They should rename this show to "Holy Fuck, Did That Just Happen?!" It's much more fitting.
Also, I'm getting pretty pissed off at all of these "All questions will finally be answered" previews. I have more fucking questions in those first two hours than I did in the entire previous five seasons.
Now, to my thoughts:
1. The bomb...I think it goes off and doesn't at the same time. In the parallel universe, it goes off and everything takes a different tangent hence the flash sideways. In the other reality, it only sends the guys back to their current time. So, everything still happens as it did in the show.
2. Hmmm...my first thoughts were Sayid was being controlled by smoke monster, but Jacob is a damn good theory too, especially considering the fact that the ash has been thrown, and all defenses are up, so smokey shouldn't be able to get into the temple. Perhaps this is why Jacob had Hurley bring Sayid to the temple. So he could inhabit Sayid's body under the protection of his peopel.
I think he [Jacob] intervenes at the most drastic times, such as when Locke fell out of the window, or Sayid was about to get run over, but Nadia got hit.
Tonight, I actually noticed that with every single one of them, Jacob actually comes into physical contact with. He touches Kate's nose, holds hands with Jin and Sun, touches Locke and wakes him up, hands Jack the candy and brushes his finger. Maybe he somehow gives them a special protection at that point to get them safely to the island when the plane crashed.
now wondering, if that temple has been there the whole time, since they first episode when they crashed. Its almost like the wall is so high, you just can't see the temple. Lot of my friends are wondering if those people are from the Black Rock.
The temple has obviously been there for a long time. The smoke monster lives underneath it, to be close at hand to kill all those fuckers if Jacob's protection every gives up. Plus, that's where they took little Ben when he got shot. He was put in that pool, and revived.
I think it was interesting that The Man in the Black mentioned Richard looked different w/o chains. Not sure if he meant literally or theoretically, that he killed Jacob and is not under his command anymore.
Richard has been shown before in earlier flashes bound in chains...the theory that he was a slave on the Black Rock is a good one, probably true. And he's just been living ever since, protected by Jacob, and not aging.
-First off I do not think Sayid is Jacob. If you notice Smokey can only replicate people who's dead bodies are on the island, i.e. Eko's brother, Jack's dad (maybe), and Locke. Even though Locke is walking around the island Locke's dead body is still there. Sayid rose from the Dead, which something new on LOST, if and only if Christan Shepard ends up being smoky and not a Zombie.
Wait...what? Sayid's dead body is on the island, so if we assume Jacob has the same powers as smokey, then this is certainly possible. Also, smokey doesn't just replicate, he retains all memories. Remember that smokey told Ben the last thought running through Locke's head when he died.
If you notice the Others made a comment about the Temple water "not being clear" and then the guy the Last Samurai goes and cuts his hand and dips it in the water. I think the water is the fountain of youth and is suppose to heal, but for what ever reason (unknown at this point) it's not working the same way. The Others looked just as surprised as the 815ers when Sayid rose from the dead.
Indeed...I think back to when Locke "rises from the dead" in season five, and Ben tells Sun, "I've seen a lot of things on this island. But dead is dead." For this reason, I think Sayid is dead, so he's either smokey or Jacob now. Yeah, pretty straightforward on the water...changes color, and it's not working, but they try anyway and it doesn't save Sayid. I think Jacob's death took away it's healing powers.
This is where it gets tricky to understands though. IMO I understood it as Jack's plan worked and he did prevent the plane from crashing which intern created a Parrnell universe which is depicted from the "Flashsidways" we are seeing. Think about it we had flashbacks and flashforwards and now flashsideways. Even though both Parrnell universes have the same people it's not exactly the same because it can't be. If they never land on the island Jack never throws the bomb down the hole because he was never in 1974. Because he was never in 1974 the magnetic anomaly goes off and sinks the island. If you look closely at the beginning when we see the island under water there is clues to suggest this true. Dharmaville is there and the statue is just a foot. Dharmaville was constructed in the early 70's to late 60's so we know the island got at least that far in time.
Here's how I see it. Everything from the beginning of time right up until the bomb incident is exactly the same in both universes. Remember that while the Lost guys are in Dharma's past, it's actually their present-tense. Anyway, so is parallel universe, the island sinks from the bomb, everything keeps going and going. The world continues. In island universe, they are simply transported back to present tense, and life continues like it was in the first five seasons. What I'm trying to say is that Jack never has to go to the island in order to go to the past in order to set off the bomb because that happens in Lost universe, and now Jack Part 2 exists in parallel universe. So his life isn't altered by that.
The thing I have a hard time with is if they blow up the future, how is Locke still alive in parallel universe? Didn't Jacob heal him when he fell out of that window? How can that happen in parallel universe if the island is gone? Or perhaps my other theory is right in that Jacob never actually heals Locke...he just marks him, and gives him protection so that he may reach the island.
Basically Miles was right, Jack was the incident. If Jack did nothing then the Swan hatch would have never been constructed and the island would have been sucked underwater by the magnetic anomaly as depicted in the Flashsideways at the begging.
Eh, don't agree with that. The bomb caused the island to sink. Basically, I think what happens is at that point, the island sinks in one reality. But in the other reality, all those guys just disappear, and the Dharma folks keep going on about their hatch business.