MILWAUKEE • Game 1 of the NL championship series got away so fast, it left Cardinals manager Tony La Russa flat-footed in the dugout. With bombs exploding at Miller Park, with the pitching mound opening up like a pit of quicksand to swallow panicked Cardinals pitcher Jaime Garcia, the future Hall of Fame manager failed to react.
Milwaukee's fifth-inning, six-run eruption was notable for several reasons. It obliterated the Cardinals' 5-2 lead. It gave the Brewers a 9-6 Game 1 victory and a 1-0 series advantage. The setback reinforced Garcia's reputation as a road worrier. And La Russa went against his career reputation by waiting to pull a completely unhinged starting pitcher despite being armed with a rested bullpen loaded with options.
The fifth-inning carnage against Garcia was stunning. It began with a single by Corey Hart. Then a double by Jerry Hairston Jr. Another double, this from Ryan Braun, who had smashed a two-run, 463-foot homer off Garcia in the first inning. And finally, a shock-and-awe 420-foot blast by Prince Fielder for another two-run jack.
After the fireworks cleared, the Brewers led 6-5.
La Russa belatedly made his move to the bullpen, for Octavio Dotel. And I still don't believe it. La Russa skipping a chance to hustle in a reliever is like Nyjer Morgan declining the opportunity to showboat. It happens about as often as the Rams win a football game.
Some of you will be quick to point out that Dotel hardly extinguished the bonfire; he gave up a two-run homer to Yuni Betancourt to make it 8-5 Brewers. Point taken. But it's also irrelevant. By the time Dotel reached the scene, the complexion and the momentum of Game 1 had changed dramatically. So we'll never know what Dotel would have done against Milwaukee's No. 3 and No. 4 hitters.
It just wasn't the same situation. Dotel's appeal was based on specific matchups and his impressive history of suppressing Braun and Fielder. The two Milwaukee mashers are both two for eight against Dotel, with six strikeouts each. That's right; Braun and Fielder have struck out 12 times in their 16 at-bats against Dotel. This would make Dotel an attractive candidate to perform an intervention.
So why was Dotel waiting and watching in the bullpen? As effective as he's been against big boppers Braun and Fielder in his career, Dotel can't strike 'em out from beyond the right-field fence.
"Fielder was Jaime's last hitter," La Russa said. "I mean, once he starts throwing the ball in the middle and there's not much room for margin for error there, once he faces Braun, and Fielder was going to be his last hitter. Dotel was ready for the next guy."
With all due respect to La Russa — and remember, La Russa's critics accuse me of being a TLR apologist — I do not understand this.
No. 1, Garcia tends to lose it in a hurry. He's microwave popcorn out there. When the heat gets to Garcia, everything starts popping and burning in a sudden burst. This suggests it's wise to be on guard for a quick removal. Didn't we learn that in Game 3 of the NL division series, when a tilting Garcia gave up the three-run pinch homer to Philadelphia's Ben Francisco?
No. 2, Garcia is not exactly Spartacus on the road. His road ERA this season (including postseason) is 4.97. He's allowed a .314 road batting average, a .479 slugging percentage and 158 baserunners in 99 2/3 innings. He's been pounded for 25 road doubles and 11 road homers. This also indicates the need to be on full alert for a quick removal.
No. 3, Braun's first inning homer off Garcia traveled so far, Donald Driver could have caught it had the Packers been playing in Green Bay on Sunday night. Dotel seemed ready when Braun stepped up in the fifth. But even if Dotel needed a couple of extra warm-up pitches, how many times have we seen La Russa go with stall-ball delaying tactics to give relievers a little extra time? He's good at it.
No. 4, after Garcia gave up the two-run double to Braun, the Cardinals still had a 5-4 lead. Under no circumstances did it make sense to let Fielder take a swing at the free-falling Garcia. And Garcia flipped in an 87 mph slider, straight over the plate, just pleading to be pulped. And Big Prince didn't miss. Fielder's home-run shot traveled 119.2 miles per hour, which made it the highest-velocity HR hit in 2011, according to ESPN Stats and Information.
La Russa said, "only when I saw him throw the ball up the middle to Braun, I said 'that's enough.' And he tried to make a pitch to Fielder and it's a two-run homer."
OK, if the bad slider to Braun convinced La Russa that it was "enough" for Garcia, then why did he allow Garcia to confront Fielder? The Cardinals didn't use their bullpen Friday. They were off Saturday. They have another off day on Tuesday. This bullpen is amped to go. And speaking of that ...
No. 5, La Russa decided to go with an extra pitcher on the roster for the NLCS. The Cardinals are carrying 12. That's even more of a reason to be aggressive with your bullpen. If you're going to hesitate before rescuing an overwhelmed Garcia, then what's the point of having eight relievers in the bullpen?
No. 6, La Russa was concerned about Garcia. La Russa had the bullpen warming in the Brewers' two-run first. And he had Dotel hurrying to get ready in the fifth. If you are clearly so worried about Garcia handling this environment, then why let him stay in there to get punched out?
And that's the overall point here: After building a 5-2 lead on Milwaukee starter Zack Greinke, after being in such favorable position to secure Game 1, you can't waste it by letting Braun and Fielder bully an unnerved young pitcher. And especially not inside the Brewers' home playpen, where they've won 61 of 85 games this season, including the postseason. It's an intimidating venue.
Garcia is in his second season. And yes, maybe Garcia should be mentally tougher by now. But he isn't. And I the manager has to be extra aggressive about keeping the game under control when a vulnerable pitcher sinks into deep and irreversible trouble.
"It's a tough loss," right fielder Lance Berkman said. "Stating the obvious, every one of these games are very important. And if you have a chance to win it, you better do it. We'll come back out Monday and see what happens."
No panic here. This should be a long series. If the Cardinals can come back from losing Game 1 at Philadelphia in the five-game NL division series, they surely can rebound in this seven-game NLCS. If the Cardinals can come back from a 2-1 deficit in the NLDS to win two in a row over Philly, they can bounce back against the Brewers. This St. Louis team has reaffirmed its competitive character many times over in 2011.
It's also true that the Cardinals will need to win a game or two at Miller Park. And rapidly evaporating starters aren't going to hold up against the Brewers in this yard. So if anything, La Russa must be on his toes and attack the Brewers with his relievers. And if the bullpen isn't good enough, then the Cardinals weren't going to win the NLCS, anyway.
La Russa calls in relievers about as often as a teenager hits the 'send" button on a text message. Multiple generations of baseball writers have needled TLR for personally creating the three-hour (plus) game with his frenetic bullpen maneuvers.
La Russa is guilty of overmanaging, some say. Well, I wish we would have seen some overmanaging of the St. Louis bullpen on Sunday at Miller Park.