Dusty Diamond All Star Softball.
FUCKING. AWESOME.
Under the radar game, but it was great. I remember all the players...Louis, the stereotypical fast black guy. I always put him in CF and batted him leadoff. Diablo, the power hitter who looked like a devil. Wendy, the witch who hit with a broomstick. I can go on and on. Great game, tons of strategy when picking your team and setting the lineup/positions. Every player had strengths and weaknesses.