What Should Colts Do With #1 Overall Pick?

[EmpireWF]

Do You:

1. Take Luck and have him sit.

2. Take Luck and rework Peyton's contract so they can trade the HOFer.

3. Trade the #1 overall pick?

 

[Houston]

Draft Luck and trade Manning, please.

 

[RainboUnicorn]

Trade the pick. With all the hype surrounding Luck this #1 pick is probably the most valuable in recent years. Draft a QB in the later rounds in another draft or maybe first round in a few years and let somebody else sit and learn from Peyton.

 

[Chrispy]

Trade it

 

[DoubleDeuce]

Either trade or sit Luck. Don't trade Manning, that's for sure.

 

[G-men]

Trade the pick for a ton of value in return. Take Matt Barkley next year.

 

[ralaw]

Trade the pick. With all the hype surrounding Luck this #1 pick is probably the most valuable in recent years. Draft a QB in the later rounds in another draft or maybe first round in a few years and let somebody else sit and learn from Peyton.

Agreed. At this point capitalize on the Luck hype and trade it. You don't need a once every 30 years prospect to win a championship.

 

[f16harm]

if you're talking logic, it's trade it. However, talking reality it is take Luck. Waaaaaay too much value is placed on the #1 pick nowadays and nobody wants to give up the ridiculous ransom teams would want for it.

 

[Houston]

If they want an eventual successor to Manning, then they should do whatever to get Matt Flynn.

 

[f16harm]

If they want an eventual successor to Manning, then they should do whatever to get Matt Flynn.

Matt Flynn is a free agent, and he's gonna get PAAAAIIIDDDD by someone to be there #1. You think He's going to choose the Colts if Manning is still playing a couple more years?????

 

[G-men]

If they want an eventual successor to Manning, then they should do whatever to get Matt Flynn.

Or just play the Lions defense every week.

 

[wr50l]

Whatever you do, don't pick yet another 1st round bust.

 

[Houston]

You think He's going to choose the Colts if Manning is still playing a couple more years?????

I over looked this.

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

houston is the master of subtlety, his unique brand of sarcasm has once again flew over the heads of many

 

[Bear Pand]

It depends entirely on Mannings health and Indy doesn't have enough information on that yet. We'll see how it looks closer to draft day.

If Manning is healthy then you trade the pick and try to put together more SB runs with him. I've heard reports that this pick is worth as much as 6 #1 picks. I think that's complete bullshit and won't happen but some team will overpay.

If Manning is not healthy and/or Indy doesn't believe they can win a SB in the next few years draft Luck. Try to trade or get rid of Manning if they can get something in return. Commit fully to rebuilding.

The only thing I'm opposed to is Indy trying to rebuild by drafting Luck and win a SB with Manning simultaneously. I think that's a waste of time.

 

[CrimsonGhost56]

colts would have to be insane to pass on Luck

 

[FirstTimer]

What can you get for the #1 pick?

 

[Aso]

I think the Colts should try to rebuild by drafting Luck and win a SB with Manning simultaneously.

:shifty:

 

[Bear Pand]

I think the Colts should try to rebuild by drafting Luck and win a SB with Manning simultaneously.

:shifty:

Pfft.

Most teams in the NFL aren't capable of rebuilding or contending. I really doubt Indy is going to be able to accomplish both at the same time.

 

[Leftwich]

Trade that pick for a kings ransom. I imagine a team like Miami would give up a first this year, first next year, second this year, fourth this year and probably a 2nd or 3rd next year. That's how you address multiple needs.