Is it time to just throw James Harrison out of the league?

[DSpydr84]

Seriously? When in life was he taught to tackle like that?

It's not a form tackle. He is hitting McCoy as hard as he can to knock him senseless. You don't need to execute a "clean" tackle when you're superior in size and strength.

He led with his head, and I don't even see the need to argue it wasn't.

Try to hit something as hard as you can with your whole body. You will look exactly like Harrison did in that video. Is it even possible to get your head out of the way?

Not saying he shouldn't be flagged, he hit his helmet. That's the rule. But you guys are acting like he launched his face at McCoy. It looks a lot more to me like he's exploding his chest/shoulders into McCoy to make an impact hit and his helmet caught McCoy in the chin.

Oh and this: Is the complete opposite of a proper form tackle.

Again, no one said it was a form tackle. Harrison is trying to hit McCoy with a lot of force; he doesn't need to go "numbers to numbers" because he's physically superior to McCoy. Colt is going down either way, might as well give him a good shot.


EDIT: To all the guys who think it was intentional, what makes you think Harrison would hit a player standing upright helmet to helmet? What's the purpose of that technique when he can clearly crush him otherwise?

 

[wr50l]

EDIT: To all the guys who think it was intentional, what makes you think Harrison would hit a player standing upright helmet to helmet? What's the purpose of that technique when he can clearly crush him otherwise?

He's James Harrison. Are you mental?

 

[kyhadley]

I don't care what position the player is, that kind of hit should not be allowed in the sport.

And no one is saying he should have stopped on a dime, but that the helmet to helmet contact was easily avoidable. Obviously at that point he is going to run into him. And just because it is a violent sport it doesn't mean life-threatening injuries can't try to be prevented.

Colt probably was cool with James because he had no idea who he was or what was going on.

 

[KnightNoles]

I agree with the preventing injuries but stuff on the field is going to happen

 

[Aso]

I got in a car accident about a month ago and the same thing happened to me as what happened to McCoy (tells you how hard a hit it was).

 

[Obst]

EDIT: To all the guys who think it was intentional, what makes you think Harrison would hit a player standing upright helmet to helmet? What's the purpose of that technique when he can clearly crush him otherwise?

Because he has done shit like this:

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEvj1Dgvz_U&feature=related"]James Harrison hit on Josh Cribbs - YouTube[/ame]

 

[DSpydr84]

Because he has done shit like this:

James Harrison hit on Josh Cribbs - YouTube

COME ON NOW... really?

Look, I'm not saying ANY of this stuff is allowable, both this and the McCoy hit are clearly penalties. Let's make sure that's perfectly clear: I don't defend a helmet to helmet hit, and it should not be in the game.

But a grown man is trying to bring another grown man to the ground. It's going to happen now and then.

This hit on Cribbs is ridiculous. What do you want him to do? He's chasing down the play, Cribbs cuts it up, he drops his shoulder and tries to knock him down. I get it, his helmet hit Cribbs' helmet. But come on. Should he slide on the ground and take out his feet? Should he stay completely upright and just try to grab him around the shoulders?

I just don't see how either situation could've been avoided. I get that he's been in trouble a lot, and I'm hardly a Steelers fan, but I think it's a little unfair to him too.

 

[Tailback U]

edit - nevermind I was thinking about a different hit.

 

[Houston]

I expected more from DSpydr84:facepalm:

 

[FirstTimer]

the hit was clean

It was a helmet to helmet hit ona QB. The hit was not clean.




.

i thought you were supposed to be some kind of smart guy here at vsn? they are all players, if you protcect one you got to protect them all.

Read a rule book you uneducated fuck.

 

[Derrville]

Im ok with the rules in place but if they're going to enforce these rules as much as they do the officials need to do a better job of recognizing an illegal hit. Too many calls are borderline at best and or the WR and QB just duck right into the hit causing incidental contact to the helmet.

Harrison just seems like a dude who doesnt care about the rules. Hes going to continue to play like this whether the NFL likes it or not. He doesnt care.

 

[FirstTimer]

I expected more from DSpydr84:facepalm:

Why?

He's an Alabama fan

 

[FirstTimer]

If he would have gone another yard or two

But he hadn't.

So you have no point.

 

[DSpydr84]

It's really not hard to make a hit like this

Eric Berry huge hit! - YouTube

The difference is Berry gets low and makes the correct play. No coach probably ever told Harrison he was doing the right thing when aiming high. That's what all of these fines and flags were for, to teach Harrison to use the proper technique but he refuses to do so. That's where this argument is coming from, if Harrison is blatantly disregarding the safety of players then he shouldn't be playing. On that player with McCoy it would of been easy for him to just drive right through his body and make a great play, but instead he wanted to lay "the big hit" which was staying up high and even if he didn't mean it, when you stay up high like that you most likely are going to hit with the helmet.

It happens pretty fast, but to me, this looks identical to the McCoy/Harrison hit except Harrison was facing McCoy. Yet this is considered a clean hit.

Berry's forehead is directly in line with Amendola's (?) chin. Only difference is Amendola is sideways so Berry hits his shoulder.

I could name a thousand hits that happen exactly this way. Here's the goal line stand from the Browns. Gocong hits Mendenhall directly in the face with his helmet. Is this first and goal from the 1? Should Gocong be fined?

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d824dfa9a/Browns-make-goal-line-stop

Again, not saying it's acceptable. But IT HAPPENS.

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

It happens pretty fast, but to me, this looks identical to the McCoy/Harrison hit except Harrison was facing McCoy. Yet this is considered a clean hit.

Berry's forehead is directly in line with Amendola's (?) chin. Only difference is Amendola is sideways so Berry hits his shoulder.

I could name a thousand hits that happen exactly this way. Here's the goal line stand from the Browns. Gocong hits Mendenhall directly in the face with his helmet. Is this first and goal from the 1? Should Gocong be fined?

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d824dfa9a/Browns-make-goal-line-stop

Again, not saying it's acceptable. But IT HAPPENS.

Then why are you arguing?

 

[DSpydr84]

Then why are you arguing?

Cause I like to argue with you guys. :jamesdean:

In all seriousness, I just think it's unfair to go so far as to remove a guy from the league for something that happens all the time. They're taking measures to remove it, and it's helping, but to say it's eliminated or will ever be eliminated is far-fetched.

 

[FirstTimer]

Gocong hits Mendenhall directly in the face with his helmet. Is this first and goal from the 1? Should Gocong be fined?

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d824dfa9a/Browns-make-goal-line-stop

Again, not saying it's acceptable. But IT HAPPENS.

Read a fucking rulebook.

Rule 12. Section 2. Article 8

For the love of God.

 

[Houston]

Cause I like to argue with you guys. :jamesdean:

In all seriousness, I just think it's unfair to go so far as to remove a guy from the league for something that happens all the time. They're taking measures to remove it, and it's helping, but to say it's eliminated or will ever be eliminated is far-fetched.

Happens all the time?


When's the last time a QB got hit heads on helmet to helmet in the open field?

 

[DSpydr84]

Read a fucking rulebook.

Rule 12. Section 2. Article 8

For the love of God.

(f) If a player uses any part of his helmet (including the top/crown and forehead/”hairline” parts) or facemask to butt, spear, or ram an opponent violently or unnecessarily. Although such violent or unnecessary use of the helmet and facemask is impermissible against any opponent, game officials will give special attention in administering this rule to protecting those players who are in virtually defenseless postures

So why wasn't Gocong penalized? Looks like a violent use of the helmet to ram an opponent, which is impermissible against any opponent.

If you penalize one, you penalize them all.

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

this. all day every day. the hit was clean and if it was a running back no flag, so fuck off.

Helmet to helmet is not legal. Therefore, it was not clean. You sound like a fool.

exactly. gocong's helmet hit mendy's, just like harrison's hit mcoy's. both times the helmet hit the chest and slid up to the other helmet. james didnt lead with it, he lowered his upper body and struck, just like he is supposed to.

Maybe you should watch it again, because I have no idea what you think you saw.

Harrison fired himself head first at McCoy, and his helmet made direct contact with McCoy's face. LOL@hitting the chest and sliding upward. Get lost with this shit.

it is pure physics, you cannot stop a 300 pound object on a dime.

No, you can't.

But those 300lb objects can stop themselves from leading with the helmet and launching themselves like rockets at the opposing players upper body (I will even give benefit of the doubt and assume Harrison is not a psychopath who wants to maim his opponents in a barbaric manner), which would eliminate most of these scary helmet to helmet shots that scramble brains.

Perhaps you should read up on the studies being done on the human brain and head injuries. Even if Harrison has no intentions of intentionally knocking these players out, his refusal to conform to the rules leads to these ugly hits. For that alone, fuck him, he's a goon and he deserves whatever punishment gets doled out.