I don't even know who the mods
are yet.
I wrote a response to your other thread, and it got deleted.
So, you think I'd delete your response?
Anyway...
Here's the response.
I love the EA blogs so far - they show a lot of promise - but I don't care what Ian or any of those guys talk about. I want tangible results. Things I see when I'm playing Madden.
For years and years and years, they make promise after promise ... and the last four or five, the same result - disappointment.
And don't lump me in with the "I hate EA Sports" crowd. I own Madden 09 on the ps3 and 360 this year (Madden CE on the ps3). I have bought every EA Sports game for at least 10 years. I am not a hater.
But I am tired of falling for this crap every year.
Madden has gotten progressively worse since Madden 04 ... to the point where I have almost given up on videogame football.
I am not an NFL2k5 guy either. I owned that game and didn't like the floaty player control. I have always been a Madden guy.
I like that Ian Cummings and Phil Frazier have come aboard the community train, but I refuse to give them "get out of jail free" cards just because EA finally has acknowledged their existence on the boards.
They have to earn our trust with their actions, not their words.
Yeah, and I have a different view. I place the blame squarely on the people who made
those Maddens and don't blame the guys who finally seem to have their heads on the shoulders straight.
It starts with priorities, and Ian and Phil have the right ones. David Ortiz did not. David Ortiz is not with EA, and while Ian hasn't said anything outright, I have a feeling there's no love lost on either side. I get the sense that this is the Madden Ian wanted to make the whole time. And from the sound of things, he wasn't quiet about it back then either.
Hell, he was leaking information to us 4 years ago, trying to get feedback and get something rallied against the morons up there. I remember him contacting Steve McGuire shortly after we released the Madden Manifesto for the '04 game. Then his "top secret" gameplay documents that suddenly stopped leaking once his name was attached to them for the '06 version. It's not like Ian's popping up out of nowhere... he's been lobbying for this since
at least 2004.
Then you have Frazier, who was the guy who lead Madden into the PS2/Xbox generation and did quite well until '04, after which Ortiz took over and everything took a shit dive.
So you're going to take the Ortiz era and blame Frazier, when it was Ortiz who fucked up all the progress that Frazier made. You're going to blame the Ortiz era on Ian, when he was the one stomping his feet and trying to turn things around and, if the back room talk I hear is true, might be part of the reason Ortiz isn't there anymore.
And, as Ian said before '09 even came out... even as he was signing the praises of the progress made... '09 is still an Ortiz game.
You'll note, in this post, I described actions, not words. It's unfortunate it's taken until now for the suits to see the truth of it... I should say, it's taken FIFA for the suits to see the truth of it. But we are where we are.
Last year the 49ers fired a failed head coach and hired one of the existing staff to take over. He's said the right things and shown some progress. I'm excited for the upcoming season. Using your philosophy, I should still be pissed off and holding Singletary responsible for Nolan's failure.