the top 107 QB ratings list

[ram29jackson]

I'm stealing someone elses work from another forum because I know you all still love the QB debates around here. I don't know if he did his own work or stole it from Profootballreference or something ?

Trent Dilfer is 100, which is elite in itself :golfclap:

Every once in a while there's the debate, who's better Peyton Manning or Tom Brady. Usually, it boils down to whoever you like more personally. So, I got curious about what the numbers say, and how other QBs stacked up as well. To do this, I didn't just compare eras apples to oranges, but actually took each players numbers compared to the league average. The numbers used were completions, completion %, yards, TDs, TD%, INT, INT% and rating for every QB who has 10 years of experience and at least 5 years as their team's majority starter with at least 2 years starting from 1966 or later (Super Bowl Era). These numbers were taken into consideration for each player's entire career, top 5 seasons and play offs. Numbers also considered were years in the playoffs, play off starts, play off wins, pro bowls, 1st team all pros, MVPs, 4th quarter comebacks (career and top 5) and game winning drives (career and top 5). In all, each player is compared in 34 different categories.

107. David Carr
106. Mike Phipps
105. Kordell Stewart
104. Gus Frerotte
103. Jeff Blake
102. Brian Griese
101. Bob Berry

100. Trent Dilfer
99. Bill Munson
98. Rodney Peete
97. Archie Manning
96. Jim Zorn
95. Steve Grogan
94. Jay Schroeder
93. Bill Nelsen
92. Richard Todd
91. Norm Snead

90. Jon Kitna
89. Jack Kemp
88. Greg Landry
87. Chris Miller
86. Steve Beuerlein
85. Michael Vick
84. Charley Johnson
83. Mark Rypien
82. Babe Parilli
81. Doug Williams

Archie Manning is 97 :golfclap:

 

[ram29jackson]

80. Jim McMahon
79. Bobby Hebert
78. Dan Pastorini
77. Chris Chandler
76. Tommy Kramer
75. Jim Harbaugh
74. Chad Pennington
73. Jake Delhomme
72. Jeff Hostetler
71. Joe Namath

70. Lynn Dickey
69. Carson Palmer
68. John Hadl
67. Jake Plummer
66. Matt Schaub
65. Joe Ferguson
64. Craig Morton
63. Neil O'Donnell
62. Steve DeBerg
61. Earl Morrall

-Lynn Dickey is 70 :golfclap:

 

[ram29jackson]

60. Frank Ryan
59. Brian Sipe :golfclap:
58. Jim Everett
57. Kerry Collins
56. Ken O'Brien
55. Jeff George
54. Jim Plunkett :golfclap:
53. Drew Bledsoe
52. Jim Hart :golfclap:
51. Brad Johnson

Jim Everett is 58 :golfclap:

 

[ram29jackson]

50. Trent Green :golfclap: Kurt Warner stole his thunder
49. Steve McNair =funny how these 2 are next to each other considering what happened to both that particular year
48. Ron Jaworski :golfclap:
47. Dante Culpepper -if it wasn't for Randy Moss, where would he be ?
46. Mark Brunell = the greatest starting career back up ever
45. Bert Jones :golfclap:
44. Phil Simms
43. Steve Bartkowski
42. Danny White
41. Sonny Jurgensen

 

[ram29jackson]

40. Vinny Testeverde
39. Dave Kreig
38. Jeff Garcia
37. Bernie Kosar- he got the Browns oohh so close but it didn't happen because Elway was always in the way
36. Billy Kilmer
35. Boomer Esiason
34. Matt Hasselbeck
33. Eli Manning
32. Daryle Lamonica
31. John Brodie

Eli is 33 :golfclap:

 

[ram29jackson]

30. Rich Gannon
29. Randall Cunningham
28. Roman Gabriel
27. Bob Griese
26. Tony Romo
25. Donovan McNabb
24. Troy Aikman
23. Len Dawson
22. Ben Roethlisberger
21. Philip Rivers

Romo is 26 and Roman Gabriel is 28...I've said here a couple times that Romo is this era's Roman Gabriel and it appears fairly true :golfclap:

 

[ram29jackson]

20. Jim Kelly
19. Bart Starr
18. Joe Theismann
17. Terry Bradshaw
16. Kurt Warner
15. Dan Fouts
14. John Elway
13. Ken Anderson
12. Steve Young
11. Ken Stabler

 

[ram29jackson]

10. Warren Moon
9. Brett Favre
8. Fran Tarkenton
7. Johnny Unitas
6. Roger Staubach
5. Dan Marino
4. Drew Brees :irked: :nope:
3. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
1. Joe Montana

 

[buckeye]

Dilfer < Rodney Peete.... and you are saying he is Elite?!?! WTH are you smoking?!?!?

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

 

[ram29jackson]

Dilfer < Rodney Peete.... and you are saying he is Elite?!?! WTH are you smoking?!?!?

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

if you 100 out of the entire history of QBs, you are in fact elite :golfclap:

LOL Rodney Peete was only famous for his wife

 

[Tailback U]

I've said many times that Drew Brees is this era's Joe Montana, and it appears fairly true :golfclap:

 

[ThomasTomasz]

I feel that this thread should be locked for baiting/trolling

 

[buckeye]

And Dilfer according to the list... is his era's Rodney Peete Lol.

Elite my foot. You are crazy.

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

 

[seaplus]

all rams does now is troll :golfclap:

 

[ram29jackson]

footnote after this post season Manning now has more career playoff passing yards than Brady

 

[ram29jackson]

I feel that this thread should be locked for baiting/trolling

I didn't even notice Dilfers name till I was done making the thread. So of course I thought I would add a comment to the mix while editing.
But I could care less about Dilfer in this. This is about the top 20 and all the other interesting remembered names in the top 100

 

[ram29jackson]

And Dilfer according to the list... is his era's Rodney Peete Lol.

Elite my foot. You are crazy.

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk

where's Peete's Super Bowl ring ?

 

[Youk]

Kordell Stewart over David Carr? Now wait just a minute there. I would really flip the two, otherwise this list has no credibility.

 

[ram29jackson]

I've said many times that Drew Brees is this era's Joe Montana, and it appears fairly true :golfclap:

that one surprised me

 

[buckeye]

where's Peete's Super Bowl ring ?

So .... Jared Lorenzen is Elite too huh? He has a ring.

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk