NFL - Who is the better quarterback?

[Rayman]

Hilarious.

First of all, I'll check again, but I highly doubt VSN is comprised of any of the 32 head coaches or GMs you mentioned before, so this thread was moot the second you thought of it.

Second, of the members of this board that are NOT Cowboy fans, a good 99% of them hate the team with a burning passion. It's an absolute no-brainer who this group of people would pick.

What you SHOULD have done was this.

QB A's career stats

726/1136 8801 yds 63.9% 7.75YPA 59TD 21INT 93 sacks 97.2 RTG 17-15 record

QB B's career stats

1178/1857 15045 yds 63.4% 8.10YPA 107TD 55INT 99 sacks 95.6 RTG 38-17 record

Then add that QB A took over a team that had just hosted a conference championship while QB B took over a team that was 3-3 and headed toward the shitter in mid-season.


All you've done is prove my point that because Romo plays for that team in Texas, he will never get the respect he's earned.

"B-b-b-but, he doesn't take the game seriously! He'd rather date blonde celebrities! He fumbled the field goal, so he sucks!"

I've never heard so much nonsense about any athlete in my life.

Frankly, I'm sick of arguing about it when every time I try to have a rational discussion about it, the response is this;

Yeah, I'm posting it before any of you can. Come up with something else. :smug:

 

[dave]

Just vote.

 

[Fappin Raptor]

I have nothing against the Cowboys. Packers also are an in-division rival to my hometown team. My vote was for Rodgers.

 

[Rayman]

Just vote.

Why? I already know what the results are going to be and I refuse to validate it to begin with.

Or did you not read what I wrote?

 

[WalkMan]

Aaron Rodgers all day man

 

[Fox1994]

Rodgers. But, in my opinion, it's super-close. I'm basing this entirely off of having seen the QB duel with Kurt, BUT, maybe that's not even legitimate because he did overthrow a receiver on the second-to-last play of the game, which would have been a game-winning TD to change the playoff picture.

Their stats are extremely similar, and I sympathize with RayMan having to defend his team. Personally, I don't hate the Cowboys. :2thumbs: If that's any consolation... But I do hate the frontrunner/bandwagon groupies.

 

[citizenerased]

Hilarious.

First of all, I'll check again, but I highly doubt VSN is comprised of any of the 32 head coaches or GMs you mentioned before, so this thread was moot the second you thought of it.

Second, of the members of this board that are NOT Cowboy fans, a good 99% of them hate the team with a burning passion. It's an absolute no-brainer who this group of people would pick.

What you SHOULD have done was this.

QB A's career stats

726/1136 8801 yds 63.9% 7.75YPA 59TD 21INT 93 sacks 97.2 RTG 17-15 record

QB B's career stats

1178/1857 15045 yds 63.4% 8.10YPA 107TD 55INT 99 sacks 95.6 RTG 38-17 record

Then add that QB A took over a team that had just hosted a conference championship while QB B took over a team that was 3-3 and headed toward the shitter in mid-season.


All you've done is prove my point that because Romo plays for that team in Texas, he will never get the respect he's earned.

"B-b-b-but, he doesn't take the game seriously! He'd rather date blonde celebrities! He fumbled the field goal, so he sucks!"

I've never heard so much nonsense about any athlete in my life.

Frankly, I'm sick of arguing about it when every time I try to have a rational discussion about it, the response is this;

Yeah, I'm posting it before any of you can. Come up with something else. :smug:

Was no worse then :

 

[Rayman]

Was no worse then :

One would think, but that apparently isn't the case.

 

[~Chance~]

Romo has NEVER won a playoff game. So he sucks.

 

[Anthony]

Neither. Colt Brennan.

 

[Cody]

Rodgers over the last two years.

 

[Anthony]

Romo has NEVER won a playoff game. So he sucks.

January 9, 2010: NFC Wildcard PLAYOFF Game

Cowboys 34 - Eagles 14





And in other news. You're still retarded.

 

[FirstTimer]

Rodgers....easily.

 

[Woy]

Vince Young.

 

[Primetime]

Aaron to Driver.....Rodger that.

Romo is a homo, and homo's don't make good quarterbacks.

 

[KINGOFOOTBALL]

I said "too close to call" with the Brees/Romo poll. So what the hell do I know.

Romo is hindered by a dumbass coordinator and avg pass blocking line.

Maybe I dont watch enough but GB "weapons" never seem entirely consistent.

As other said both are about equal and are hovering in the 4-6 spots.

 

[Carlos]

I said "too close to call" with the Brees/Romo poll. So what the hell do I know.

Romo is hindered by a dumbass coordinator and avg pass blocking line.

Maybe I dont watch enough but GB "weapons" never seem entirely consistent.

As other said both are about equal and are hovering in the 4-6 spots.

THANK YOU!

Romo > Rodgers as of right now. After this year, it might be a different story. I really hope not though.

 

[Boss AZ]

What do you expect Cowboys fans to say? :smh:

 

[Leftwich]

I have to go with Romo. Rodgers has been a starting QB for 2 seasons while Romo has more on him. I think both of them will have Superbowl rings before their careers are over but Romo has shown me more based on the fact that hes been starting longer.

 

[dboy_dc]

well I'm a long time Cowboys fan... before Aikman got there long....

I'd go Romo, why well stats. In the couple of meetings Romo had with Rodgers Romo shines. Rodgers came through on that last game they played but that's neither here or there. Rodgers is a very very good QB. If i wasnt a Dallas fan it'll be the samething. People talk playoffs and superbowls, but really if those 52 other guys dont do their job, it's kind of hard to win anything. just saying.