Statwise, Vick looked human. Gamewise, Vick's receivers dropped two/three wide open TD passes and were derping most of the game.
Sure, Eli's derp ended the game, but the Eagles were pretty much dominant through most of the game. Justin Tuck was the only real defensive force for the Giants in that game. Vick was due for a pedestrian game. This was it. But he's now 5-0 and outside of Jason Avant dropping passes and the O-Line having trouble blocking Tuck, the Eagles looked fine.
Even as a Giants fan, I've kinda' accepted that the Eagles will most likely win this division as long as Vick is upright. If Kolb is behind center, then the Eagles will fuck up.