Nuk's Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks.

[Shayn•Da•Pain]

I would rather see your bottom 10 quarterback list..

I'm just guessing but I bet his bottom 10 looks something like Orton, Cutler, Alex Smith, Fitzpatrick, Max Hall, and then any combination of starting black QB's [McNabb, Gerrard, Vick, Campbell, and Freeman]. That is of course if he sticks with starting QB's only.

I think Big Ben deserves to be on this list, despite off-the-field antics

I'm glad you said it before I did. I don't want to look like a homer...much.

 

[Nukleopatra]

List has been corrected due to too much confusion about why Ben Roethlisberger was left off.. In no way, do I think a hack like Joe Flacco is better than Ben. Ben gets his 2009 rank back.

 

[Houston]

lol Tony Romo got lost and accidentally found himself on your list. Please guide him back to where he came from.

 

[Nukleopatra]

I'm not ready to give up on Tony Romo yet. The guy is a 64% career passer, QB rating in the mid 90s. I realize he plays for Dallas, so he's one of those players who you guys enjoy bashing the hell of, which is cool, because I enjoy bashing certain players, too. Dallas' issues right now, in my opinion, have more to do with coaching than Tony Romo. It took Drew Brees a few years before he was able to get over the hump. If you're saying Romo is overrated, I can agree with that, but he's rated 9th on my list - I don't think that's too high.

 

[Houston]

If you're saying Romo is overrated, I can agree with that, but he's rated 9th on my list - I don't think that's too high.

With QB's sucking so much right now you can pick an average QB and have a tough time keeping him off a top 10 list.

 

[ralaw]

I really don't understand why Rivers is always so high on these list.

 

[Nukleopatra]

With QB's sucking so much right now you can pick an average QB and have a tough time keeping him off a top 10 list.

How true.

I can't remember the last time the NFL was this bad. Hell, I considered putting Joe Flacco on the list, that tells you everything you need to know right there.

 

[mgoblue2290]

Shaun Hill should be 10th over Sanchezchise.

 

[MrBill]

Vick looked like a top 5 QB in his starts. Suspect that he will pick up where he left off when he is back under center for week 9.

 

[j.hen]

Matty Ice is too low now.

 

[corbin]

I have no problem with Brees moving down, I never considered him a top 2 or 3 QB anyways.

However no Eli Manning on the list is a crime. How can you have a rookie in the top 5 but leave super bowl winning Eli off the list completely?

 

[Nukleopatra]

Eli's been in the league for a while now, and he's just not consistent enough to make my list. I'd take every quarterback on my list, ahead of Eli Manning, if I were running a franchise. What's his lifetime rating? 79? Unless you're black, that's not really all that impressive. I think his lifetime completion % is in the 50s, or damn close to it.

You can argue that Eli should be ahead of Mark Sanchez - maybe. I'll give you that.. but ahead of Sam Bradford? No. My reasoning will be clear as day in the next 10 years.

 

[Aso]

Rodgers > Bradford?

 

[Nukleopatra]

Rodgers > Bradford?

If I had to take one guy, I'd take Bradford, without even thinking about it. But to put Sam Bradford at #4 this soon, would just come off as being a homer. I left the homerism out of this list.

 

[inthecards21]

If I had to take one guy, I'd take Bradford, without even thinking about it. But to put Sam Bradford at #4 this soon, would just come off as being a homer. I left the homerism out of this list.

the fact that he is even on the list is homerism in itself, let alone #5

 

[Nukleopatra]

the fact that he is even on the list is homerism in itself, let alone #5

And the only reason you posted, is because you think Ben at #6 is too low.

Your homerism blinds me.

 

[inthecards21]

And the only reason you posted, is because you think Ben at #6 is too low.

Your homerism blinds me.

I never said that, ben is right where he should be except brees should be in front of him

 

[strahanfan92]

Sanchez above Eli right now is ridiculous. I don't care if Eli isn't even on your top 15 list, but to have that second year spic above him is ludicrous.

 

[Nukleopatra]

Sanchez above Eli right now is ridiculous. I don't care if Eli isn't even on your top 15 list, but to have that second year spic above him is ludicrous.

Eli is at #11, tied with Joe Flacco.

 

[EmpireWF]

HOMER WAR!

I understand people shit on Eli every chance they get. For a winning QB, he sure gets a lot of crap. First, at least I'm not the homer claiming my teams rookie QB is among the five best QB in the league. lulz

Eli is definitely one of the top 10 guys in the league. I have no problem saying Peyton, Brady, Brees, Big Ben are better. I wouldn't even say Eli is #5 but to say there are SIX OTHER QBS better? lmao

I don't care if Bradford goes on to win a dozen Super Bowls...right now, he's a solid rookie QB.

With Eli as the starter, the Giants have never had a losing season. Over the past three years, the Giants offense has been top ten in both points scored and yards gained. And over the past three years, Eli's completion percentage has increased and he's on pace to set a career high.

My two criticisms of Eli are 1) He has yet to prove he can play in the wintry winds at the Meadowlands. THANKFULLY 2007 was played on the road....which eli played lights out football for four consecutive weeks...including outplaying Favre in his own building. Back to the criticism....2) He throws too many picks for my liking. This year he is on pace for 20+, which would be the second time in his career.

Lets look at Big Ben and Eli...

Eli has started 94 games in his career. Ben has started 88 games and has a 5% better completion percentage. Eli has a couple hundred more yards, more INTs and one more TD.

Eli's playoff record--- 4-3. Ben's record -- 8-2. Ben is the better QB, but Eli is in the discussion.