Playoff consensus reached for college football

[kyhadley]

But the other side of the argument is with 123 coaches and private polls it is a lot easier for coaches to hide their biased votes among the masses. That's not possible with a smaller committee.

 

[FirstTimer]

But the other side of the argument is with 123 coaches and private polls it is a lot easier for coaches to hide their biased votes among the masses. That's not possible with a smaller committee.

Yeah..nothing screams safety against collusion like private polling that isn't released.


Wut.

 

[FirstTimer]

So we model a system that selects 68 teams from a tournament with little doubt that you certainly capture at least the top 20 best teams to select 4 teams, makes very little sense either. At least with polling the simple solution exists to make polling public.

Maybe I'm giving this site too much credit but I'm pretty sure you could get 10 guys from VSD together and pick the top 4 teams and have it be pretty well agreed upon. I'm not really worried about this committee doing a competent job.

 

[ZoneBlitz]

Maybe I'm giving this site too much credit but I'm pretty sure you could get 10 guys from VSD together and pick the top 4 teams and have it be pretty well agreed upon. I'm not really worried about this committee doing a competent job.

Not true. VSN would be split on whether Alabama should make the final 4, with half saying "they didnt even win their conference or division!"

 

[Senser81]

Not true. VSN would be split on whether Alabama should make the final 4, with half saying "they didnt even win their conference or division!"

 

[FirstTimer]

Not true. VSN would be split on whether Alabama should make the final 4, with half saying "they didnt even win their conference or division!"

3 out of 4 isn't bad.

 

[packersfan4eva]

Not true. VSN would be split on whether Alabama should make the final 4, with half saying "they didnt even win their conference or division!"

That's a different question entirely. It's pretty widely accepted that Alabama was one of the best four teams in the country. However, whether they earned a spot in a playoff despite not winning their division is another problem.

 

[ragman]

What year was it when there were 5 undefeated teams in the top 6 ranked teams? What happens if that happens again? Who gets left out?

 

[Sportsbuck]

What year was it when there were 5 undefeated teams in the top 6 ranked teams? What happens if that happens again? Who gets left out?

2009.

Alabama
Texas
Cincinnati
TCU
Boise State