Who would you take out of the following 3 QB's?

[Fox1994]

^He's on-record as saying "I just threw it up there". Tyree's out of a job, but who made that fucking catch?

Granted, much respect to Eli for that scramble. I thought he was sacked. But he got out of there...

 

I still think the Pats could've kicked a field goal if they hadn't been tryna hail-mary down the field. Oh well, FUCK BELICHICK AND BRADY!

 

[EmpireWF]

^He's on-record as saying "I just threw it up there". Tyree's out of a job, but who made that fucking catch?

Granted, much respect to Eli for that scramble. I thought he was sacked. But he got out of there...

 

I still think the Pats could've kicked a field goal if they hadn't been tryna hail-mary down the field. Oh well, FUCK BELICHICK AND BRADY!

Okay, but that's just one play on the big drive.

Eli has been one of the better 2-minute drill QBs in the league. I'm just saying, all things the same, I'd rather have the guy who's been in the big game and led his team to victory.

 

[Wildcard]

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sfb5tMBugbA"]YouTube- Plaxico Burress Super Bowl Winning Touchdown[/ame]

Because this pass was such a hard one to make.

How do you get that Wide Open?

 

[EmpireWF]

Guys are actually criticizing Manning for driving his team down the field and scoring the game winning TD?

Damn.

 

[SethMode]

I picked Romo, but LOL at "Because this pass was such a hard one to make."

Maybe we can ask Romo if that pass is easy if the Cowboys ever even make it that far.

 

[strahanfan92]

lol you guys are your damn rings.

You enjoy your guy with the career 79.2 QB rating, I'll take the one with the 86.5. Romo is a bitch, so I'm not grabbing him.

Career playoffs

Eli: 58% completion, 8 TD, 7 INT 77.6 QB rating
McNabb: 59% completion, 24 TD, 17 INT, 80.0 QB rating
Romo: 59% completion, 4 TD, 2 INT, 80.8 QB rating

Wait, does Eli get to bring Tuck and Osi with him?

Yeah how bout you try throwing the ball in the Meadowlands.. How bout ask Akers what its like to kick there..

Not to mention, QB rating is the worst stat in the game.

 

[FedEx227]

Better or worse than using a team accomplishment and attributing it to an individual player on one side of the ball?

 

[strahanfan92]

How can you possibly downplay throwing 1 interception in 4 playoff games (that wasn't even his fault) and leading a 4th quarter comeback in one of the greatest upsets of all time?

 

[Rayman]

How can you possibly downplay throwing 1 interception in 4 playoff games (that wasn't even his fault) and leading a 4th quarter comeback in one of the greatest upsets of all time?

Because it was a fluke?



*runs*

 

[strahanfan92]

*Call off the tanks

 

[EmpireWF]

If it's a team accomplishment, it doesn't matter which fucking QB then, does it?

Otherwise, take the one with the championship in his pocket

I can't argue if you say you'd want PManning, Brady, Brees or Big Ben above EManning, but McNabb and Romo? :runaway:

 

[SethMode]

If it's a team accomplishment, it doesn't matter which fucking QB then, does it?

Otherwise, take the one with the championship in his pocket

I can't argue if you say you'd want PManning, Brady, Brees or Big Ben above EManning, but McNabb and Romo? :runaway:

I don't know why it's ever still argued about, particularly when the speculation of how someone would do if he were on a different team comes into play. No offense but, it used to drive me crazy when people would say Eli > Big Ben because look at what Big Ben has around him. It's such a pointless argument that I believe is merely used because you can't defend against it because it's pure conjecture. It's using an imaginary situation to come up with an imaginary conclusion that meets your need. It's silly and it's being used here to a degree too. There is no evidence that McNabb or Romo could have led the Giants down the field in that situation, because Eli Manning was the QB of the Giants and neither of those guys ever did it in a SB on their respective teams either. I don't buy into the rings = greatness argument either, and as I said, I like Romo the best, but talking about the situation like any of them could have done it and using that as a knock on Eli is bad arguing/dumb.

 

[FedEx227]

I agree. I'm not using it as a knock.

What I'm trying to say is, if we're picking one of those three... I have to look at individual performance to decide who I'm going to pick. Even if Eli won a ring but has numbers that are noticeably worse than the other two, I'm going with the other two.

 

[ram29jackson]

why is Romo even involved in the topic? he may have decent stats but has accomplished nothing compared to the other 2.

all of that being said- I wouldnt mind the absurdity of Dallas making the push next year and playing a home field superbowl just to see it happen.

 

[NAHSTE]

I picked Romo, but LOL at "Because this pass was such a hard one to make."

Maybe we can ask Romo if that pass is easy if the Cowboys ever even make it that far.

Yeah, because this hold was so hard to make:

 

[Esjay]

I think Romo is better than them both, but I chose Eli because I've seen him do it before..

McNabb last.

 

[Rayman]

Yeah, because this hold was so hard to make:

58 posts.

Shocked it took that long.

 

[NAHSTE]

58 posts.

Shocked it took that long.

You don't think he asked for it by criticizing the game winning touchdown pass of the Super Bowl for being "too easy"?
:fencing:

 

[Rayman]

You don't think he asked for it by criticizing the game winning touchdown pass of the Super Bowl for being "too easy"?
:fencing:

Psh, I'm giving you and the others credit for restraining from doing it so far in.

 

[NAHSTE]

definataly eli manning because he coumes from a family of greatness. and hes a super bowl champion, won the same championships amount has his older prother peyton.

:bizzaro: