Oh I think LVG would be a good signing don't get me wrong, it's just if I were a United supporter I'd want to just say fuck it, accept the position you're in, and get someone who while they might not bring instant glory, would be someone who would be there at the club for years to come.
I mean thinking about the length of the career that Rodgers could have at Liverpool is mind blowing. If Rodgers retired at the same age as Fergie, and assuming he doesn't leave... that's 30 years. 30 YEARS. Stability is important.