Dennis Dixon = Well its him or Batch, I supose the thinking is that maybe throwing him out there may help him develop, or maybe it just a situation where he out played Batch, but really my biggest gripe on putting him here is because its not like the Orgainzation picked him to be their guy, he is only starting because Ben is supsended, so its hard for me to knock the organization, especially being 2-0.
David Garrard = He was an ok starter a few years ago, however in the what have you done for me lately league, he has done nothing and looked so bad yesterday he got his ass benched, I would hope that they now know its time to move on.
Jake Delhomme = at one time, he was a good QB, he has taken a team to the SB, however that was 7 years ago, he has been a terrible QB the past few years which is why he isn't in Carolina anymore and as we see later on in the list when you are picking Moore over him, you know you got problems, can't see how he is any better than Anderson/Quinn
Matt Moore = Yeah I dont' get it, I mean its one thing to sit your young guy to learn from a good QB, or even a Jon Kitna type, but what is Clausen going to learn from this guy.
Matt Cassel = When you have Randy Moss you looked good like he did in NE, when you have no offensive line you look like he has looked the last 2 years. i want to say he is better than what we have seen, however he has done nothing to prove me right.
Alex Smith = I was never sold on this guy from day one.
Trent Edwards = the Bills have lots of problems, he is just one of them, when you lose your job to guys like J.P. Losman and Ryan Fitzpatrick not to mention can't look good when you have guys like Lee Evans and T.O.(last year) to throw too, then you really aren't very good
Kevin Kolb = Well I really don't think he has seen enough PT to be able to put him on this list
Chad Henne = Hard to fault that they are 2-0, sure he won't ever be a Dan Marino, but he could be a Jon Kitna/Trent Dilfer type, or maybe.
Josh Freeman = He is young, again another team that is 2-0 on here, like others have said i put him on the list with Henne and Kolb as not ready for the list.
Derek Anderson = "wow, Matt Leinart must REALLY suck." - had to quote you on this because I couldn't have said it better myself, when Anderson first started getting looks in cleveland he looked like a guy who could be a decent career backup, but to give him the reigns to replace the retired Warner that tells me that either Arizona has lost their minds or Leinart is really terrible.
Jason Campbell = yeah never got the hype around this guy, Washington knew enough to let him go and took advantage of the fact that Al Davis is out of his mind.