Here is some stat lines for you to take a look at, you tell me which player you think gives you the best chance to win.
Carson Palmer
2005 - 32 TDs, 12 INTs, 3850 yards, 67% completed passes
2006 - 28 TDs, 13 INTs, 4100 yards, 63% completed passes
2007 - 26 TDs, 20 INTs, 4150 yards, 65% completed passes
2008 - Injure riddled season
Ryan Fitzpatrick
2008 - 8 TDs, 9INTs, 1,900 yards, 59% completed passes
I've done my research and I've heard you always talk about records and such and how certain quarterbacks are "losers"... look at Fitzpatrick last year, he was 4-7-1.
Palmer
2004 - 8-8
2005 - 11-5
2006 - 8-8
2007 - 7-9
2008 - 0-4(If you want to count last season)
34-34 all time record... he is not a terrible quarterback(record wise). Remember Bengals have been notorious for having a terrible defense which doesn't help any quarterback out. Fitzpatrick had a better defense than Palmer has ever had and he couldn't get anything done. The running game is usually at the bottom of the league and Palmer hasn't had a good offensive line since 2005.
I'm not saying that Carson Palmer is the best thing to ever hit the field... I'm really not. All I'm saying is Palmer is an upgrade over any QB they had last season. In my opinion, I think he is a talented QB that has the potential of carrying the Bengals, remember POTENTIAL... I'm not predicting him to do so.