I agree about the penalty thing, but I don't think the positives - and there are many - of this game shouldn't be tossed aside as "crap EA football."
This is, by far, their best next-gen football game. For the first time in years, I am actually having fun playing an EA football game.
If Madden is this good, I could see myself playing multiple seasons of dynasty.
Please Madden ... be this good.