Heisman Watch Thread

[G-men]

for an OSU fan, you have little faith in Pryor. but i completely agree with what you said about Robinson. if it were a two week season, it would really only be between him and Moore for the Heisman.

 

[SuperKevin]

for an OSU fan, you have little faith in Pryor. but i completely agree with what you said about Robinson. if it were a two week season, it would really only be between him and Moore for the Heisman.

Cam Newton disagrees

 

[KNUBB]

Patrick Peterson laughs at those guys

 

[Sportsbuck]

for an OSU fan, you have little faith in Pryor. but i completely agree with what you said about Robinson. if it were a two week season, it would really only be between him and Moore for the Heisman.

Pryor's a solid QB but he's nowhere near Heisman caliber.

 

[Maize]

yeah fuck you guys, the only mistake on my list was Jacory Harris to be honest.

Same. And I don't see Robinson as a Heisman candidate because I don't see Michigan as a BCS Bowl team. And that is the only way I see him getting invited to New York. I could potentially see a Maxwell Award and continual shattering of the record book. Nice thing is, he gets to front load his stats. Next two weeks, he should put up sick numbers. I don't see him playing much next week, but I can see him shredding BGSU.

Then we get MSU, a game that I can't get a good feel on. Heisman race will be incredibly interesting this year.

 

[Woy]

I don't know what to think.

Yeah, Denard has put up some sick stats, but he's done it against UCONN and ND... lets not pretend he's playing Alabama, or even Wisconsin at that. He doesn't face a legit defense until Michigan State, then has Iowa, and Penn State after that. If he's putting up half those numbers on the ground and not turning it over through the air, then my opinion will change.

Like I said, Denard has played outstanding so far. But he's done it against two horrible defenses.

BTW, your other mistake besides Harris was Pryor.

This is exactly what I would have said. I'm not going to buy into the Denard hype until he plays a legit defense.

 

[NAHSTE]

Patrick Peterson was limited on returns this week. Credit to Vandy's punter for some boomers.

Stevan Ridley handled himself well today, 17 carries for 158 yards. He's got 240 yards in two games, add him to the list. Oh and Russell Shepard upped his TD total to 3. Add him to the list also.

Yeah, LSU be cheesin'.

 

[NAHSTE]

Oh and big Drake Nevis had five tackles and 2.5 sacks. Add him to the list.

 

[Colonel Angus]

John Clay has 4 rushing TD's through these first 2 games despite limited snaps. They're saying he's still not 100% after offseason surgery on both ankles, so the other backups have been sharing the snaps.

 

[Fox1994]

I don't know what to think.

Yeah, Denard has put up some sick stats, but he's done it against UCONN and ND... lets not pretend he's playing Alabama, or even Wisconsin at that. He doesn't face a legit defense until Michigan State, then has Iowa, and Penn State after that. If he's putting up half those numbers on the ground and not turning it over through the air, then my opinion will change.

Like I said, Denard has played outstanding so far. But he's done it against two horrible defenses.

BTW, your other mistake besides Harris was Pryor.

Pryor played lights-out against Miami. And, as I see it, these preliminary lists don't have any mistakes... They're like the polls, players go up, down, or completely fall off based on their week-to-week performance.

Harris and Pryor both had potential to be Heisman candidates. Harris had a weak game, Pryor played strong.

 

[Cody]

Its almost safe to put Shoelace in the heisman race.

 

[Maize]

1. Kellen Moore
2. Ryan Mallett
3. Terrelle Pryor
4. Patrick Peterson
5. Ryan Broyles