gilbert Melendez

Did someone kick your dog today?

I've already conceded that I didn't understand. I was essentially combing divisional rankings and grouping all weights together, the rest of you were doing something else.

 

[Kuzzy Powers]

The Rob/W2B tension has been building forever and Rob finally snapping.

I love it.

 

[SHOGUN]

The Rob/W2B tension has been building forever and Rob finally snapping.

I love it.

Word.

opcorn: