Hester vs Jackson

[1ke]

Its your call in a hell in the Cell matchup......Who you got?

The kid who cartwheeled and fumbled at the 1 in the AA game....?

Or the first person EVER to for some reason have Madden give him 100 speed on the game, when he's not even the fastest Bear......?

Im biased here, but curious to see what everyone else thought. DeSean has been lightin it up recently.

 

[MrBill]

Hester is still a threat to score every time he touches the ball but Jackson is more explosive and a much better receiver so he gets the nod.

 

[Juggernaut]

It's a "what have you done for me lately" kind of reaction.

DeSean "Bouta Get Paid" Jackson

 

[1ke]

I still gotta go with my boy though. Although, what yall said is completely true....Unless im looking at the wrong stats, which I may be doing. But DeSean has only 1 return for a TD this season, while Devin has 2. Plus Devin still does it on KR sometimes......

 

[G-men]

Hester is still a threat to score every time he touches the ball but Jackson is more explosive and a much better receiver so he gets the nod.

the problem is, Hester doesn't touch the ball nearly as much as Jackson

 

[MrBill]

the problem is, Hester doesn't touch the ball nearly as much as Jackson

If Hester were a better receiver, then he would get those extra touches.

 

[j.hen]

Jackson is easily the fastest player in the NFL, he'd beat Hester in a foot race while high stepping the last 5 yards backwards with his tongue out.

 

[Blade]

Homer vote goes to DJax

 

[Colonel Angus]

Devin Hester just isn't a good WR. As far as returning skills its a wash.

 

[Kuzzy Powers]

As a punt returner? Devin. As a WR its not even debatable.

 

[Deviant]

As a PR/WR, DeSean Jackson wins hands down. Hester would edge him out as just a returner though.

 

[j.hen]

If Jackson was a KR/PR exclusively he'd have 10+ return TD's a season.

 

[Saluki]

Hester is tied for the most return TDs all time RIGHT NOW. And he has 1 more PR TD than Jackson even this season. If we're talkin return i don't see how you don't take Hester.

Now if we're talking WR then we shouldn't even be talkin. Jackson by a long shot.

Note: I voted assuming you ment who you'd take as a return man, cuz if you ment WR there wouldnt even be a reason to make a poll.

 

[wingsfan77]

DeSean hasn't returned that many punts this year, usually only when they need a big play, ala today. If he returned as many punts as Hester he'd probably have more TD's, plus DeSean doesn't return kick-offs.

 

[NAHSTE]

Jackson because he actually knows how to play football. Hester is so stupid that Miami tried him at three different positions and he never figured out any of them.

 

[Saluki]

DeSean hasn't returned that many punts this year, usually only when they need a big play, ala today. If he returned as many punts as Hester he'd probably have more TD's, plus DeSean doesn't return kick-offs.

Hester only has 8 more PRs than Jackson this year. With a higher return average 1 more TD and 2 less PR fumbles. I didn't count KRs cuz Jackson doesn't do those.

Jackson avgs 11 yards on his 20 PRs

Hester avgs 15 yards on his 28 PRs

Better Returner = Hester
Better everthing else = Jackson /thread

 

[inthecards21]

homer thought: Mike Wallace is one fast man

 

[1ke]

You dont need to be smart to run fast....Hester is a td Return from being in the HoF as a returner.

Saluki gets it....My bad i should have been more clear, I was only talking about as a Return man....

 

[Kuzzy Powers]

DeSean hasn't returned that many punts this year, usually only when they need a big play, ala today. If he returned as many punts as Hester he'd probably have more TD's, plus DeSean doesn't return kick-offs.

Daniel Manning does majority of the kick returning for the Bears aswell. Hester is MOSTLY used on PRs only. But when he does get a KR he is beastly there too. And its amazing how many times this guy has been dragged down right around the end zone or by the punter.. he should have a handful more return TDs in his career.

 

[Hasselbeck]

As a return man, Hester.

As a WR, Jackson.