Game of Thrones

[NAHSTE]

of course she's not taking the black, but thats the guise she's going around under, a boy taking the black

Yeah, I guess I should have saved my facepalm for the guy who thought she was becoming a pirate.

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

she was sent to the wall to be a slave/worker... did you not watch that part??

Arya was taken by Yoren, who is the recruiter for those being sent to the Wall...he is very intimate with the Stark's...he is the one who told Ned of Tyrion's capture by Catelyn (remember, Tyrion left the Wall with Yoren), recruited Jon Snow to the Wall, etc...he just kind of chilled out in the town recruiting for the Wall until Ned's death...he sees Arya, takes her, changes her identity and has her join his recruits to the Wall...Winterfell is on Kingsroad to the Wall.

You do not need to read the books to understand this.

 

[SethMode]

Arya was taken by Yoren, who is the recruiter for those being sent to the Wall...he is very intimate with the Stark's...he is the one who told Ned of Tyrion's capture by Catelyn (remember, Tyrion left the Wall with Yoren), recruited Jon Snow to the Wall, etc...he just kind of chilled out in the town recruiting for the Wall until Ned's death...he sees Arya, takes her, changes her identity and has her join his recruits to the Wall...Winterfell is on Kingsroad to the Wall.

You do not need to read the books to understand this.

I thought that the show was even MORE clear about this, because you can recognize Yoren by sight. IIRC, in book one, Ned gets his dome lopped off from Arya's point of view, and she doesn't recognize Yoren, and it's not like the description of him is so detailed that you go: "Oh, that's Yoren from the wall!"

Unless I'm misremembering it. I just remember finishing that chapter and being all, "What the hell!?" (for a number of reasons obviously).

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

I thought that the show was even MORE clear about this, because you can recognize Yoren by sight. IIRC, in book one, Ned gets his dome lopped off from Arya's point of view, and she doesn't recognize Yoren, and it's not like the description of him is so detailed that you go: "Oh, that's Yoren from the wall!"

Unless I'm misremembering it. I just remember finishing that chapter and being all, "What the hell!?" (for a number of reasons obviously).

I didn't understand she was with Yoren until Clash of Kings and then I had to go back and read, and it was an "ooooooh" moment.

 

[Sharkweather]

Downloaded this last night and just finished the season. It was as good as I had been hearing and I'm definitely hooked now. Going to look into buying the books before the next season.

 

[Rush]

It's always satisfying being able to watch everything and not having to worry about spoilers in the thread. Too bad this one has book spoilers.

Khol Drogo was one of the most badass characters ever. Without spoiling anything, will another character as awesome re-enter the story?

 

[St. Francisco]

It's always satisfying being able to watch everything and not having to worry about spoilers in the thread. Too bad this one has book spoilers.

Khol Drogo was one of the most badass characters ever. Without spoiling anything, will another character as awesome re-enter the story?

I'd say yes...the Viper of Dorne. But that won't be for a while.

 

[SethMode]

Don't read the spoiler unless you're at least 3/4 of the way through Book 3:

 

Robb and Cat getting betrayed by Frey and Bolton and that whole scene of he and his crew basically being systematically butchered was FUCKING GUT WRENCHING. I seriously could not think straight for a solid 10 minutes after, even though I kind of sensed that something bad was going to happen, but it still shocked me. It's murder for me too because all of my friends got into the series AFTER the show ended so most are either on book 1, or in the case of one friend he is on book 3 but in the first quarter. It's maddening. I need like a support group at this point.

 

[Saluki]

Don't read the spoiler unless you're at least 3/4 of the way through Book 3:

 

Robb and Cat getting betrayed by Frey and Bolton and that whole scene of he and his crew basically being systematically butchered was FUCKING GUT WRENCHING. I seriously could not think straight for a solid 10 minutes after, even though I kind of sensed that something bad was going to happen, but it still shocked me. It's murder for me too because all of my friends got into the series AFTER the show ended so most are either on book 1, or in the case of one friend he is on book 3 but in the first quarter. It's maddening. I need like a support group at this point.

 

Lol yeah that shit was FUCKING CRAZY. But its like i said, no ones safe in this series, at all. I kinda saw that scene coming, but i didn't know it'd be as bad as THAT.

 

[SethMode]

 

Lol yeah that shit was FUCKING CRAZY. But its like i said, no ones safe in this series, at all. I kinda saw that scene coming, but i didn't know it'd be as bad as THAT.

 

Yeah, like I said, I sort of saw SOME type of betrayal coming at the hands of that douchebag Frey, but the level of it was just bananas. And definitely no one is safe. It's crazy too how things just turn on a dime with his books too. One minute there's a bedding coming, the next Cat thinks she's overreacting to someone not wanting to dance, and then boom. Crazy shit.

 

[NAHSTE]

My girlfriend took book 1 with her on her trip.

 

[Saluki]

My girlfriend took book 1 with her on her trip.

Aw hell naw, when she walks in the door you need to be standing there like this.

 

 

[SethMode]

Saluki, having read the 4 out so far, how would you rank them? I am LOVING book 3 right now. Book 2 ended awesomely, but it took some time to pick up for me. Book 1 was great as well. As of now I'd probably go 3 > 1 > 2.

Some of the reviews on Amazon of 4 are somewhat negative, but part of me feels like that might be blowback from the delay between 3 and 4. Thoughts?

 

[Saluki]

Saluki, having read the 4 out so far, how would you rank them? I am LOVING book 3 right now. Book 2 ended awesomely, but it took some time to pick up for me. Book 1 was great as well. As of now I'd probably go 3 > 1 > 2.

Some of the reviews on Amazon of 4 are somewhat negative, but part of me feels like that might be blowback from the delay between 3 and 4. Thoughts?

Yeah 3 was prob the best, but it'd be hard for me to rank them. Four is the least popular because it's really only half a book. Alot of the characters dont have thier POV in it because he didn't want to make the book too long (its about 1100 pages i think). So in book 4 your left wondering what's going on with some of the other characters.

Book 5 is supposed to be really a book and a half, with the other half of what was supposed to go into book 4 in it according to Martin.

All that being said, for me it's prob equal across the board.

 

[mgoblue2290]

3 and 1 are equal to me. While 3 was better, 1 introduced us to the whole world. I'm always partial to the first book in any series. 2 is solid and 4 starts off slow but it picks up and ends up being alright. Book 5 had better blow 2 and 4 out of the water.

 

[SethMode]

Finally finished book 3, and while I normally would agree with you Mo about books kicking of a series, I have to definitively say that book 3 is my favorite. Although with all of the fucking craziness I don't even know how the story can continue, let alone have 4 (!!!) more books.

 

[Saluki]

Finally finished book 3, and while I normally would agree with you Mo about books kicking of a series, I have to definitively say that book 3 is my favorite. Although with all of the fucking craziness I don't even know how the story can continue, let alone have 4 (!!!) more books.

Cuz shits about to get real is how.

Don't read if you haven't read most of the books.

 

Think about it. The REAL wars havent even started yet. Theirs no white walkers past the wall yet, Dany and her dragons haven't come across the sea yet. Everything so far has been like an appetizer to all the REAL SHIT thats about to happen.

 

[SethMode]

Cuz shits about to get real is how.

Don't read if you haven't read most of the books.

 

Think about it. The REAL wars havent even started yet. Theirs no white walkers past the wall yet, Dany and her dragons haven't come across the sea yet. Everything so far has been like an appetizer to all the REAL SHIT thats about to happen.

 

Yeah, I mean, I was being rhetorical more than anything, but just SO much has fucking happened it's hard to believe I'm not even at the halfway point. Great fucking series. I'm a little too worn out from Book 3 to start 4 yet (3 puts you through the emotional ringer) but I hope to have 4 finished by the 12th when I receive 5. Here's hoping it doesn't take him 5 or 6 years to write book 6...

 

[NAHSTE]

Might as well have a separate thread for the book at this point.

 

[Houston]

Might as well have a separate thread for the book at this point.

This thread is a spoiler minefield.