No disrespect to LT, but he wasn't as good as Ray Lewis.
Ray Lewis dominated the middle of a field for 15 years. LT dominated one side of it for 7 or 8. He had less than 10 sacks in all of his other seasons, while I know how much he could impact the game, he began to slow down late in his career while teams began to improve the left tackle position.
They both impacted the game as well as anyone, but to be one of the greatest middle linebackers of all time you have to be elite in coverage, elite against the run, and elite at rushing the passer. You have to make tackles, you have to make interceptions, you have to make sacks, you have to cause fumbles. Few players to play this game have done it like Ray Lewis.
Any GM, any era, is going to take a great pass rusher over a great MLB.
If you don't believe me, check salaries & draft positions of pass rushers vs MLB's. Far more valuable.
Tailback U said:
Do you think Lawrence Taylor would dominate today as he did when he played? Do you think the left tackle position has improved since twenty years ago all over the league?
Impossible to say, and a non point anyway. His career started 30 years ago. Of course the game has advanced and players are bigger and faster. We can only compare LT (or anybody else for that matter) against their own era. Who cares if Babe Ruth could or couldn't hit modern pitching? Who cares if George Gervin was too slow for the modern NBA? It means nothing.
In 30 years, Lewis will be physically inferior too.
Tailback U said:
Look at all the elite pass rushers in the league today. Nearly half the league has some freak coming off an end now.
Wanna guess why?
LT changed the game. Every team in the league is still looking for the next LT, because an elite pass rusher completely changes the game in a way a MLB never can.
Tailback U said:
Now tell me how many great middle linebackers there are in the league. How many superstar middle linebackers are playing today?
Tell me how many DE's/OLB's in the league today even approach what LT could do? Be careful with your answer.
I'm not sure if you ever saw LT play, but not only was he the most dominant pass rushing force i've ever seen, but he was a complete player as well. But when you have a guy like LT, you don't ask him to cover TE's or spy HB's. That's a waste of his unique ability. But he could (and did) do those things.
LT was a physically superior beast, hopped up on coke & steroids who was impossible to block with one man. Impossible. And that isn't urban legend. Ask Joe Gibbs, who played him twice per year and would routinely run pass routes with TWO receivers, while trying to get LT blocked with everybody else.
In some fantasy world where LT & Lewis are both 21 again and in the NFL Draft, all 32 GM's take LT without hesitation. LT changed the way teams approached building defensive teams, and his influence changed the way the game was played on both sides of the ball. Ray Lewis is a great player, an all time player, but he wasn't the type of player who changed the NFL.