Rank the remaining playoff QBs...

[GoChargers]

DREW BREES DOES NOT HAVE AN EXTREMELY POOR POSTSEASON CAREER.

And his record is NOT 1-8.

It is 1-2. (One of those being the Chargers vs Jets game, Kaeding misses a 40yarder to win the game)


Vs Jets 31/42, 319yds, 2TD, 1INT.
Vs Eagles 20/32, 243yds, 1TD, 0INT.
Vs Bears 27/49, 354yds, 2TD, 1INT.


Alot of you seem to think he is going to come into this game vs the Cards - fumble the ball 3 times and throw 4 picks.



And bringbackjimmy, I had to groan that post. Romo > Rivers is laughable. What? Because he finally got a postseason victory? Rivers has 3 and he can do more than "throw jump balls to his 6"5 recievers". Give me a break

 

[Hasselbeck]

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Warner
4. Rivers
5. Favre
6. Romo
7. Flacco
8. Sanchez
451. Painter

 

[seaplus]

who the fuck is phillip rivers?

 

[bringbackjimmy]

DREW BREES DOES NOT HAVE AN EXTREMELY POOR POSTSEASON CAREER.

And his record is NOT 1-8.

It is 1-2. (One of those being the Chargers vs Jets game, Kaeding misses a 40yarder to win the game)


Vs Jets 31/42, 319yds, 2TD, 1INT.
Vs Eagles 20/32, 243yds, 1TD, 0INT.
Vs Bears 27/49, 354yds, 2TD, 1INT.


Alot of you seem to think he is going to come into this game vs the Cards - fumble the ball 3 times and throw 4 picks.



And bringbackjimmy, I had to groan that post. Romo > Rivers is laughable. What? Because he finally got a postseason victory? Rivers has 3 and he can do more than "throw jump balls to his 6"5 recievers". Give me a break

sorry must of misread nuk post.....anyways it's a opionion thread like who do you like better...sorry if i wanted a QB that just threw it up and have his WR make a play i would go with Rivers..if i want a QB that can actually make plays with out relying on the jump ball I'll go with Romo... I don't like Rivers and in my opinion Romo>Rivers sorry...

edit: I watched the Dallas game and all he did was throw jump balls to the sideline...

 

[bringbackjimmy]

again Flacco is obviously hurt and the coaching staff doesn't have confidense in him or he would have thrown more than 10 passes......

 

[Tailback U]

again Flacco is obviously hurt and the coaching staff doesn't have confidense in him or he would have thrown more than 10 passes......

he didn't need to throw more than 10 passes. that's why he didn't.

 

[bringbackjimmy]

Btw I love the fact that people groan my opinion list in a thread that ask to give your opinion. Don't see me groaning every post that has Brett favre who really hasn't done crap in the playoffs since his last sb run besides set int Records #2. People need to get a fucking life and stop harassing me...

On to flacco yeah at the end of the game they didn't need hi
to, but I remember a 3 and like 8 after suggs ff where they ran in what clearly was a passing situAtion.. Ravens can't Trent dilfer teams this yr.

 

[Bmore]

Btw I love the fact that people groan my opinion list in a thread that ask to give your opinion. Don't see me groaning every post that has Brett favre who really hasn't done crap in the playoffs since his last sb run besides set int Records #2. People need to get a fucking life and stop harassing me...

On to flacco yeah at the end of the game they didn't need hi
to, but I remember a 3 and like 8 after suggs ff where they ran in what clearly was a passing situAtion.. Ravens can't Trent dilfer teams this yr.

Maybe you don't watch the Ravens, but we are known for running the ball in passing situations (we did this even with McNair). It's nothing against Flacco, at the beginning of the season we passed a lot and for 3 games were doing fine, but we hit that losing streak because we weren't running out enough of the clock. Thus we resorted back to old tricks.

If your HB was averaging as many yards as Ray Rice per rush. You would hand the ball off to him in 3rd and 5+. When it was 3rd and long, we passed it. Remember the Mark Clayton first down?

 

[Liquidrob]

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Warner
4. Rivers
5. Favre
6. Sanchez
7. Flacco
8. Romo

This will be Kurt's last game, he will pass the torch to Bress and nuk will have a new favorite QB

sidenote: Drew Breeeessssssss

 

[bringbackjimmy]

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Warner
4. Rivers
5. Favre
6. Sanchez
7. Flacco
8. Romo

This will be Kurt's last game, he will pass the torch to Bress and nuk will have a new favorite QB

sidenote: Drew Breeeessssssss

people look i am not going to groan his post. even though I clearly disagree with his list... Thank you rob for giving us your opinion in this opinion thread...

 

[Nukleopatra]

people look i am not going to groan his post. even though I clearly disagree with his list... Thank you rob for giving us your opinion in this opinion thread...

I did it for you.

 

[Senser81]

8) Mark Sanchez The only QB here without a postseason loss but he is ranked #8?

Sorry, but this comment sucked. It sucked royally.

Grow a brain.

 

[Fox1994]

List looks good...

Sanchez is number one. The rest are irrelevant.

I wanna reply to your response with your avatar, but I'm not gonna do the work...

I did it for you.

I'll join in.

 

[MrBill]

Btw I love the fact that people groan my opinion list in a thread that ask to give your opinion. Don't see me groaning every post that has Brett favre who really hasn't done crap in the playoffs since his last sb run besides set int Records #2. People need to get a fucking life and stop harassing me...

Well, actually he completed 63.8% of his pass attempts in the two games he played in '07 with the Packers, one in a blizzard and the NFC championship game that was the 3rd coldest game in NFL history. He had 5 TD's to 2 INTs and still had the best efficiency rating of any QB in the playoffs at 99.0%. Saying he didn't do anything in '07 is like saying Aaron Rodgers didn't do anything this season. It wasn't really Favre's fault, the defense didn't show up against the Giants just like they didn't show up against the Cardinals last week.

 

[adembroski]

1. Kurt Warner- His playoff performances last year and opening this year are astounding. As clutch as it gets.

2. Brett Favre- Was the Kurt Warner of the mid-90s, has shown a lot more over his career in the playoffs than Manning has.

3. Payton Manning- Hasn't done a lot in the post season over his career, but some of that has to be laid at Tom Brady's feet rather than his.

4. Drew Brees- Has done nothing in the playoffs, but comes in having put up two consecutive dominant regular season performances.

5. Philip Rivers- I just think the guy's got the right attitude to make things happen in the post season. I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt, but he could throw 5 TDs, or 5 INTs, and it wouldn't surprise me

6. Mark Sanchez- Jumping the gun having him this high? Sure, but his one game was better than all of Flacco's last year, even if they were all 5 yard dump offs. Maybe the kind of guy who thrives in this environment, we'll see.

7. Tony Romo- The guy's just too think skinned for the playoffs. If he wins in Minnesota, I'll give him his due, but I'm going to withhold praise for now.

8. Joe Flacco- Has yet to do anything really impressive in his career beyond benefit from a great defense. I like him, hope he turns out great, but he's proven zero at this point.

 

[Senser81]

It wasn't really Favre's fault, the defense didn't show up against the Giants just like they didn't show up against the Cardinals last week.

Great comparison! The Packers defense gave up 45 points to the Cardinals and Aaron Rodgers had 422 yards and 4 TDs and 1 INT in a losing effort. In 2007, the Packers gave up 23 points to the Giants and Favre had 236 yards 2 TDs and 2 INTs. So, in 2007, the Packers defense gave up half as many points, Favre threw for half as many yards and TDs, and had twice the INTs...yet its the same thing!

 

[MrBill]

Great comparison! The Packers defense gave up 45 points to the Cardinals and Aaron Rodgers had 422 yards and 4 TDs and 1 INT in a losing effort. In 2007, the Packers gave up 23 points to the Giants and Favre had 236 yards 2 TDs and 2 INTs. So, in 2007, the Packers defense gave up half as many points, Favre threw for half as many yards and TDs, and had twice the INTs...yet its the same thing!

Factoring in 65° and sunny for the game in Arizona and -13° and windy in Green Bay for the two teams combined with the fact that Favre actually had better stats than Manning that game, I would say yes, it is a fair comparison because it was the defense more than the offense that cost their team the game. The Packers defense allowed the Giants to make numerous sustained drives which ultimately cost the team the game. The Giants kicker also missed 2 FG attempts to end regulation that would have kept the game from going to OT in the first place.

Time of possession:
Giants - 40:01
Packers - 22:34

You are also ignoring the fact that both Favre and Rodgers had two turnovers in their respective games for the Packers. Just because Rodgers game losing turnover was scored as a fumble instead of an INT, it was still a direct turnover on his behalf that cost his team the game.

 

[Senser81]

Factoring in 65° and sunny for the game in Arizona and -13° and windy in Green Bay for the two teams combined with the fact that Favre actually had better stats than Manning that game, I would say yes, it is a fair comparison because it was the defense more than the offense that cost their team the game. The Packers defense allowed the Giants to make numerous sustained drives which ultimately cost the team the game. The Giants kicker also missed 2 FG attempts to end regulation that would have kept the game from going to OT in the first place.

Time of possession:
Giants - 40:01
Packers - 22:34

You are also ignoring the fact that both Favre and Rodgers had two turnovers in their respective games for the Packers. Just because Rodgers game losing turnover was scored as a fumble instead of an INT, it was still a direct turnover on his behalf that cost his team the game.

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/drivechart?gameId=280120009

Uh, what game were you watching on January 20, 2008? It couldn't have been the Packers-Giants game. Of those "numerous" sustained drives the Giants had, only 2 were over 60 yards in length, and one of those drives ended in a FG anyway. So your point has been blown out of the water on one count. Throw in the fact that the only Packer "drive" of 40+ yards was a one-play, 90 yard TD pass to Donald Driver, and I think you can understand how the TOP was skewed to the Giants.

In that game, Brett Favre and the Packers had 12 possessions. Of those 12 possessions, SEVEN WERE OF THREE PLAYS OR LESS!!!

 

[Rayman]

1. Kurt Warner- His playoff performances last year and opening this year are astounding. As clutch as it gets.

2. Brett Favre- Was the Kurt Warner of the mid-90s, has shown a lot more over his career in the playoffs than Manning has.

3. Payton Manning- Hasn't done a lot in the post season over his career, but some of that has to be laid at Tom Brady's feet rather than his.

4. Drew Brees- Has done nothing in the playoffs, but comes in having put up two consecutive dominant regular season performances.

5. Philip Rivers- I just think the guy's got the right attitude to make things happen in the post season. I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt, but he could throw 5 TDs, or 5 INTs, and it wouldn't surprise me

6. Mark Sanchez- Jumping the gun having him this high? Sure, but his one game was better than all of Flacco's last year, even if they were all 5 yard dump offs. Maybe the kind of guy who thrives in this environment, we'll see.

7. Tony Romo- The guy's just too think skinned for the playoffs. If he wins in Minnesota, I'll give him his due, but I'm going to withhold praise for now.

8. Joe Flacco- Has yet to do anything really impressive in his career beyond benefit from a great defense. I like him, hope he turns out great, but he's proven zero at this point.

Wow.

Just wow.

 

[Liquidrob]

I did it for you.

its ok nuk, I accept your groin (yes homo), you will see when Bress puts up 500 on the cards