DRAMA!!! Wildcards Top 10 QBs

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

Tony Romo @ #7?

smh.

He is a bottom half QB.

 

[Nukleopatra]

Brees threw for 315 and put up I'm not gonna look it up right now, but it was around 20 more points than Warner did. With a worse surrounding team too..

Warner played against a healthy Donovan McNabb, in a postseason game.. When Drew Brees can play like that, in that type of atmosphere, get back to me.

When Brees passes Warner in most 300 yard games, or even yards thrown, you can talk.

Until then, he's just another half assed stat padder.

Kurt Warner leads him in just about every category, but I'm sure you'll hear all about his stats, and postseason succes during the hall of fame ceremony. Lol @ comparing the two..

Let's compare Joe Montana and Carson Palmer next, please?

 

[Archer]

Anybody see Manning last night ? With a defense that allowed 200+ rush yards ..... Saints D is alot worse than that right? I could have sworn Manning came from behind in the 4th AGAIN (36th of his Colts career)

If only he had the supporting cast Brees had on D it would have been over by half time right? You know seeing as the Saints forced 2-3 turnovers v the Eagles and the Colts forced 0?

Yeah ....... that's how you win a game with or without a supporting cast on D

 

[steeljake]

Warner played against a healthy Donovan McNabb, in a postseason game.. When Drew Brees can play like that, in that type of atmosphere, get back to me.

When Brees passes Warner in most 300 yard games, or even yards thrown, you can talk.

Until then, he's just another half assed stat padder.

Kurt Warner leads him in just about every category, but I'm sure you'll hear all about his stats, and postseason succes during the hall of fame ceremony. Lol @ comparing the two..

Let's compare Joe Montana and Carson Palmer next, please?

lol... i tried to warn the dude...

peyton manning is the GOAT btw. the jets blitz made brady look like a bitch and when teh phins blitzed, peyton torched that ass.

 

[mgoblue2290]

Brees does it again and lifts the Saints to another win. Such a shitty defense too. He's a top 3 QB in the league, you have to be extremely biased against him not to think so...

1) Manning
2) Brees
3) Brady

Who really cares about the rest?

Brees over Brady? You must be out of your damn mind.

 

[Nukleopatra]

Maybe when Drew Brees gets a supporting cast of guys like Larry Fitz, Anquan Boldin, Steve Breaston, Issac Bruce, Torry Holt, etc, then he'll be smashing those numbers.
.

Well, since you brought up such an original argument.........

:crazy:

 

[Derrville]

Whats wrong with Colston, Bush, Henderson, Meachem and Shockey? Their all really solid Football players and a nice Supporting cast imo.

 

[Archer]

For the 10000000th time, everyone has Manning #1. Nobody is comparing Brees to Manning...

Decent ranking.

Only 2 problems:

1.) Top 3 should've been Brady, then Brees, then Manning.
2.) Romo shouldn't be ranked ahead of Big Ben

Yeah move the fuck along please

 

[Nukleopatra]

Whats wrong with Colston, Bush, Henderson, Meachem and Shockey? Their all really solid Football players and a nice Supporting cast imo.

Or even LT, Turner, Gates.....

Same argument will go on and on... The weapons made Warner what he is. While every person on any team Brees has been on, will continue to hold him back.

Philip Rivers has a couple playoff victories with those weapons, after Brees got the boot.. One of those seasons, he had a worse defense than Brees did. Goes to show what a true leader can overcome.

 

[KoRnStARr]

lol... i tried to warn the dude...

peyton manning is the GOAT btw. the jets blitz made brady look like a bitch and when teh phins blitzed, peyton torched that ass.

Are you a moron?

Have you seen Peyton against the 3-4 at all in his career?

So because he played the Dolphins and they blitzed, that means he's now a better QB against the blitz?

 

[Archer]

Are you a moron?

Have you seen Peyton against the 3-4 at all in his career?

So because he played the Dolphins and they blitzed, that means he's now a better QB against the blitz?

I guess he got his 3 mvps , 9 pro bowls and 33 4th qtr career comebacks from just playing 4-3s every year lol

Remind me , who won between Indy and Pitt/Baltimore last year?

Baltimore 3 - 31 Colts - Manning 19/28 271yards 3td 0int

This v the second best defense in the NFL last year


Pats 15 - 18 Colts - Manning 21/29 254yards 2tds 0int

Colts 24-20 Steelers - Manning 21/40 240yards 3tds 0int

V the best D in the league

Colts 23 - 20 Bolts (reg season) - Manning 32/44 255yards 2tds 1int

"Manning comes up huge on a 4th and one pass to Marvin Harrison leading to a walk off Feild Goal"

Colts lose in Divisional Game - Manning 25/42 310yards 1td 0int

Yeah because our inability to get off the fucking feild had NOTHING to do with that loss


Please let me know when you have shut the fuck up

 

[bucky]

Please let me know when you have shut the fuck up

If he "shut the fuck up", then how can he let you know?

 

[Archer]

If he "shut the fuck up", then how can he let you know?

Quality point

 

[KoRnStARr]

I guess he got his 3 mvps , 9 pro bowls and 33 4th qtr career comebacks from just playing 4-3s every year lol

Remind me , who won between Indy and Pitt/Baltimore last year?

Baltimore 3 - 31 Colts - Manning 19/28 271yards 3td 0int

This v the second best defense in the NFL last year


Pats 15 - 18 Colts - Manning 21/29 254yards 2tds 0int

Colts 24-20 Steelers - Manning 21/40 240yards 3tds 0int

V the best D in the league

Colts 23 - 20 Bolts (reg season) - Manning 32/44 255yards 2tds 1int

"Manning comes up huge on a 4th and one pass to Marvin Harrison leading to a walk off Feild Goal"

Colts lose in Divisional Game - Manning 25/42 310yards 1td 0int

Yeah because our inability to get off the fucking feild had NOTHING to do with that loss


Please let me know when you have shut the fuck up

Ah yes, regular season stats. Gotta love Manning lovers.

Manning's an incredible QB, don't get me wrong. But he's struggled against the 3-4 his entire career, mainly in the post-season and has been known to be Manning's biggest kryptonite.

Are you really trying to stake a claim for Peyton that he played good against the Chargers, or Steelers in the playoffs in 2005 and last year? LOL!

 

[Bear Pand]

Kornstar hates on anything colts, no point even debating him.

 

[KoRnStARr]

Kornstar hates on anything colts, no point even debating him.

Not true!

 

[Archer]

Ah yes, regular season stats. Gotta love Manning lovers.

Manning's an incredible QB, don't get me wrong. But he's struggled against the 3-4 his entire career, mainly in the post-season and has been known to be Manning's biggest kryptonite.

Are you really trying to stake a claim for Peyton that he played good against the Chargers, or Steelers in the playoffs in 2005 and last year? LOL!

Manning did above average v the Chargers last season in the post-season . Our inability to stop 3rd downs (they completed over 70%) and Scrifes punting us down into our 10 all game were the biggest problems

Then even after that we had to sit through 3 bs penalties in over time . I am sorry , I pressumed a career = regular season AND the playoffs . How about we stop talking about 05 and start talking about recent times . And if you look at last seasons stats (reg season and non reg season) Manning did just fine

We really want to talk about struggling qbs in the past?

Talk a look at your qbs 13 P/R in the biggest game of them all please ..... I know though if that was Manning having a 13 p/r (or w/e it was) we would have lost 35-0 and he would have been labelled a horrible qb

Have you ever stopped to think that the Ds Manning struggled against (Pats , Steelers , bolts) were just really good ds at the time? and even then he beat all of them last season and beat the Pats in the sb season .

 

[KoRnStARr]

Manning did average or slightly above v the Chargers last season . Our inability to stop 3rd downs (they completed over 70%) and Scrifes punting us down into our 10 all game were the biggest problems

Then even after that we had to sit through 3 bs penalties in over time . I am sorry , I pressumed a career = regular season AND the playoffs . How about we stop talking about 05 and start talking about recent times . And if you look at last seasons stats (reg season and non reg season) Manning did just fine

We want to talk about struggling qbs?

Talk a look at your qbs 13 P/R in the biggest game of them all please ..... I know though if that was Manning having a 13 p/r (or w/e it was) we would have lost 35-0 and he would have been labelled a horrible qb

Have you ever stopped to think that the Ds Manning struggled against (Pats , Steelers , bolts) were just really good ds at the time? and even then he beat all of them last season and beat the Pats in the sb season .

The Manning led Colts offense scored 17 points in a PLAYOFF game against the 32nd ranked pass D in the NFL. Yeah, the punter put you guys in shitty situations. But in the playoffs you must overcome. Which Peyton has failed at frequently, as his playoff record indicates with a 7-8 W/L record.

If you think Peyton played good against the Chargers in the playoffs last year, then you're truly a homer or a guy who looked strictly at the player stat sheet. Quit blaming the D, when they had multiple stops on the Chargers the entire game -- the offense didn't help them out any with their inability to sustain drives.

And are you suggesting the Chargers D was a great D last year? I'm going to let you think about what you just insinuated before even responding to that...

 

[Bear Pand]

What's the point in bringing up someone's playoff record?

Big Ben played terrible against the Seahawks in the Super Bowl and got a W.

It's a team game, there's been countless times when a kicker, a Nick Harper, or some other retard has contributed to the Colts losing more than Manning.

Chagers' D wasn't that bad last year after they switched D coordinators or whatever they did, and they have some nice corners. Don't get at archer for bringing up regular season stats, then bring up the Chargers' regular season defensive stats to evaluate how they played in the postseason.

 

[Archer]

The Manning led Colts offense scored 17 points in a PLAYOFF game against the 32nd ranked pass D in the NFL. Yeah, the punter put you guys in shitty situations. But in the playoffs you must overcome. Which Peyton has failed at frequently, as his playoff record indicates with a 7-8 W/L record.

If you think Peyton played good against the Chargers in the playoffs last year, then you're truly a homer or a guy who looked strictly at the player stat sheet. Quit blaming the D, when they had multiple stops on the Chargers the entire game -- the offense didn't help them out any with their inability to sustain drives.

And are you suggesting the Chargers D was a great D last year? I'm going to let you think about what you just insinuated before even responding to that...

The Chargers D was in the top 15 after Rivera took over (week 10) so that 32nd ranked pass D is a pointless stat . And no I was saying the Chargers D in past years has been good , not neccisarly last season .

The Defense struggled to get off the feild in key 3rd down situations , I won't say it was all their fault but Manning played slightly above average on the night .

It's a shame Manning can't afford a 13 p/r and have his team still win I guess :bizzaro: