MLB Chise Trade Talks

[goDawgs1433]

Would it be realistic in my Braves 'chise to trade Detroit a B prospect (Cole Rohrbough, very promising starter) for Dontrelle Willis? D-Train is in Triple-A for the Tigers but he would be on my major league club, probably as a long reliever but I may move him into my 5th starter spot and move either Kawakami or Hanson to the 'pen, more likely Hanson.

It would make a nice storyline, trying to revive Willis' career. Plus, he would give me (most likely) a nice lefty presence in my rotation, which I don't have atm. Thoughts?

 

[goDawgs1433]

Anyone?

 

[Vinsane]

You got to remember the Tigers wrapped up a nice bit of stock in D-Train, you might be looking at a 2 for 1 deal?

 

[T.Dot]

Thinking of trading Roy Halladay to the Atlanta Braves...

Tgouhts?

Vernon Wells also on block

 

[Vinsane]

I doubt anyone would take Vernon Wells, unless they were really hurting for a DH. Trading Halladay to the Braves for what in return?

 

[goDawgs1433]

You got to remember the Tigers wrapped up a nice bit of stock in D-Train, you might be looking at a 2 for 1 deal?

Good point. And by 2 for 1 do you mean me sending two players to the Tigers and getting D-Train in return or the other way around?

 

[chazmaniandevil]

no, the padres will never trade peavy to a team in the nl west

 

[Mit]

I know the Dodgers are interested in real life in Jake Peavy. I found a deal that would work and I'm wondering if it is good enough to keep it realistic.

Dodgers give up:
SP Clayton Kershaw
2B Blake DeWitt (in AAA)
LF Andrew Lambo (in AAA)

San Diego would give up only Jake Peavy.

It would definitely bolster my rotation by giving me Peavy, Kuroda, Wolf, Billingsley and Stults/McDonald

I know Peavy is a stud, but why would you trade away a future ace and two decent players?

 

[T.Dot]

OK looking to get Adrien Beltre from the 27-71 M's, which makes sense, here's two deals I was thinking of:

Toronto Gets:
3B Adrien Beltre

Seattle Gets:
SP Jesse Litsch
3B Kevin Ahrens
RP Jesse Carlson

----------------------------

Toronto Gets:
3B Adrien Beltre

Seattle Gets:
3B Jose Bautista
SP Jesse Litsch
RP Mike Maroth



What deal is better?

 

[goDawgs1433]

Probably the 2nd one cause they get a pretty good 3B in return.

 

[Nash]

2nd

 

[Vinsane]

Good point. And by 2 for 1 do you mean me sending two players to the Tigers and getting D-Train in return or the other way around?

You sending two players. They'll need a starter so maybe a AAA prospect that could come in for them from the get-go. Or maybe your 4th, 5th man in rotation. That coupled with a young prospect should do the trick, anyone else with thoughts?

 

[goDawgs1433]

You sending two players. They'll need a starter so maybe a AAA prospect that could come in for them from the get-go. Or maybe your 4th, 5th man in rotation. That coupled with a young prospect should do the trick, anyone else with thoughts?

Yeah, I was at least going to be sending Rohrbough (AAA B potential SP) over there, maybe I could add a semi-decent hitting prospect?

I'm thinking now about a Peavy deal, though...trying not to add Hanson in there but I might have to. Probably get rid of Escobar, too...he's been terrible recently.

 

[goDawgs1433]

Yep. Yunel is batting like .255 with 1 HR and 6 RBI's in 21 games, mostly out of the 2 spot in the lineup. Sandwiched in between Kelly Johnson (.365 and on a tear) and Chipper (.427, best in NL), if I could get more production out of that slot I would be much better off. Yunel just isn't getting it done and he leads the team in errors.

Prado would probably play short with Infante being my utilityman off the bench.

I'm hoping they'll accept a Mike Gonzalez-Escobar-Medlen package, but we'll see. Just trying to work around giving up Hanson.

 

[chazmaniandevil]

Foster, what do you think about my Peavy deal. The Padres dont want to trade to LA but if they have to they will, because thats one of his teams he would waive his no trade clause to.

no they wont, theyll settle for a not as flashy deal from someone not from the nl west if it comes down to it

id bet 100000000 dollars on that, theres no way they want to face him 6-7 times a year

 

[goDawgs1433]

If the deal is sweet enough (which it would have to be), I could see them going for it. It's gotta be a great package, though.

 

[chazmaniandevil]

shit it better be kemp+kershaw+ethier+loney+billingsley+lol you get my point, never happening

 

[goDawgs1433]

shit it better be kemp+kershaw+ethier+loney+billingsley+lol you get my point, never happening

:joker: :jonesy:

Lol, but really, you're stupid. After Peavy turned down that White Sox deal a couple weeks ago the ESPN article said that the Padres don't want to trade him to the NL West if they don't have to, but if they get a sweet offer, then they'll go for it.

Obviously, Kershaw would have to be included...Idk who the Dodgers other good prospects are. I know San Diego wants middle infield help and maybe CF.

 

[chazmaniandevil]

:joker: :jonesy:

Lol, but really, you're stupid. After Peavy turned down that White Sox deal a couple weeks ago the ESPN article said that the Padres don't want to trade him to the NL West if they don't have to, but if they get a sweet offer, then they'll go for it.

Obviously, Kershaw would have to be included...Idk who the Dodgers other good prospects are. I know San Diego wants middle infield help and maybe CF.

lol if any of you guys think peavy will be traded to the dodgers

im not living in a cave here i realize what the padres options are here

According to radio host Dan Patrick, Dodger General Manager Ned Colletti said his team has “tried to get in on the Jake Peavy trade possibility before, but Padres GM Kevin Towers told the Dodgers that they'd have to pay extra since they were divisional rivals." Patrick added that "Colletti said San Diego wanted three players and a top prospect, and [Coletti] couldn't do that.”

how much you want to bet that it was a ridiculous offer, im thinking kemp+mcdonald+wade+someone, or replace mcdonald and wade with kershaw

they may want him, theres no way theyre going to get him without looking like the stupidest organization ever

 

[goDawgs1433]

Just because that means "give extra" doesn't mean that they have to sell the family farm, just give more than other teams. If you think the Dodgers even THOUGHT about trading Kemp, you must be living in a cave.

Padres would've accepted our offer of Hanson + two pretty good prospects, so why wouldn't they accept Kershaw + 3ish good prospects. Kershaw is more MLB-ready than Hanson.