The Top 10 QBs in the NFL (2012 Edition)

[nflman2033]

I will thank this post for the sheer hilarity of it, but if you are serious...

 

[Houston]

6. Cam Newton - I'll wait for all the air to come back into the room after NAHSTE gets done sucking it all out when he reads Cam this high. Dual threat who will only get better as a passer and is almost unarguably the best athlete at the position. Give him someone to throw to other than an undersized guy in his 30s and Newton could do some nasty things to the record books.

Surely you troll!

 

[NAHSTE]

Dual threat who will only get better as a passer and is almost unarguably the best athlete at the position.

FWIW, I'd still say Vick is the better athlete than Newton. Cam be good and shit, tho.

 

[NAHSTE]

Also where the fuck is Matt Flynn? I'd slot him between Rodgers and Peyton tbh.

 

[RainboUnicorn]

No Cutler? The team absolutely crumbled without him.

 

[GoChargers]

It's hard to find a spot to put Manning. Assuming he comes back next year and is 80% as good as he usually is, he'll still be top 5 for sure.

1) Drew Brees. Bit of a Brees homer but I don't see any concrete reason Rodgers or Brady should be rated higher. Brees has been consistenty elite for 5 years now and could get his 2nd ring this season.

2) Aaron Rodgers.

3) Tom Brady

4) Peyton Manning

5) Philip Rivers

6) Ben Roethlisberger

7) Matt Stafford

8) Tony Romo

9) Eli Manning

10) Matt Ryan

Will change after playoffs and may include names such as Alex Smith, Joe Flacco.

 

[Houston]

List is lacking in Schaub.

 

[Aso]

Cutler > Eli Manning. SRS: Which QB would you rather have..

 

[GoChargers]

Cutler > Eli Manning. SRS: Which QB would you rather have..

Eli hands down.

 

[Diivox]

Eli hands down.

cutler was clearly the superior qb doing more with less than eli before he got hurt.

 

[GoChargers]

cutler was clearly the superior qb doing more with less than eli before he got hurt.

Cutler's barely got a .500 career record. 1 playoff win doesn't change that imo. He would've likely led the Bears to the playoffs this season but the fact remains he's only made a 1 playoff appearance in 4 seasons as a starter.

 

[Woy]

:locker:

 

[Houston]

:locker:

Better watch his back, Schaub stay creepin.

 

[nflman2033]

I'm just trying to start a monkey shit fight in a zoo.

ok, then Tony Romo should be on there, he is a fucking warrior, fractured ribs, busted up hand. Still throwing TDs, just don't ask him to sneak it, when all game long you had been taking snaps from shotgun, and then on 4th and 1 you line up under center.

 

[Primetime]

Cutler's barely got a .500 career record. 1 playoff win doesn't change that imo. He would've likely led the Bears to the playoffs this season but the fact remains he's only made a 1 playoff appearance in 4 seasons as a starter.

:yao:

 

[G-men]

It's hard to find a spot to put Manning. Assuming he comes back next year and is 80% as good as he usually is, he'll still be top 5 for sure.

1) Drew Brees. Bit of a Brees homer but I don't see any concrete reason Rodgers or Brady should be rated higher. Brees has been consistenty elite for 5 years now and could get his 2nd ring this season.

2) Aaron Rodgers.

3) Tom Brady

4) Peyton Manning

5) Philip Rivers

6) Ben Roethlisberger

7) Matt Stafford

8) Tony Romo

9) Eli Manning

10) Matt Ryan

Will change after playoffs and may include names such as Alex Smith, Joe Flacco.

Anyway, this is my list. I'm not gonna rank Peyton Manning because I honestly can't say what's gonna happen to him.

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Drew Brees

3. Tom Brady

--------------------------------------------

4. Philip Rivers

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Eli Manning

--------------------------------------------

7. Matthew Stafford

8. Cam Newton

9. Jay Cutler

10. Tony Romo

 

[Primetime]

Going on projected numbers....had Rodgers thrown as many passes as Brees, he would have thrown for over 6,000 yards.

 

[EmpireWF]

9. Eli Manning - If only because he has a ring. The guy has thrown 41 INTs the last two years. That's atrocious. He belongs no higher than this.

lol @ using 2010 logic to judge Eli.

Put Rivers ahead, but get better reasoning.

 

[Goober]

Cutler's barely got a .500 career record. 1 playoff win doesn't change that imo. He would've likely led the Bears to the playoffs this season but the fact remains he's only made a 1 playoff appearance in 4 seasons as a starter.

Five seasons, plus his rookie season when he took over a would be playoff team and blew the season.

 

[CrimsonGhost56]

In 5 out of his 8 seasons he's thrown 15+ INTs, including two seasons in which he's thrown more than 20. And that's including his rookie season when he threw 9 INTs in the only 9 games he played.

That's not 2010 logic, that's career logic.

EDIT: I just looked it up... Eli Has 22 more career TD passes than Rivers but he also has 51 more INTs....

and 1 more super bowl ring

:truestory: