NFL's Top 100 Discussion

[Raidersabc123]

We could talk about anybody you want to talk about. Name somebody and lets discuss.

About time

[BigBucs]

Can we just stop talking about Freeman

Thank the haters. Cant blame me this time.

It was a statement only made to point out the obvious gigantic holes in his so called irrefutable evidence. His statement is basically that Freeman can't be on the top 100 list because 95%(bullshit) of the probowl roster is better than he is because Freeman didn't make the probowl. Which is complete horseshit because the probowl roster can only have 3 QBs, and Freeman had plenty of support for the probowl. And he must really suck at math because 95% of 39 = 37 players, and you can have another 37 from the AFC roster as well and that still leaves you with 12 players that didn't make the pro-bowl before Freeman. So if Freeman were close to making the probowl already, it wouldn't be a stretch to say he's 86th.

I know, you know and Im sure he knows but Senser is one of the biggest trolls on the site.

[Blick]

Warner said he could name 100 players he would rather have on his team than Freeman. It is idiotic to take that many players over a potential franchise QB in a league that shows you over and over how valuable it is to have a first round, blue chip talent at the most important position on the team.

[BigBucs]

Warner said he could name 100 players he would rather have on his team than Freeman. It is idiotic to take that many players over a potential franchise QB in a league that shows you over and over how valuable it is to have a first round, blue chip talent at the most important position on the team.

Ask him to name 100 players he would rather have on his team over Bradford.

[ram29jackson]

The list is pointless, you can change the bottom 60 to people who arent even on the list. Its just momentary arguments made for whomever comes to mind

[BigBucs]

The list is pointless, you can change the bottom 60 to people who arent even on the list. Its just momentary arguments made for whomever comes to mind

Thanks for the info.

[Blick]

It's a Josh Freeman highlight video. It's not like they'll show his bad points.

Alright Jon Gruden, give us your breakdown.

[Blick]

I'm not going to get into semantics and debate the merits of a G or ILB or FS vs. a QB.

Because you know that QB's are more valuable than any other position and it would make your claim look even more ridiculous.

[Shayn•Da•Pain]

Thank the haters. Cant blame me this time.



I know, you know and Im sure he knows but Senser is one of the biggest trolls on the site.

Oh I know, and I know you know now, and knowing is half the battle.

[Primetime]

Alright Jon Gruden, give us your breakdown.

Gruden's not a good example. He loves everyone. He'd tell you Charlie Sheen has all the tools to be a successful NFL QB if you gave him the time of day.

[Shayn•Da•Pain]

About time

Let's talk about Mike Williams at #83. Boy, he sure can catch a good Josh Freeman pass can't he? :smug2:

[Sven Draconian]

Warner said he could name 100 players he would rather have on his team than Freeman. It is idiotic to take that many players over a potential franchise QB in a league that shows you over and over how valuable it is to have a first round, blue chip talent at the most important position on the team.

...which does not make a QB a better player.

Value =/= skill.

This is the basic issue with any of these lifts. There are 5 offensive lineman starting for every team, every weeek. There is 1 QB. Any logical, rational list should have damn near that same 5:1 ratio for lineman to QBs.

Looked at from a different perspective, as there are 22 starters you would expect each position to have around 4 representatives, with a few left over spots.

So, is Freeman a top 5 (I'll even give it 6) QB?
In no particular order:
Rodgers
Brees
Brady
Peyton
Rivers
Ryan
Rothlesburger
Vick???

He hasn't done anything to seperate himeslf from the Sanchez or Flacco. It's tough to even put him over a guy like Eli. Just off stats, he's right with Schaub and Orton.

Freeman is somewhere on the fringe of the top 10. Putting him right on par with a top 20 CB, top 30 LB, top 20 DE, top 30 WR, top 10 RB, top 10 center ect ect.

Putting him rihgt on the fringe of the top 200 players. Since the AFC>NFC, I think it's pretty fair to say that he is on the outside looking in on the top 100 NFC players.

[Champ]

Eli is top 10 ^^

[Primetime]

Eli is the 3rd best QB in his division.

[Champ]

Eli is the 3rd best QB in his division.

Haha.