People have been crying over the perception that 2k5 had 3 man tackles (it didn't), and they bitch and moan about EA's tackling system for ever, EA finally creates something that, you cannot deny, utterly destroys anything done in a football game to date, and of course you say I'm over hyping it.
Eat me. You haven't seen it in action, you've only seen the lame "everyone stand in a circle and stomp around a bit" crap that the marketing department decided to use, for god knows what reason.
I have taken Brandon Jacobs around the edge and saw a nice 190 lb DB to run over, only to have him hang on for dear life until a linebacker showed up to clean it up. I have driven toward the goalline knowing I'm going to bowl over those two guys at the line, only to have a third grab me from behind and pull me back and prevent the score.
Call me "overhyping' if you want, but at least wait until you've actually used it first. As far as I'm concerned, it's the biggest and most important innovation in football gaming history, by a very wide margin.
As for Madden 10 in general: I'll be very candid... while I love their passion and direction, I don't know if they've got the skills to finish it. They've bitten off far more than any previous Madden team has, and that's a testimate to their ambition of course, but will they be able to deliver in the time alotted is the question. I'm praying for a bug free game, but it's not going to happen. There's gonna end up being this glitch or that that screws things up. I'm just hoping to god it's not a game killer, but I am very concerned.
The difference is, if there is one, I'm fairly certain it'll be patched. These guys have some professional pride, and once we get our hands on it, it'll be Community Day times several hundred thousand. I look forward more to seeing this game in September than I do August.